4 ms·
[citation needed] Eliminating any motivation to perform well is of course going to discourage people who try harder for rewards. That’s basic economics. Claim
by kortilla 7y ago
[citation needed]
Eliminating any motivation to perform well is of course going to discourage people who try harder for rewards. That’s basic economics.
Claiming that the top performers will continue to innovate and lead when they are compensated the same as the bare minimum clock punchers is extraordinary and requires evidence.
About the only place where unions are better (at least the salary negotiating US style ones) are jobs where innovation and efficiency are irrelevant.
- turtlecloud 7y agoWith UBI that should remove the lazy ones who are stuck in those type of positions.
- ci5er 7y agoSociety pays for those who won't work? Nice promo material!
- cortesoft 7y agoWe pay for them in some way or the other... they either are on public assistance or end up in jail. We pay either way.
- ci5er 7y agoYou have a preference?
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoOr we could do neither...q
- kortilla 7y agoNo, UBI is paying for people who already work and receive nothing. We’re not “paying either way”.
- taneq 7y agoProbably better that society pays them to sit on the couch at home than that we force them to pollute workplaces that would otherwise get more and higher quality work done.
- zaroth 7y agoWhy? When they can pocket the UBI and also get paid to fuck around and be protected from getting fired? More generally, UBI cannot possibly solve for a scenario where people are being dramatically overpaid and there’s no way to correct it.
- fzeroracer 7y agoThere's already no motivation to 'perform well' because promotions don't mean shit nowadays. You can perform better than the rest of your entire company and get a 1% raise as a show of kindness along with maybe a new $50 coffee machine gift. It's common knowledge in the software industry that the best way to advance is to hop jobs every two or so years. Do you think it's because of the non-existent unions, or because of corporations underpaying employees because they know they can get away with it?
- austhrow743 7y agoYou know this is about Google right?
- fzeroracer 7y agoNo, you're wrong on two accounts. First, this argument chain is about unions in general. Please read up on the full response chain to understand the context of my response, starting with stjohnswarts. Second, this thread and story is not about Google. It's about Google's contractors. There's a very important distinction there, because contractors are often treated worse both by the companies they're working under as well as the contracted companies they're working with. Google might treat its own employees better (although the jury is still out on that with many stories alleging discrimination in terms of pay and what not) but this story is obstensibly about the anti-union behavior occurring at companies Google is partnered with.
- privateSFacct 7y agoFalse. There are contractors to google making a killing - seriously - if you own your own business or provide a service to google you can make bank. One example -> some of the employee / teambuilding / staff appreciation stuff. If the google FTE's like doing your teambuilding program google is absolutely happy to pay for it. I know some other direct contract work with google - generally don't fight on price but their focus was on quality. I'd like to hear some firsthand experiences of direct contractors working for google (ie, google 1099's) getting badly treated because that wasn't what I saw.
- LaGrange 7y ago> That’s basic economics. Oh really. Because to me it sounds like a statement about human motivation patterns, and some huge assumptions about it that are, quite often, wrong. Just like cats, humans can be motivated by: * food (or food-equivalents in the form of flipping some bits in a bank) * social interaction (60% of cats as long as not starved!) ...also, unlike cats (AFAIK), but very frequently (also AFAIK) humans can be motivated by: * self-expression * perceived benefit to society. If not for the need for self-expression, there would be barely anyone working in the games industry. And pretty much every company's internal relations spew more-or-less thinly veiled nonsense about how spying on customers is good - or at least acceptable - actually. That's because the last part is an _enormous_ part of motivation for many. > Claiming that the top performers will continue to innovate and lead when they are compensated the same as the bare minimum clock punchers is extraordinary and requires evidence. ...except non-unionised companies often tolerate bare minimum clock punchers, and, conversely, unions often penalise those. Good relationship with management can easily allow slacking, and unions have more interest in company's survival than some nomadic C-level. You're making things up and then demanding others to provide evidence. Some of us actually worked in an office for more than a day, you know.
- kortilla 7y ago>Because to me it sounds like a statement about human motivation patterns Lol. I think you need to look up what the study of economics is.