3 ms·
Wow. That’s not going to cause massive, crippling hyper inflation at all, is it.
by simonh 7y ago
Wow. That’s not going to cause massive, crippling hyper inflation at all, is it.
- nitrogen 7y agoIf people being able to feed themselves would cause unsustainable inflation, then we have bigger problems.
- luckydata 7y agoThat's such a myopic, small way to see the world. Human dignity is the priority, if our economy doesn't work for that then we change the economy, we don't give up on dignity.
- simonh 7y agoI agree completely. Nobody should go hungry, without basic health care or without a roof over their heads in a modern advanced economy. But $1,000 a month for everybody is insane. It would require a massive tax on corporations and the wealthy, and it’s just an objective fact that raising taxes that way does not significantly increase tax income. It just doesn’t. It’s been tried over and over in many countries and it never works. I live in the UK. We have universal health care, a robust social care model, my kids are getting a decent free education and we have a decent benefits system. I’m proud of all of those and don’t resent a single penny I pay in taxes towards it. But plonking big wadges of cash on everybody, funded by hammering anybody that looks even moderately successful, is a recipe for economic mayhem.
- Jeff_Brown 7y agoInflation comes from an increase in the money supply. If we printed the money for it, it would cause inflation, but he plans to tax it. But even if we printed it, it would by no stretch of the imagination cause hyperinflation, just inflation. The M2 money supply -- still an incomplete measure, as there are lots of kinds of money -- in the US is 14 trillion and change, per Investopedia[1]. 12K per year * 350M people in the US = 4.2 trillion more dollars a year. Hyperinflation happens when a regime does something like double the money supply every week. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/moneysupply.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/moneysupply.asp
- simonh 7y agoThe economy isn't an undifferentiated lump of money, stuff and people. It is a complex structure. If most people have a lot more money, they will be able to afford a lot more of the stuff most people buy most of the time. So the inflation will be concentrated in staples and consumer goods simply due to greater demand versus supply. If prices stayed as is, it's hard to see why anyone would do a lot of the low paid to medium income jobs many people currently do. But those jobs would still need to be done, which would drive up wages, but where is the money for the increased wages going to come from? Well, businesses would have to charge more. That's inflation again. These effects would still happen, but might be mitigated by easing in a policy like this over time. I'm not convinced about taxing it to make it fiscally neutral. A wealth of evidence shows that increasing taxes on the wealthy doesn't significantly increase tax revenue. They just progressively take more and more of their wealth out of the economy off shore, or move off shore themselves, along with their businesses. Many governments across the world have tried this and it just doesn't work.
- ryacko 7y agoAfter numerous natural disasters, wars, etc, the one long-term constant for prosperity seems to be human capital. If you have society that attracts the smartest individuals for the most productive professions (which is right now anything involving information technology), your society wins. Your society will develop new concepts first, will be the first to sell it, and the first to reap revenues from it. Besides, it is very easy to tax the megacorps. Tariffs on intellectual property. Or reduce tax deductions on licensing fees. Bermuda is the center of intellectual property ownership.
- simonh 7y agoThe smartest people in the most productive professions are above average earners. How is taxing them into the ground going to attract them?
- Jeff_Brown 7y ago