4 ms·
> I hear a lot about AVX-512 being really good. Its a great instruction set, Absolutely great, AVX512 supports gather/scatter, a whole slew of efficient proces
by dragontamer 7y ago
> I hear a lot about AVX-512 being really good.
Its a great instruction set, Absolutely great, AVX512 supports gather/scatter, a whole slew of efficient processing instructions, etc. etc.
However, AVX512 has poor implementations right now. Skylake-X is one of the only implementations, and running it drops the clock-rate in ways that are difficult to predict. (One core running AVX512 drops the clock of other cores, slowing down the throughput of the entire server).
Traditionally, the first implementation of these instruction sets always a degree of "emulated". For example, the gather/scatter instructions aren't much faster than load/stores in practice.
So while the AVX512 instruction set could theoretically be efficiently implemented, it seem like Skylake-X's implementation leaves much to be desired. Hopefully future implementations will be better.
------
The other major implementation of AVX512 is Xeon Phi, which has been deemed end-of-life. I like the idea of Xeon Phi, but it just didn't seem to work out in practice.
- gameswithgo 7y agothe clock rate has nothing to do with a bad implementation, all the computation just makes a lot of heat. the performance increase is still massive, often more than 2x avx, which also throttles btw
- DuskStar 7y agoThe clock rate issue isn't the fact that it downclocks a core when moving to AVX512, it's that it downclocked all the other cores on the processor at the same time.
- robocat 7y agoFrom what I have read, AVX512 only affects the one core (downclocking License level L1 or L2), it is older CPUs with AVX2 that affected all cores. Independently thermal throttling can occur which would affect all cores, although presumably the CPU is generating heat per numeric operation, so AVX512 is neutral versus other instructions per numeric operation.
- gameswithgo 7y agoon intel cpus the license levels basically are discrete thermal throttles. vs and which doesn’t do that, just constantly monitors thermals and adjusts clock. intels method makes benchmarking simpler! but may leave performance on the table.
- gameswithgo 7y agoi understand why downclocks are an issue, and i understand that on some intel cpus the while chip downclocks with certain instructions. i was commenting on the supposed reason the down clocks happen, and mentioning that performance is spectacular despite then (assuming you schedule your workload appropriately).