2 ms·
The article makes clear that it isn't about a solution for everybody and it sounds like this is a form of assisted living, like I was describing. I didn't see
by perl4ever 7y ago
The article makes clear that it isn't about a solution for everybody and it sounds like this is a form of assisted living, like I was describing.
I didn't see where the costs are stated, so are you implying that it is vastly less expensive than my estimate?
"When we comb through and we're picking out three people from this list of 86," Austin says, "it does kind of suck to know that we left 83 people on that list that don't have an option"
Just as it has always been, there are people who are privileged to be helped and those who are not:
"Austin notes they need a candidate who is male and "plays semi-nice with others.""
- ceejayoz 7y ago> I didn't see where the costs are stated, so are you implying that it is vastly less expensive than my estimate? The article briefly mentions the enormous costs of having people on the streets, in ER visits and jail, and indicates that housing is cheaper. More specific numbers here from a different test: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/02/housing-first-solution-to-homelessness-utah/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2015/02/housing-first-s... "Denver found that emergency-service costs alone went down 73 percent for people put in Housing First, for a savings of $31,545 per person; detox visits went down 82 percent, for an additional savings of $8,732." > Just as it has always been, there are people who are privileged to be helped and those who are not. You're really misreading that portion of the article. It's discussing a particular opening, and how they slot people into them. Overall numbers for the program are available elsewhere in the article: "By implementing a model known as Housing First, Utah has reduced that number from nearly 2,000 people in 2005, to fewer than 200 now."
- perl4ever 7y agoCan you provide an alternative estimate of the (net) cost, and break down the reasons why it differs from mine? And I mean, not precisely at all of course, but in a logical manner. One significant figure seems appropriate. As far as how many people are helped, or what percentage, maybe Utah has eliminated homelessness. That was an article from 2015; a follow-up might be informative. In general, I'm really skeptical of solutions to difficult problems described by journalists, because I expect the key is always going to be redefining the boundaries of the problem. How much cutting edge research on cancer do you read about, and yet, when it came down to it, someone I knew got Gemzar and Abraxane and blood transfusions, and then she died.
- ceejayoz 7y agoSure, that's easy: Your napkin math ignores the fact that the homeless already have significant costs, like shelters, ER visits, law enforcement, and the like. The findings thus far from housing-first policies appear to indicate that subsidizing housing for chronically homeless reduces these costs dramatically; likely because some of them stem simply from being homeless, and others (like PTSD therapy) are easier to coordinate access to when you're not on the streets. It's like the criticisms of Medicare for All that claim "oh, we'd have to raise taxes by $X" while ignoring the fact that the current system isn't free. (Also, my reading of the Utah program is that the housing is substantially lower than the $4k/month you cite. Outside of NYC/SF sort of places, a studio apartment can be had for well under $800.)