3 ms·
> For ages, friends, family, and colleagues have lent and borrowed from each other, but what differs today is a lack of reciprocity. In peer-to-peer credit, eve
by gumby 7y ago
> For ages, friends, family, and colleagues have lent and borrowed from each other, but what differs today is a lack of reciprocity. In peer-to-peer credit, everyone is eventually likely to be a debtor and a creditor; terms can be reworked according to timelines and margins that are subject to negotiation. In contrast, the fintech industry envisions ordinary Kenyans as first and foremost borrowers, leading many Kenyans to describe their predicament as a form of servitude
Is it any different in the USA?
- jalgos_eminator 7y agoMany parents give their children money, but I think its most often just a gift. Other than that, I have never heard of anyone lending more than $100 or so to another person that isn't in their immediate family.
- ntlk 7y agoIn my friend group it was perfectly normal to borrow / lend small sums of money. That is until a point in my life where my friends now have savings.
- scarejunba 7y agoExpat Asian families do this a lot because the relationship is buttressed by a secondary relationship in the old country. It's not uncommon to see Indian tech workers lend each other six figures here in the Bay Area. A friend just got his downpayment from his friends.
- novok 7y agoIn the USA? Often they don't count those gifts for mortgage downpayments unless you are blood related.
- scarejunba 7y agoIn the Bay Area and it does work. Don't know if that's changes recently. I observed three years ago.
- yardie 7y agoI’ve always been fascinated by how new Indian immigrants with limited resources can pull enough scratch to start a small business or franchise. Mostly without help from immediate family or rich friends.
- hinkley 7y agoMy parents grew up in rural areas and moved to small cities. Some of my relatives still live in the same 6000+ person town they went to school in. I always think of the Amish model of big project management to be just a more formal version of the economy of reciprocity that goes on everywhere that your neighbors are your safety net. You may recall in the '90s and into the '00s there were a bunch of people crowing about the 'gift economy' that was going to come about. In hindsight it's pretty clear to me that these are the children of city folk who have discovered a new idea and think they're the first to think of it. What may be bothering the Kenyans is the over-precise nature in which a bank wants to do you a 'favor' versus a neighbor. To an extent you can borrow on credit and the strength of your personality, and you are expected to repay 'in kind', but the math is fuzzy. I do a 'big favor' for you, you do a 'big favor' for me, but it's loosey goosey. In a social exchange we are square when I've done something that is approximately on par with your act (+/- 10%) in anything like a reasonable time frame. With a bank we are only square when my act is at least 5% larger than yours, and the act always gets bigger the longer I delay. Also the bank's transactions are always between 2 individuals. A generous person within a village might be able to enjoy (or even expect) dividends from people he has no previous transactions with. You helped my grandma when she was sick. You can borrow my plow. The bank doesn't care how much charity work you've done, or how much business with another bank. You've still got to pay. And soon.