4 ms·
> they are denying him admission based on his decision to stay on at the public defender instead of quiting and finding likely nonexistent higher paying work to
by jasonlotito 16y ago
> they are denying him admission based on his decision to stay on at the public defender instead of quiting and finding likely nonexistent higher paying work to service his exorbitant albeit average student loan debt.
That's incorrect. It's because he's not...
"seeking full-time employment, which he acknowledges would give him a better opportunity to pay his obligations and possibly qualify him for an additional deferment of his student-loan obligation."
So, he admits that he could do a better job at paying his obligations and could also not default on his loan obligations. In other words...
He has already admitted that he has chosen not to work to pay back his loans.
- cma 16y agoThat isn't illegal or immoral.
- thebooktocome 16y agoTrue, but the theory behind character and fitness tests is that if he is desperate for money with which to repay his debts, he may be more susceptible to coercion, blackmail, and criminal elements.
- pyre 16y agoAh, so the rich automatically have 'character and fitness' and are immune to corruption. Makes sense.
- ericd 16y agoI would say it's immoral to ignore your debt obligations, yes. He went through a program that cost a lot of money, and which he promised to pay for over time. He's not a victim here. One can't always choose to do whatever they prefer, especially when in debt to others. There are many startup lawyers who bill >$400/hour, and I'm sure even the lowest paid lawyers who aren't public defenders make a fairly respectable salary. Paying off 150k of student debt on the kinds of timelines those things are usually on isn't outrageous.
- stevenbedrick 16y agoBut the catch 22 is that he can't work as a lawyer until he passes the bar...
- jasonlotito 16y agoBut he can do other things that will help him pay of his debt until he passes the bar and then work as a lawyer. Just because you go for school for something doesn't mean your guaranteed a job doing just that. You go to school to learn something. Usually you use that knowledge to advance your career (or start one). However, it's unfair to demand that just because you went to school to become a lawyer (or doctor, or whatever) that people must hire you into that position.
- stevenbedrick 16y agoI agree with you 100%, but the comment to which I was responding seemed to be suggesting that he solve his debt problems by choosing to work as a more profitable sort of attorney (as opposed to a public defender). Until he passes the bar, those specific options will be closed to him. Furthermore, the student isn't demanding that anybody hire him as an attorney- just that they grant him the legal credentials needed to be eligible to be hired as an attorney. There's a big difference.
- ericd 16y agoMy understanding of the story was that he was not going to be able to pass the bar because of his plans to try and get out of his debt by ways other than paying it back, even though he assumed he would pass the bar? Might be wrong, it was a bit hard to dig through the outraged writing.
- cheriot 16y agoMoral? No. He's has a contract with a financial company. Do you think they would behave morally if it meant giving up a dollar? Borrowing money from a friend is a moral obligation. That's not the same as signing a contract with a financial company that has buildings full of lawyers and accountants looking for ways to screw you.