4 ms·
I think Uber (and Lyft) are absolutely adding value. I now regularly take ride shares when I would previously have driven or extremely reluctantly taken cabs. I
by sokoloff 7y ago
I think Uber (and Lyft) are absolutely adding value. I now regularly take ride shares when I would previously have driven or extremely reluctantly taken cabs. I also talk to my rideshare drivers and the platforms provide some much needed cashflow (and perhaps day-filling) for people who seem genuinely happy to avail themselves of the income opportunity provided.
I see no reason to think that those two companies couldn't be quite profitable in their core businesses in their established cities. (I think they already are.)
That said, their valuations in the market are comically/insanely/unjustifiably high, but that's quite different from saying they "add no value".
- WhompingWindows 7y agoThey may add value vs taxis, but would Uber or Lyft add value vs any other startup taxi service? Expanding further, How about a taxi-app you and I could sit down and hack out? How much value-add is there in an Uber or Lyft vs what we could do?
- Apocryphon 7y agoDoesn't Flywheel already own that space?
- berbec 7y agoBe careful, you're suspiciously close to saying the uber is nothing more than FTP, curlftpfs and CVS. [1] I'm not arguing that Uber is worth it value, but dismissing the tech & usability involved is a treacherous road to go down. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9224
- JohnFen 7y agoIn my area, they add no real value over the standard taxi companies. Literally the only advantage to them is that they're cheaper (which is an artificial and unsustainable difference). Everything else they do is also done equally well by the cab companies. That may be why there aren't an increasing number of Uber and Lyft drivers here, but the taxi companies are expanding.
- andreilys 7y agoDo your local cab companies offer the equivalent of uber pool or lyft line?
- avn2109 7y agoIn your area, do taxi companies operate a service "Lift Line" or the uber equivalent, in which you share a taxis with strangers who are going in a similar direction? I have never seen a non-app taxi service do this, and it's a real genuine technology enabled value add. Is it 50 billion bucks worth? Probably not. But it isn't 0 either.
- jbarberu 7y agoI grew up with something like this. We called them buses, they were pretty cool :)
- JohnFen 7y agoI have no idea, since that's not a feature that I'd notice or look for. > I have never seen a non-app taxi service do this What do you mean by a non-app taxi service? All of the taxi companies here have apps that work pretty much the same as Uber and Lyft's.
- im_cynical 7y agoI heard some economist call Uber "the greatest transfer of wealth in a very long time". What Uber is doing is taking investors money and subsidizing your Uber ride to a restaurant. They are providing value and I'm a casual user myself. However the consumer price right now is arguably unsustainable against the stated quote above. To survive both of them are going to have to raise prices
- 35787 7y agoThis is not true. Uber drivers make tons of money. I know because I was one. The press put a microscope on the subset of drivers who are stupid and can’t make money because they run their businesses poorly. The press is happy to let them tell their son stories but what they don’t mention is that those drivers refuse to drive anywhere outside their immediate area, they drive huge shitty cars that cost literally ten times more per mile to operate than a corolla or Prius, and various other things. There’s this myth floating around that Uber is a trap because the costs of running and maintaining a vehicle is difficult to quantify and all Uber drivers are uneducated people being taken advantage of. This is totally, completely untrue and seeing this myth/meme spread like cancer across the entire internet has opened my eyes to how something that is totally untrue can become widely and vehemently believed. It’s simply not true. I’ve given many thousands of rides. I know. I have a college education and the calculations solidly land within the region of very healthy profit no matter how pessimistic the maintenance projections are and no matter how wide the error margin is made. It’s. A. Fucking. Myth. I genuinely wonder if people will someday understand. Anyway, drivers make more than enough. After glancing at Uber’s books, it looks like they spent literally a billion dollars on advertising. They also do a a lot of research. Uber could easily run its ride sharing service with room for profit if it wanted to cut back in other areas. Ride sharing is totally economically viable as a business and it is better than traditional dispatch in almost every way. Companies like Uber aren’t going anywhere. To say that Uber is worthless is flat out wrong. Overvalued or levered or invested-in, yes maybe. But ride sharing is solid. The only thing that could change it is self driving cars.
- cjarrett 7y agoI’m gonna trust the multitudes if studies than someone telling the rest of his peers to be better.
- praptak 7y agoThey do add some value. They don't add any value above a taxi company/cooperative with a decent app.
- mynegation 7y agoAt least one bit of the value is that you do not have to install new app or two in every city you go to. I wish something like this existed for parking payments.
- lokedhs 7y agoI'd be happy if I was even allowed to install the parking application in the first place. When I went back to Sweden last time to visit my family, I rented a car but when I wanted to park I wasn't able to install the application since my account is not Swedish.
- ellyagg 7y agoOnly having to install one app to get a consistent experience around the world is high value for me as a user.
- stedaniels 7y agoNeither Uber nor Lyft are really ridesharing. They are ride hailing apps. Unless you are sharing with other passengers? I didn't realise they offered this?
- joshuamorton 7y agoYes, Uber pool and Lyft line both allow you to share with other riders.
- hangonhn 7y agoThey've been doing this for years now. Significant savings that way too.
- stedaniels 7y agoTIL! I always thought they just pretended they were ridesharing because you were sharing with the driver who just happened to be going the way you asked them to. Goes off to see just how prevalent real ridesharing is on the platforms
- amalter 7y agoOnly anecdotal, but Uber Pool is by far the most popular product among my cohort in Brooklyn and Manhattan. Usually you ride with at least one other person, and it’s not unusual to have 3-4 passengers if it’s a third row suv. I enjoy shitting on Uber also, but there is a grain of genuine innovation in the mountain of crap.
- otakucode 7y agoThe problem I see with Uber is that, at the end of things, all they provide is some software running on some servers. While not an easy weekend project, it would not be impossible for a distributed system to replace it, making whatever life they have almost certainly temporary. Every action they take to extract more profit will only increase the pressure toward development and move towards a distributed system. As long as it can present an app to a customer that can hook them up with a driver without being obtrusive, it seems like a service destined to become a commodity and certainly not something likely to be a cash cow for long.
- pfranz 7y ago> The problem I see with Uber is that, at the end of things, all they provide is some software running on some servers. That's true, and this isn't an argument for the bad things they do, but they did force the taxi industry forward a few decades. Prior to Uber/Lyft, taxis in most areas were outright hostile. I had called to schedule a taxi ride the day before and had them no-show. It was so common for taxis to feign their credit card machine didn't work that it was outlawed (but still done)--they preferred cash to avoid reporting and fees. Hailing taxis in most cities isn't permitted. Minimum distance requirements have caused me problems (been refused or been treated hostilely even when offered to overpay or overtip). Those things are never an issue anymore. In addition, they've also made it much easier to track down lost items left behind or to dispute incorrect fares or taking longer routes. The incentives in place with taxis alone didn't address these things. Those things, in addition to having consistency when traveling between cities and countries, sounds like a reason to have stickiness to one service. McDonalds is popular even though it's not a great meal and people could eat anywhere.
- otakucode 7y agoI didn't mention anything about other things they've done, I'm just looking at what the organization actually provides to the market. While it is true that they did all of the things you mentioned, that is unfortunately what's known as First Mover Disadvantage. They pave the way, and now anyone can crop up and make use of the tough road they laid down. McDonald's is popular, at least this is what I was told in business courses, because people like familiarity and they know when they get a meal at a McDonald's it's going to be mostly the same everywhere. Uber doesn't really enjoy that. They do enjoy that it is a unified app and service no matter where you are, they have that going for them for a certainty, but they do not have control over their drivers to the level at which McDonald's has control over their franchisees. That's down to the fact their drivers are independent contractors, although it likely couldn't work any other way. It might be moot since the service is the same, getting from point A to B, so the part people want stays the same. I would almost be inclined to see it as Uber being more valuable for their management of driver reputations than the software they provide, really. They set a standard, and hold drivers somewhat accountable to that standard, which is something that a more 'open' solution would make very difficult or impossible to do.