3 ms·
There's a ton of FUD going around about this in games journalism - claiming that this could be the end of the game industry as we know it. Problem with this re
by falcolas 7y ago
There's a ton of FUD going around about this in games journalism - claiming that this could be the end of the game industry as we know it.
Problem with this reporting is - console games have been re-sellable since the beginning, and console gaming (from a fiscal and number perspective) vastly outpaces PC gaming. That doesn't even include how much more prevalent pirating is with the PC gaming market.
If the console market can survive this, so can the PC market. Yes, even indies.
- d1zzy 7y agoYes, but console games never get anywhere near the steep discounts or the sheer number of them that PC digital games get. I'm sure PC gaming can _survive_ this but surviving is not the same as "nothing will change" nor is it "it's going to be better overall". That remains to be seen.
- knightofmars 7y agoOP never said "nothing will change" or "it's going to be better overall". To be clear, I'm not trying to be antagonistic, what exactly are you arguing here?
- falcolas 7y agoRemember - when you can re-sell the game, you don't need the same deep discounts, when you can sell the game to someone else for 80+% of the original sale price. Even with that in mind, console games (specifically the ones that can be resold) frequently go on sale for half their retail price, and after a year or two can get down to a third. Just like their digital counterparts.
- rjf72 7y agoYou might find the numbers surprising. This [1] provides a reasonable overview of financial data on the games industry. PC vs all consoles combined tends to be extremely close in terms of fiscal figures (34 vs 34.7bn in 2016, 32.2 vs 33.3bn in 2017, 25% vs 28% in 2018, etc). User numbers are heavily lopsided in favor of PC. For instance one of the top ten grossing games worldwide is Dungeon Fighter Online. It's Windows only, and has a userbase in excess of 600 million. That is some multiple of the total number of all modern consoles sold. In any case this isn't about console vs PC. It's about digital vs physical. With digital "licensing" as opposed to ownership, games are thrown about like beads at mardis gras. I have a hundreds of games that easily have a retail price in the thousands of dollars, but thanks to sales, give aways, bundles, etc I doubt I've spent more than $1000 on them in total. Many of the games I've never even played simply for lack of time. If you start enabling reselling this entire model becomes impossible because now organizations would emerge to take advantage of these opportunities for dirt cheap products with the intention of accumulating stock and reselling them. Obviously this ending would not be the end of the games industry, but I do think it'd be safe to say that it'd be the end of the game industry as we know it. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_in_video_gaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2018_in_video_gaming
- falcolas 7y ago> Dungeon Fighter Online A Chinese built and published title. Somehow, I doubt that a French ruling against a US country is going to have any impact whatsoever on a title in China. Frankly, when it comes to copyright (and anything related to it, like game licenses), it's smartest to ignore the Chinese market entirely, since they don't respect the US or EU copyright system when it doesn't benefit them. > I do think it'd be safe to say that it'd be the end of the game industry as we know it. In what way? Even if we include the Chinese market, game developers for consoles with their rampant(!) game reselling have hardly fallen apart (or seen much impact at all) to their bottom line. They're still making record profits. Why assume that the PC market will be that drastically different?
- hekdev 7y agoUsed physical copies degrade and are an objectively inferior offering to new copies. Digital copies don't degrade unless artificially made to do so. The copies can be traded for infinity without ever degrading or lessening in value. Which essentially mean that with time the demand for any game would be vastly outnumbered by the supply of cheap "used" copies that never ever degrade. It would be very hurtful to indies since they will be the first ones to have their games dumped on the market, even if they're good.
- falcolas 7y agoI have old physical copies of Nintendo Entertainment System games that are still perfectly usable. I have playstation 1 games that show a few scratches, but which are still 100% usable. I have some PS2 games that got scratched all to hell, used a CD repair device on them, and they still work just fine. They are a digital product, not analog. They don’t degrade with time, for all practical purposes. You’d have to physically destroy the media, which takes quite deliberate effort in most cases. When it comes to videogames on CD’s, DVD’s, BluRays, and Cartridges, the age of the media means effectively nothing when it comes to a playable game.
- oliwarner 7y agoThey absolutely can survive this. But they don't have to. Publishers and vendors could simply stop selling software licenses and start leasing them out in the EU. Your rights diminish. They wouldn't have to charge less. They wouldn't have very much of anything. It'd actually be a lot easier than complying than this ruling. Or —if they're willing to do more than an hour's work— they could completely pivot and only lease software as part of a membership (Origin Access), or keep essential elements of the game as SaaS with rent, or even just keep everything and do remote gaming as a service (eg Stadia). Welcome to the brave new world of software licensing.