5 ms·
On average unions work better for the most people. People on the upper end will not stop contributing or trying, people on the lower end don't matter much anywa
by stjohnswarts 7y ago
On average unions work better for the most people. People on the upper end will not stop contributing or trying, people on the lower end don't matter much anyway. It's the middle that provides most of the advancement.
- whiddershins 7y agoSource?
- privateSFacct 7y agoAt least two other data points - I have a friend who worked in a govt agency - doing cool and important work - she left because of the unfirable lifers - while the stories are funny you can’t go to work and perform well in that situation. In high school teacher X was notorious for giving no work and no s*its. He missed lots of his classes so always subs. We thought it was cool (usually easy A). He was there years but my senior year he must have done something way over the line because he was fired midday. Amazingly the gossip never figured out what he did (despite kids w parents on school board)
- dlp211 7y agoThose are nice anecdotes, the data says otherwise. There will always be slackers, they exist in every job and industry.
- vondur 7y agoI’ll admit there’s always slackers in any workplace, but what data are you referring to?
- kortilla 7y ago[citation needed] Eliminating any motivation to perform well is of course going to discourage people who try harder for rewards. That’s basic economics. Claiming that the top performers will continue to innovate and lead when they are compensated the same as the bare minimum clock punchers is extraordinary and requires evidence. About the only place where unions are better (at least the salary negotiating US style ones) are jobs where innovation and efficiency are irrelevant.
- turtlecloud 7y agoWith UBI that should remove the lazy ones who are stuck in those type of positions.
- ci5er 7y agoSociety pays for those who won't work? Nice promo material!
- cortesoft 7y agoWe pay for them in some way or the other... they either are on public assistance or end up in jail. We pay either way.
- ci5er 7y agoYou have a preference?
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoOr we could do neither...q
- kortilla 7y agoNo, UBI is paying for people who already work and receive nothing. We’re not “paying either way”.
- privateSFacct 7y agoI'd be interested in that data - I have colleagues with wives / husbands doing union shift work - even if you are 100% gung-ho it seems to be 100% seniority based still or has that changed? Things like UBI, higher minimum wage, reduce exempt classification loopholes etc all seem like ways that rules could change to benefit everyone. I would LOVE to see the data that says a seniority based union system results in better retention of high performers and their continued push to perform well.
- thomasmeeks 7y agoUnions aren't perfect, so take care to not scrap your car because it has a dent. https://www.google.com/search?q=do+unions+benefit+employees+data https://www.google.com/search?q=do+unions+benefit+employees+... First two links have loads of commentary with citations. There's plenty of books on the subject, as well, if you're interested. Amazon is a good place to look for them.
- linuxdude314 7y agoThe union I have experience with (Sound Engineers union in Burbank) was nothing but a complete pain. The union admits members based on nepotism (friends and family only essentially) and the work they did was always second tier in comparison to the non covered studio engineering team. I was on a systems engineering team at this studio, and our union counter parts were nothing but incompetent pains in the ass. Unions don’t have to be this way, and I think they serve an important roll, but people should really be careful what they are asking for as the results might not be what are expected.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shitgoose 7y agothere will be way more slackers in a job-secure environment, where workers have 0 motivation to do anything.
- whenanother 7y agofunny how your are referring a technically government job and conflating it with corporate jobs. completely different set of politics involved. what is great is that the notion of engineers being above unionization is a ruse that has been clearly put to bed. also it is not yours or mine concern as to whether or not corporations are operating efficiently.
- MiroF 7y agoAnecdotes don't gain rhetorical force by calling them "data points"
- vidarh 7y agoMeanwhile things like the 8 hour working day was a result of decades of union efforts - much of which was met with open violence. Unions can go too far in supporting people who should not be protected,but a large part of the reason they do is that they came into existence at a time when employers literally were prepared to see workers die to protect their ability to mistreat people. Unions tends to take softer stances e.g. in parts of Europe where their level of involvement in decision-making means the hard-line stances are no longer seen as necessary.
- andrepd 7y agoCool, you have two stories of slackers on a job. What relevance does that have to the discussion?
- privateSFacct 7y agoI was responding to this claim about seniority based unionized workforces "People on the upper end will not stop contributing or trying". I was interested in the citation for this given the anecdotal info I had which involved high performing folks trying to find more rewarding work elsewhere.
- LanceH 7y agoWhat about the people who won't be hired at all because of a union? How does the union work out for them?
- Consultant32452 7y agoThe primary mechanism of power used by unions to keep wages high is by reducing the available work force. This is done by lobbying for things like requiring certifications to be legally allowed to perform work and lobbying/negotiating for disallowing non-union members from accepting work. This has the net effect of increasing the wages of the high paid workers while reducing the wages of the low paid workers who could do the higher paid work but aren't allowed to. Here's Nobel economist Milton Friedman discussing it in more detail. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzYgiOC9cj4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzYgiOC9cj4