3 ms·
Invention is overvalued as well as the idea of "creativity." The biggest proof is the current China-USA standoff. USA is on the paper the biggest nation on ea
by baybal2 7y ago
Invention is overvalued as well as the idea of "creativity."
The biggest proof is the current China-USA standoff.
USA is on the paper the biggest nation on earth by manufacturing output, but what was the last time you saw made in USA household goods in supermarket without having to specifically look for them?
Why China has industrial base and USA doesn't?
Wages difference? No, not by a chance. In some places in China, the cost of trained blue collar labour begins to exceed that of US.
An hourly rate for an experienced pick and place machine operator in South China certainly exceeds $15 per hour, and may be closing on $20. This is what I can tell from my own experience.
On an another hand, it is $16 in USA. https://www.indeed.com/salaries/SMT-Operator-Salaries https://www.indeed.com/salaries/SMT-Operator-Salaries
Even plain assembly line workers now get close to $15, and trained ones above that. For any manufacturing automation specialist in China, wages are better than in USA...
You don't see Chinese industrialists racing to setup factories in USA. Think why now?
I was telling my own story on HN few times already. I was trying to setup an electric scooter factory in Vancouver, Canada, and then in US northwest on behalf of my employer.
I had to hire university grads to do plain assembly, as anybody else had hard time to just wire a battery, throttle, BMS board, and a motor. And that with colour coded wire harness with mechanical keys to prevent miswiring... We spent 6 months looking for an operator for our model of pick and place machine.
In China, those are the jobs I can hire a highschooler for.
America wastes its talent not any much less than, say, most countries Americans call "the third world."
A very good story about that https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/28/technology/iphones-apple-china-made.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/28/technology/iphones-apple-...
- jeremyjh 7y agoEven if wages are comparable, are other costs of employment, such as unemployment insurance, healthcare, pay roll tax comparable? And even if they are comparable now, its true that it no longer matters. The work moved to China because of low wages, and its going to stay there now because all of the labor force and supply chain infrastructure are much better developed. You are quite right those things no longer exist in the US, they have atrophied.
- baybal2 7y ago> Even if wages are comparable, are other costs of employment, such as unemployment insurance, healthcare, pay roll tax comparable? At ~23.5% Chinese social insurance (medical, trauma and serious illness, pension, housing fund, maternity, unemployment) costs more to employer than in US, at least in Guangdong province. This is why I was saying that guessing purely on numbers, lower cost of capital, external risks, taxes, social payments, and somewhat lower wages, USA should be a better place for manufacturing than China
- soniman 7y agoIt's not at all surprising that low-wage assembly jobs aren't going to attract the best talent in a high-wage country. Also not surprising that low-margin manufactured goods are made in a low-wage, not high-wage, country.
- Jimmc414 7y agoPurchasing power parity.