4 ms·
After spending a scant few minutes looking at it, here are the things I like about this project so far: - It has a "How and why are we different" page. In the
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago
After spending a scant few minutes looking at it, here are the things I like about this project so far:
- It has a "How and why are we different" page. In the age of "I made a meta package on top of Ubuntu and called it a new OS", it's refreshing to see a Linux distribution come right out and say "here's what we do that separates us from the other 700".
- It actually is different. Recognizing the nigh-uselessness of separate user accounts (for personal computers), embracing of simple GUI tools over terminal wankery, eschewing of the legacy UNIX file hierarchy.
- They use the ROX filer, the only file manager for Linux with AppDir support and the centerpiece of the unfortunately long-defunct ROX Desktop.
I'm anxious to find out more.
- swiley 7y agoMaybe it's because of my limited experience with containers but I can't imagine why on earth you would prefer GUI tools (especially a graphical shell) in a container.
- tracker1 7y agoApplication isolation and the ability to upgrade separate applications and components with their dependencies separately from each other. Less issues with "update X" now broke A, B and C apps... you now have to add a PPA for Apps A and C, but B you'll have to build from source, oh crap, no longer actively maintained... switching to D app which was forked a couple months ago. Not to mention the ability to easily support different build tool chains combinations, etc. Right now, my preferences are flatpak, snap, ppa, repo in that order. Not really looking to play with a new linux, Manjaro is next on my list. Currently running Pop!_OS, which has been nice (just jumped this past month, haven't tried a linux desktop in 5+ years before that). I've been relatively happy. That said, my biggest issues so far: * need to update kernel and new mesa drivers before putting the 5700 XT video card. * needed to update kernel for wifi support (intel ax). * rainbow puke from RGB controllers, the Gigabyte (X570 Aorus Master) support is all but worthless, and the open-source project I saw was actually for windows. For the Lian Li o11 Dynamic Razor edition case, there's open-source Razor drivers, but I'll need to setup a windows drive in order to capture some data in order to support the specific device. I haven't even looked into the Corsair ram yet (which is actually the biggest eye sore at the moment). I really regret not building another black box. My first two choices of cases without windows were sold out, so I went for the "pretty" case option. Which would be great if I were running windows, but I have no intention to. A lot of money on RGB fans (all matching), water cooling, ram, etc... and none of the controllers have good linux support. Would switch to another controller, but the only one I keep finding is a German company and doesn't seem to actually be sold anywhere. Which wouldn't cover the ram or case.
- danShumway 7y agoI might be off-base, but when I hear someone talk about running GUI tools in a container, I think about being able to effectively fork application configs/intallations and environments. I run an extremely minimal arch installation on my production machine. It's... nice, I guess. I'd love to experiment with it more and make something even more customized, but I can't risk any downtime. And a large portion of my computer is command line tools, sure. But I'm also running EXWM, I'm also running Firefox, I'm also running Tiled, and Blender, and so on, and so on. I don't want to get rid of my command-line tools, but I'm not only running command line tools. I want to be able to download a game, put it in a container, mess around with my drivers until it runs well, and then delete the container when I'm done and know 100% all of the customization just went away. This was what originally got me excited about Docker, until I dug into it and realized Docker kind of didn't work particularly well for that. My understanding is if I sat down and did the research, I could build something like that with regular Linux tools, but it's time consuming and as interested as I am in the underlying tech, I just know very, very little about how this stuff works. But I always perk up whenever I hear someone talking about running graphical applications in containers, because in the back of my head I'm mapping that to some kind of fictional computing utopia where I can have complete isolation between processes and treat my computer like a Git repo.
- tipsysquid 7y agoI have been wanting something like you describe for forever. Honestly, the closest thing that I've found to this that works-out-the-box is Crostini in ChromeOS. I don't love ChromeOS, but if I started building what you're looking for, I'd look at Crostini for inspiration. Crostini can spawn gui apps through Wayland instead of pure X. That takes effort and I wish they would contribute it back.
- blablabla123 7y ago> - They use the ROX filer, the only file manager for Linux with AppDir support and the centerpiece of the unfortunately long-defunct ROX Desktop. I was so happy when ROX Desktop was still active and alive. It had exactly all features necessary to use a file browser, blazing fast and the UI was really intuitive. Actually it inspired me for years to maintain a ~/Apps folder, so reinstalling my system mostly just meant copying over my home folder.
- lucideer 7y agoInteresting point from their "How and why are we different" is the part about their heritage: > Puppy heritage > [...] it must be stated that Easy is also very different, and should not be thought of as a fork of Puppy. Inherited features include the JWM-ROX desktop, menu-hierarchy, run-as-root, SFS layered filesystem, PET packages, and dozens of apps developed for Puppy.
- dstroot 7y agoAnyone know how this compares to CoreOS? Whatever happened to them?
- Already__Taken 7y agoThe company coreos renamed their distro coreos to Container Linux (have fun googling help for that) then later they coreos were bought by redhat. container linux is forked off my the community as flatcar linux. Redhats container linux is getting rolled into fedora silverblue or something? This paragraph I'm not really sure about.
- pas 7y agoThere is Fedora CoreOS, it seems pretty active. https://github.com/coreos/fedora-coreos-tracker https://github.com/coreos/fedora-coreos-tracker
- GordonS 7y agoI'm actually looking for a good container hosting OS right now. I remember hearing some stuff about CoreOS being deprecated or something, but I can't find anything concrete?! Do you know what the situation is? I also looked a bit at RancherOS today, which looked pretty cool, but it seems to use 10x the memory of CoreOS...
- w7 7y agoIf you're mainly just looking for something with Docker preinstalled VMWare's PhotonOS[0] may be an option. It's a stripped down CentOS/RHEL based distro that's targeted at being a container host. I believe they've said they'll also package other container runtimes in the future as the market shifts. [0] https://vmware.github.io/photon/ https://vmware.github.io/photon/
- GordonS 7y agoThanks, this isn't one I've come across! A quick look shows the ISO as ~4GB, which is a bit concerning though - CoreOS is around 450MB, and RancherOS only 135MB (although it's a bit difficult to compare, since they both download stuff during boot).
- msla 7y ago> embracing of simple GUI tools over terminal wankery, eschewing of the legacy UNIX file hierarchy. So you're telling me I have no tools and no existing tools are going to work. Good to get that out in the open, I suppose.
- jodujehhdd 7y agoYeah, in guessing GP drank the windows koolaid and is azure cool kid now. Lol what a joke.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoGod forbid someone not create another Ubuntu derivative that isn't substantively different than every other Linux distro on earth, right?
- msla 7y agoDo you have a point to make about how this is better, or is this change for the sake of change?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoGUI tools provide significantly better discoverability, for one. The file hierarchy is a mess to put it mildly.
- msla 7y agoDiscoverability is only possible if the tool is trivial. Otherwise, you have to hide functionality inside the UI to prevent the creation of an unusable mass of buttons on the GUI's main screen. This also kills fluency, by preventing people from developing muscle memory.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]