5 ms·
> [C++] is high performance, and it offers but features I don't want, and at a great complexity cost. 1. Complexity of implementation is not complexity of use.
by einpoklum 7y ago
> [C++] is high performance, and it offers but features I don't want, and at a great complexity cost.
1. Complexity of implementation is not complexity of use. Example: Take std::array vs a plain C array. std::array is a few hundreds of lines of code. But - it's about as inutitive to use; has more convenience features; easier for the compiler to optimize; and doesn't let you should yourself in the foot that easily.
2. If Whiting don't want _any_ of the features of C++ - his software-writing skills are suspect. Now, few people need or want all of C++'s features - but C's are definitely insufficient, especially if you consider both the langauge and some of the standard library (or non-standard common libraries).
3. The complexity you have to tackle with C++ is lower than the complexity of non-standardized often-inconsistent idiosyncratic platforms and libraries for achieving the same things with C (or C + assembly).
So I find Whiting's argument for C over C++ unconvincing. IMHO C++ would be the least-bad language for writing demanding games in.
- seamyb88 7y agoSome people just like writing code. You can't say that C's features are insufficient, when you can implement the vast majority of C++ features in native C, and all of 'em with tooling. What's wrong with having direct control of only the features you need? What's wrong with code generation? Not to trample on C++, I like it (albeit less than C). I would definitely create C++ if it didn't exist.
- einpoklum 7y ago> when you can implement the vast majority of C++ features in native C No, you absolutely cannot, even in principle. C++ is not "C with classes" and some syntactic sugar like it started out. That's not been the case for many years already. Also, even the features you can implement - you won't; you don't have the person-years for that. You will have to, need to, use libraries. For those you need to compare the libraries available for C and for C++, and C comes up quite short (not just because C libraries are also usable in C++...)
- lightedman 7y ago"No, you absolutely cannot, even in principle." Which is why it has been done for my 2D Second Life clone? Some of us can very easily implement C++ stuff in native C.
- seamyb88 7y agoSo which feature can you not implement? The only I can think of which you'd have real problems are anonymous functions/lambdas. Most other features I think you can implement. It won't look the same, but it will serve the same purpose.
- johannes1234321 7y agoThings coming to mind: Pointers which can't be NULL (aka. references) Exceptions which also clean up intermediate frames (the exception itself can be done with longjmp, but no destructors which could be run)
- megous 7y agoPointers that can't be null are usually implemented by struct embedding. That's typical for Linux kernel code, for example.
- ncmncm 7y agoDestructors. It is the defining feature of the language; everything else in the language extends their reach. They are the key to full exercise of code paths, and thus reliable code. A programmer who makes full use of destructors is simply a better programmer than one who doesn't.
- tejohnso 7y agoAlso, the C++ committee is very serious about not paying for what you don't use. You can rest assured that there's no unused, hidden C++ bloat that is chipping away at your frame budget. This is not meant to be a strawman against the complexity cost argument, it's just a related feature of C++ that I thought might be worth explicitly pointing out in case anyone is misinterpreting. Also, if anyone has a credible dispute against the claim I'd like to hear it.
- Pombal 7y agoYou are describing 'zero cost abstractions'. Except that they are anything but zero cost. Game developers and low level programmers shy away from them because of their impact in compile and build times, debug build performance and stack trace bloat, increased cognitive load, reduced refactoring ability. Even std::unique_ptr has runtime costs in release builds that a raw pointer does not. In game development performance is a feature and anything that makes performance and memory usage less deterministic is frowned upon, like a GC. But iteration times are still paramount and things that make compile, load and link times longer and make it more difficult to debug are also frowned upon. Yes, we'd like to have our cake and eat it too :)
- jcelerier 7y ago> Even std::unique_ptr has runtime costs in release builds that a raw pointer does not. O RLY ? https://gcc.godbolt.org/z/QhbUjI https://gcc.godbolt.org/z/QhbUjI
- abainbridge 7y agoHow would I create the pointer to int in the unique_ptr case without initializing the int? I tried this: https://gcc.godbolt.org/z/SfVxzU https://gcc.godbolt.org/z/SfVxzU I expect there is a way, just I don't know it.
- jcelerier 7y agoSee the docs : https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/memory/unique_ptr/make_unique https://en.cppreference.com/w/cpp/memory/unique_ptr/make_uni... For C++ < 20 replace `std::make_unique<int>()` by `std::unique_ptr<int>(new int)` (which with all explicit uses of `new` can end up not being safe in some cases (in that case, only if you've not enough memory to allocate an int which should not really be a common occurence...) For C++ >= 20 you get std::make_unique_default_init which does that properly.
- xigency 7y agoSerious game developers often do not use STL as a matter of habit and principle. That goes for most of your points about standard libraries. If you are developing code that you expect (or hope) to run on Windows, Linux, Nintendo consoles, phones, PS4's and Xboxes and expect to know the real performance cost of operations, you will be writing all of your own standard libraries anyway. It is very much a problem of "...the complexity of non-standardized often-inconsistent idiosyncratic platforms and libraries for achieving the same things." > Complexity of implementation is not complexity of use. And that's where the language complexity comes into play. Game developers who are bootstrapping need to implement and use these pieces. If you are simplifying your life with C++ features, you must know the ins-and-outs and you cannot rely on new language features because you don't have a choice of compiler in most cases. > I find looking up language features, and quirky 'clever' api's incredibly tiring. The ideal language would be one I can memorize, and then never have to look things up. This is a fair ask and is definitely more accurate of C than C++. What you might write is longer, more tedious code, but that is its own trade-off.
- lacampbell 7y agoFrom the article: "...I care about the speed of the compiler. I am not a zen master of focus, and waiting 10+ seconds is wasteful, yes, but more importantly it breaks my flow. I flick over to Twitter and suddenly 5+ minutes are gone."
- tdsamardzhiev 7y ago5 minutes? Commendable, it's more like 2 hours in my case.