3 ms·
I actually disagree with the idea that incomprehensible philosophy comes from philosophers so smart that their readership can't understand them. Smarter philoso
by dr_dshiv 7y ago
I actually disagree with the idea that incomprehensible philosophy comes from philosophers so smart that their readership can't understand them. Smarter philosophers could say things that would permit more people to gain greater understanding, wouldn't you say? Assuming of course that philosophers are trying to say things that support understanding.
Further,I think philosophical quality ultimately has to do with its ability to produce positive outcomes. Plato is not definitive -- but reflecting on Plato is deeply enriching. Incomprehensible and miserable philosophy is just that and only that.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Guthur 7y agoIt's not simple thing to explain non simple things in a way that it's comprehensible to a layman. I think this video is a very good illustration of this fact https://youtu.be/36GT2zI8lVA https://youtu.be/36GT2zI8lVA
- dddw 7y agogotta love that man
- jplayer01 7y ago> Smarter philosophers could say things that would permit more people to gain greater understanding, wouldn't you say. This contains the assumption that the purpose of philosophers is to convey philosophy to the masses. I'm not sure why it should be. An electrical engineer's job isn't to convey electronics to lay people. A mathematicians' job isn't to convey his work to laypeople. There are people of those disciplines who take up that as their purpose, and this is an important, crucial role, but to pretend that the goal of every great engineer, scientist or philosopher is to do it is absurd.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoExplaining to the masses is one thing. I'm saying the smarter philosophers are able to understand concepts well enough to explain clearly to other smart people. Like, say Richard Feynman in physics. He is smarter, I'd say, for being able to develop concepts and communicate them. I agree it is a different job to do promotion. But it's an issue if Wittgenstein couldn't communicate comprehensibly to the greatest philosophers of his time -- or experts of today.
- namelosw 7y agoAchieve two goals at the same time is always harder or equal to achieve one of them. If philosophy is easy to understand then good. But make every concept comprehensible to 6-year-old kids would limit the exploration of concepts. As an example I can think of - in programming world, a bunch of programmers always trying to explain an abstract idea of 'monad' to other programmers but almost always fail. But it's a really useful universal abstraction in programming.