5 ms·
Concerning ‘Remove Richard Stallman’
- Mathnerd314 7y agoRMS is pretty old (66). I wonder if he was given the option to fight it but decided he'd rather retire than deal with all the politics, or if it was a fait accompli situation where he only had the choice between resigning and being fired.
- javagram 7y agoThe FSF is his life’s work, and he is getting close to retirement age. I could see the decision as having been at least somewhat voluntary if he wants to keep the FSF’s mission relevant (GNOME and the SFC were threatening to break ties).
- 5F36B5F62640 7y agoStallman's mistake was expressing his key point in two sentences using many words of three or more syllables. This apparently put it beyond the reading comprehension level of the reporters at Vice and Daily Beast, and of Selam G., and so his point was completely misunderstood/misrepresented.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoAre women coerced into doing and accepting things that they would rather not due to misogyny. Absolutely. But they still have free will and a choice. At the end of the day, sexually harassed women make a Faustian bargain. They didn’t have to. But they did. It might be the devil but when you choose to consort with the devil, you play in hell. A lot of times(admittedly not always), the solution is to walk away. Walk away. The damage to the ego can be dealt with and maybe even vindicated. But it’s wiser to walk away to a place of strength to strategize and wage a bloody war to win rather than engage in puny battles for fragile hollow victories. It’s easier to nurse a wounded ego and come back to fight another day than endure systemic harassment that rips your very spirit apart. Stupid battle of the sexes.
- pbiggar 7y agoThe author expects people to fully understand stallmans world view and to thoroughly examine his position. However, the author did not pay the same regard to Salam G., the author of the original post reporting on the most recent of Stallmans shitty proclamations. The author shows no sign of understanding why it's important that Stallman was fired, nor did he show he had done to work to try and get it. You can safely ignore this. I came away worse for having read it.
- scrumper 7y ago> The author shows no sign of understanding why it's important that Stallman was fired... Not sure that's fair. In the conclusion he writes: > The goals Selam G. seeks to advance are good ones. Institutions like MIT need to closely consider their past and present treatment of women. People at those institutions, and perhaps even Stallman himself, need to have their worst impulses checked, or possibly even be removed altogether. He was arguing for something like a due process in firing Stallman, not for not firing him.
- pbiggar 7y ago> Not sure that's fair. In the conclusion he writes: I feel confident with my assessment. He showed no indication that he understood the current movement to hold powerful men accountable for their actions. For example, where's the due process for the women Stallman excluded by his horrible behaviour for decades? Stallman went down for being a creepy perv for decades. He should have gone down for one of the many lines he crossed before today. Eventually, when you give a creep enough passes he'll say something so creepy it's indefensible, Yet here you are trying.
- mikeash 7y agoSince when did anyone ever expect due process when being fired? This is a world where you can be fired for showing up 30 seconds late because of a road closure.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fortran77 7y agoI'm no fan of Stallman, but this was a very odd reason to give the guy the boot. They're mad at Epstein, and he's dead, so they need other people to direct their anger at. Who knows what Minsky may or may not have done? Nobody. He's dead too. So when Stallman did some awkward speculating, these women constructed false stories about what Stallman said, and then used these false statements as lies to get Stallman fired. Any man with any sense would be wise not to involve women in any way, shape, or form in a project or company.
- emiliobumachar 7y agoSJWs are out of control and doing real damage, but don't generalize your grudge to half of humanity.
- pavel_lishin 7y ago> SJWs are out of control and doing real damage [citation needed]
- emiliobumachar 7y agoWe're commenting on an article about Richard Stallman being removed for something he did not say. That's the damage I'm talking about.
- pavel_lishin 7y agoSeems like he's being removed for being an asshole for years and years, and for things he very explicitly did say, repeatedly, for years. And this seems very much like a "straw that broke the camel's back".
- fortran77 7y agoAnd my very reasonable comment about it was flagged and removed because we can't have reasonable discussions on Hacker News because we all have to be woke!
- 7y ago
- CPLX 7y agoOur culture has made a very bright line decision that sex with minors is unacceptable. Expressing doubt about this cultural norm, or especially advocating against it, is considered unacceptable. Of course one can argue with the merits of those two facts, but they are plainly true and fairly widely accepted. The very concept of statutory rape reinforces how clear this judgment is. The reference to "statutory" means that the mere facts of the act taking place mean that the conduct is off limits. Things like "consent" or even a misrepresentation of the person's age are generally considered irrelevant. As a society we've decided that there aren't really exceptions to this. If sex with minors occurs it's not OK, there isn't much need to further investigate why it happened. Stallman, and anyone else commenting here, has really no basis to claim ignorance of this phenomenally clear social norm, which if broken will result in being fired from just about any public facing institution. It's on a pretty short list of such norms, alongside things like displaying your genitals in a board meeting. While I appreciate the efforts to make this into some kind of principled argument, I don't find "first they came for the people advocating for sex with minors" to be particularly compelling.
- kjksf 7y agoThis is perfect example of mob mentality in action. At no point Stallman was defending sex with minors. And yet, here you are, extremely offended at him for something he didn't say.
- CPLX 7y ago"I think it is morally absurd to define 'rape' in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17." "I think that everyone age 14 or above ought to take part in sex, though not indiscriminately. (Some people are ready earlier.)" "I am skeptical of the claim that voluntarily [sic] pedophilia harms children. The arguments that it causes harm seem to be based on cases which aren't voluntary, which are then stretched by parents who are horrified by the idea that their little baby is maturing." - Richard Stallman Source: https://www.npr.org/2019/09/17/761718975/free-software-pioneer-quits-mit-over-his-comments-on-epstein-sex-trafficking-cas https://www.npr.org/2019/09/17/761718975/free-software-pione...