4 ms·
While I am skeptical of bloomberg, I'm even more skeptical of the NSA as they've burned all their goodwill in my eyes at this point. So I'm in the "probably tr
by munk-a 7y ago
While I am skeptical of bloomberg, I'm even more skeptical of the NSA as they've burned all their goodwill in my eyes at this point. So I'm in the "probably true, if not then probably something nearly identical happened with a different serious vulnerability" camp.
- tptacek 7y agoWhat "goodwill" would be involved here? NSA is chartered to exploit things like Heartbleed.
- monocasa 7y agoThey're also chartered to provide information assurance.
- JasonFruit 7y agoOne of those goals benefits the people with power who are above the NSA. The other provides a benefit to the public at large that few will notice. Which goal do you think is likely to be top priority?
- monocasa 7y agoWell, in the case of heartbleed where first the NSA found it, and an independent researcher found it, and the DoD uses Linux and OpenSSL all over the place, you'd think that the information assurance side would be better represented. Who knows how many adversaries were using that as well before it was public (hence the whole point of responsible disclosure). Edit: Like, stuff like cryptanalysis of SM4 is for sure on the table. I can even see their neat Diffie-Hellman hack that costs $100m per nonce. But a trivially remotely exploitable memory safety bug in software that runs large sections of the military? Like, come on.
- admax88q 7y agoTo be fair, I bet the NSA knows better than anyone if any given exploit is being used in the wild.
- tptacek 7y agoI'm not sure anyone really takes the IAD mission seriously. The actual purpose of the organization is to do offensive SIGINT.
- monocasa 7y agoI mean, I don't really have any sympathy for them writing off half their mission, despite the impunity with which they do so.
- PeCaN 7y agoI think they got some retroactive goodwill from the DES thing when it was discovered that they legitimately made it stronger. Of course, they've more than squandered that by now, but it's not like they always completely ignored the IAD.
- JohnFen 7y agoRight, which is why any denial they make about this sort of thing is meaningless.
- ENOTTY 7y agoThey don't try to take information assurance seriously? Are projects like SELinux[1], SE for Android[2], or the STM/PE[3] serious enough? [1]: "Retrospective: 26 Years of Flexible MAC" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AKWFbxbsU3o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AKWFbxbsU3o [2]: https://selinuxproject.org/page/SEforAndroid https://selinuxproject.org/page/SEforAndroid [3]: https://www.cyberscoop.com/nsa-firmware-open-source-coreboot-stm-pe-eugene-myers/ https://www.cyberscoop.com/nsa-firmware-open-source-coreboot...
- tptacek 7y agoOh, they requisition budget for the IAD mission, and they use it on IAD things. In reality, the most important thing NSA does is get budget allocated to itself! But does anyone believe that in a conflict between IAD and CNO/SIGINT, IAD has ever won?
- scarejunba 7y agoWell, yes, but the problem is that (unlike Dual EC-DRBG) other people can also exploit these things when open. For instance, I suppose, would the USA be better if Project Zero shipped all their stuff to the NSA and they both kept it quiet or would the USA be better if they fixed these things. The point is to gain differential advantage. When you're the rich guy you don't want everyone's doors to be unlockable. When you're the poor guy you do. The USA is the rich guy.
- jMyles 7y agoSure, if indeed the InfoSec arm is just for show and not the thrust of the organization, then they were chartered in such a way as to be incapable of cultivating goodwill, and incapable of existing in a just and free society. And as such, the NSA (along with the CIA and perhaps, looking forward, the ONI, MIC, etc) are subject to deprecation. In order for peace to come to earth in the information age, we must mature beyond a perceived need to have state agencies keeping secrets on the public dime and fomenting reasonable paranoia among the populous.