4 ms·
Could this extend to ebooks as well? Valve's argument that what they sold was a license and not the game feels like a distinction without a difference to me. S
by criddell 7y ago
Could this extend to ebooks as well?
Valve's argument that what they sold was a license and not the game feels like a distinction without a difference to me. Say I accept that. Then why can't I sell that license?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ldng 7y agoUnder French law, probably. Not A French Lawyer.
- ajnin 7y agoI think this should. Using the same logic, this should apply to in-game items and other "dematerialized" goods.
- roblabla 7y agoA license is a contract between you and valve. You can't transfer that license because the contract says you can't. The court says that the digital game is a good (just like a DVD is), and not a license, so you must be allowed to resell it to somebody else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shadowgovt 7y agoSo is an ebook not a good?
- criddell 7y agoSo the end result must be that licenses can't take away your resale rights.
- jandrese 7y agoTransferring the doctrine of first sale to the digital realm would have massive implications for pretty much every digital distribution service we have today. Streaming services wouldn't be affected, but Kindle, Steam, iTunes, and so many others are built on the assumption that their product has no secondary market.
- criddell 7y agoThat's probably true, but it shouldn't factor into the decision about whether or not digital goods should be transferrable.
- Freak_NL 7y agoAt the moment, no, because a ruling in the Court of Justice of the European Union this September concluded that the resale of e-books is illegal. Interesting to see how these two rulings will affect the notion of reselling digital items. https://www.trouw.nl/binnenland/doorverkoop-tweedehands-e-books-illegaal~bacc9585/ https://www.trouw.nl/binnenland/doorverkoop-tweedehands-e-bo... (in Dutch)
- jandrese 7y agoIt sounds to me like this is going to be a mess of competing lower court opinions until a high court somewhere comes down on one side or the other.
- bobcostas55 7y agoWhat's the difference between the two cases?