3 ms·
I don't know if this is the proper place (if not, sorry), but there's a device I've been dreaming about and that I would gladly pay for: a home router / service
by bambax 16y ago
I don't know if this is the proper place (if not, sorry), but there's a device I've been dreaming about and that I would gladly pay for: a home router / service that would also do antivirus, content filter and VPN in a user-friendly, turn-key way.
There are products that address some of these features (and yes it can be custom built "by hand"), but I'm not aware of something that does it all out of the box? Here's a more detailed description.
1. Antivirus
1.1 At the gate
Since the only way to get something on my computers is via the Web, it doesn't seem efficient to run an AV on each one; this device would check all incoming traffic.
1.2 "AV DMZ"
Ideally, this device would also be able to do an AV check on hard disks and such when connected to it via USB, so that if someone comes to my house with a USB drive I can check it there without having any other machine with an antivirus installed.
2. Proxy / filter
2.1 AdBlock
This is currently worse than antivirus software (except that it's free): one needs one AV per computer, but one AdBlock per browser (and some browsers can't have any, except by using a proxy). Having it centralized would be so much simpler.
2.2 Content filter / blocker
Most home routers have some sort of white list / black list mechanisms, but they have to be edited manually; this device would filter content based on crowd-sourced lists; there could be different lists of differing strength (cf. all the recent talk about content farms).
3. VPN
Content is being more and more controlled, either at the source (Hulu) or by governments, even in the West (France, Australia and others -- cf. Wikileaks).
A VPN service that would a/ encrypt traffic and b/ make it originate from different places in the world (user-selectable among different solutions offered by the service, maybe for different prices) would alleviate all those problems.
- SimonPStevens 16y agoThe initial problem I see with something like this would be encryption. All the attacker would have to do is encrypt their virus which would get it past the antivirus gate keeper, then when it was decrypted on the local PCs there would be nothing to recognise it. The same problem would exist for anything running over https. That would be the first problem to solve, although I'm sure there would be ways of resolving this.
- IgorPartola 16y agoHTTPS will get in the way of most of these. If someone on your network decides to search for content you have blocked, all they'd have to do is use HTTPS to access Google, Yahoo, etc. Unless of course you require all your browsers to go through the proxy server on your device that forces HTTP on them. Which is more of a pain.
- bambax 16y ago> If someone on your network decides to search for content you have blocked... I don't mind; it's a device for the home, not for the office. I'm not trying to enforce anything for my "users", I'm just looking for convenience for me. Content blocking is not a punishment that people would want to escape: it's a reward! Use it if you want to, don't use it if you don't want to...
- oldgregg 16y ago4. SecureBrowse. Add a couple settings to your computer and no matter how/where you are connected to the internet it will route your trafic through your home router. I've seen an increasing number of "normals" that refuse get on public wifi because of security concerns-- they are convinced the moment you connect to public wifi everyone will be able to access your email and bank accounts. Subscribing to existing VPN services is either too complex or not compelling because of the price point-- people don't want ANOTHER subscription just to use free public wifi. VPN technology isn't magic, but with the right (simple) implementation it might seem like it.