3 ms·
The problem with what Bloomberg reported was not that it was implausible, but rather that it was unsubstantiated as to whether the attack actually occurred. If
by mindslight 7y ago
The problem with what Bloomberg reported was not that it was implausible, but rather that it was unsubstantiated as to whether the attack actually occurred. If Bloomberg had narrated the article as "this could happen", attempting to explain a possible attack vector, that would have been fantastic.
I do agree there was a lot of "but SPI requires 6 wires and the slave can only respond when talked to" (treating SPI with the assumptions of a design engineer rather than an attacker), but that was ultimately just noise.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoAgree. Remember BadBIOS? * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BadBIOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BadBIOS Same problem. EVERYTHING that Dragos Ruiu claimed is plausible, and it could be a great cyberpunk plot written by Neal Stephenson. But there is ZERO evidence that the malware actually exists. And finding an actual incident in real life is much more important than theoretical possibilities. For example, almost everyone knows that it's very possible for semiconductor vendors to include a silicon-level backdoor since the 1980s, but finding an actual Intel/AMD chip with such backdoor (not ME, something like a secret instructions) is another matter.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Sephr 7y agoME has a debug mode that might be possible to enable with a signal sent through the 3.5mm jack on some laptops[1]. I'd be pretty concerned about ME bugs and backdoors disguised as ME bugs. 1. https://youtu.be/xUJQps2-VWk?t=301 https://youtu.be/xUJQps2-VWk?t=301
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoI meant, finding a backdoor in its full form on the main system would be a much more significant find, and its impact and newsworthiness is greater than any hypothetical or baseless speculations, such as Bloomberg's BMC affair. The impact of the BMC affair, if true, is showing real evidence and real demonstration that such an attack has happened, has been used in the wild, rather than showing that the attack is possible (we all know). Unfortunately, bad journalism at work. P.S: I'm not saying that the ME subsystem, or buggy speculation (pun not intended) isn't a threat, just to make a point. > I'd be pretty concerned about ME bugs and backdoors disguised as ME bugs. Same consequences. I'd say they're effectively the same thing.
- ryacko 7y agoZuckerberg’s famous MacBook with tape over web cam and microphone jack has a lot more context now. I guess this says everything about corporations caring about security.
- monocasa 7y agoThere's a difference between one guy chasing ghosts, and several sources anonymously saying "we found this and had to mitigate it".
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoWell, a year later, we still haven't seen the backdoor chip in question being taken to a lab or DEFCON yet... Even the photograph was fake, just a stock photo... I was excited to read the news story, and it was a huge disappointment.
- monocasa 7y agoWe also haven't seen the devices in the NSA's TAO catalog taken to a lab or showing up at DEFCON. That's half the point of targeted hardware attacks. And yeah, it was a graphic that wasn't entirely accurate; welcome to print journalism.
- monocasa 7y agoI mean, relying on multiple anonymous sources saying "this happened and this is how it happened" along with third parties validating the plausibility is a common acceptable standard for journalism.
- mindslight 7y agoI don't know if I'd thought about it that way. There is so much ambiguity and embellishment that goes into journalism in general, I don't view the output with any sort of authority. Applying the standard of security research, they didn't detail any evidence demonstrating their claim that it was actually being exploited [0]. It seems that difference in perspective is how Bloomberg thought their story was reasonable. IIRC it was also heavily focused on Supermicro, without any distinction whether Supermicro was specifically targeted or just happened to supply the boards that were bugged and caught. [0] eg showing a chip, or ideally the whole motherboard system. Does it actually rewrite instructions going by on MISO or was something else more practical? Parasitic energy harvesting? Inquiring minds want to know!!
- nickpsecurity 7y agoOh no, it isn't. Look, I get that you've seen enough to either know the shit is happening or believe it is based on what you've seen happen. I'm in the same boat. I'm just saying you're hurting your already-good credibility saying things like that. No, it's not acceptable if it's a highly-controversial claim in an industry or topic that normally comes with proof of exploitation. They should've got it even if it was independent party vetting it that most would trust who wouldn't give too many details that would compromise an investigation. They could get money and/or advertising for doing the review. Otherwise, present it like it's information coming from anonymous, unvetted sources who could be full of shit.
- monocasa 7y agoLiterally some of the most influential journalism of all time has been sourced from anonymous informants that weren't vetted by third parties. We didn't find out who deep throat was until over thirty years later, after he was in a nursing home with dementia. Remember that anonymous doesn't mean unvetted. And that leak was over literally millions of lives, so it's not like an intelligence arm of a Nation state doing its job in peace time is so more serious that the standards are higher.
- wybiral 7y agoTo be fair to Bloomberg, some of the companies involved were also complicit with the NSA PRISM project and in the initial reporting of that they all denied giving the government a backdoor. But you're right, it's been a year now and no further evidence has surfaced which seems odd.
- monocasa 7y agoThe original disclosure was about a targeted hack. What further evidence would you expect to appear?
- wybiral 7y agoRegarding the "spy chip" story: Other sources. Or other news agencies confirming the sources used. Or any evidence of the chips being planted on any hardware at all. To be clear: I'm not saying it didn't happen, just that I'm skeptical about the validity and details of their story unless they have something to back it up with.
- monocasa 7y agoThey had multiple sources. And the story was that the targeted boards were either destroyed or handed off to the government, are you asking for someone to have probably risked jail time by holding onto one of them?
- utopian3 7y ago> are you asking for someone to have probably risked jail time by holding onto one of them? You’re the first person to even propose such a thing
- monocasa 7y ago..no I'm not. They handed over the boards as part of an investigation. Withholding evidence in an investigation involving national security, along with all the false statements you'd need to make in order to make that happen is a great way to not see your family for a few years. I'm not the first to suggest this.