3 ms·
Though you messed up the basic numbers, I think that the larger point needs addressing. Why are these homes vacant? Should people be allowed to take a month o
by epistasis 7y ago
Though you messed up the basic numbers, I think that the larger point needs addressing.
Why are these homes vacant? Should people be allowed to take a month of vacation without losing their home? Is it ok for an apartment or house to be empty for a few months in between residents?
One month in between tenants every two years is more than a 4% vacancy rate. What should the vacancy rate be?
And what if in addition to housing the homeless we also want to house workers with unreasonable commutes?
Every single person I know who has raise this X vacant homes and <X homeless has not bothered to ask these very basic questions.
We need more homes. 25% more than we currently have, in the high demand areas. We don't need hem in Detroit or Stockton, we need them next to jobs. And we need to stop the profiteering home owners who speculate on the value of their homes by blocking others from living close to them.
- fragmede 7y agoObviously there will be some time between renters where units will sit vacant, but that's not the issue. Units are vacant because landlords don't want to rent them out for various reasons. Totally different situation! So, during this housing crunch units sit vacant and very little supply is being added. Sure, owning property means they're allowed to do whatever they want with it (within reason), but we're also free to complaint about the situation. As to why landlords leave units empty; rent control. Rent control and strong renters protections, combined with dramatically increasing market rate, means landlords will get more money if they keep a unit empty for a year.
- epistasis 7y ago> Units are vacant because landlords don't want to rent them out for various reasons. Totally different situation! Are they? I don't see much of the Bay Area but I haven't notice many vacancies at all, and the rates overall are low from what I've seen, something like 5%. I'm all for vacancy taxes, and actively looking to see how to get one passed in my city. But I don't think it's going to do much other than provide a revenue stream for homeless services, like Oakland's Measure W. I can't see them helping with the housing situation based on these sorts of low vacancy rates. We need 25% more housing than we currently have, and a 0% vacancy rate is pretty much impossible and a horrible situation for renters, so I would hate to see the vacancy rate go any lower.
- rmrfrmrf 7y agoLA and Boston did this and now just have vacant high-rises to show for it. And, really, greedy homeowners are the least of our worries compared to real-estate developers and landlords. I've seen the idea of a vacancy tax thrown around. Not sure how effective it would be, but might be worth trying.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 7y agoFor a city of 4 million people, LA is building something like 9 thousand apartments [1]. That's not a 25% increase in the number of homes, that's nothing at all. It doesn't cover the number of births, the number of immigrants. Building that few homes is a plan to displaced people from the city. It's time to stop treating housing as if numbers don't matter, and the only thing that matters is our feelings about seeing a crane. There is a massive housing shortage, and people that deny it are just as fact-free as climate deniers. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/urbanplanning/comments/d0a9wb/top_20_us_metros_by_projected_new_apartments/ https://www.reddit.com/r/urbanplanning/comments/d0a9wb/top_2...
- chaostheory 7y ago> We don't need hem in Detroit or Stockton, we need them next to jobs. If more companies embraced remote workers or even just partial remote work, this problem would be greatly alleviated.
- epistasis 7y agoOn the other hand we could also let people live where they want, instead of letting a few people exclude others from living by them. People want to live in the Bay Area, it's wrong to exclude them.
- chaostheory 7y agoLook, even if by some miracle, building permits are easier to get and more lenient; there’s a reason for “excluding people” and it’s not gatekeeping surplus housing. Supply is just limited. It will always be too limited due to geography and other conditions. Ie the thing stopping people from living where they want is that there’s not enough places available to everyone. Regardless of the economic system used to distribute this finite resource (money, lotteries, etc...), no matter what the end result will be the same: not everyone will get housing. While there are a lot of nice things here, people mainly want to be here because of the jobs. If you help distribute the jobs via remoting, it will really help in reducing demand for very limited resources
- epistasis 7y agoThere's more than enough space, there's tons of space that we need to make more dense with infill housing. This isn't just a social issue, it's also a climate issue. Even if we assume extremely ambitious goals of 100% EVs and 75% of energy from renewables in 2050, we need to drastically reduce the amount of vehicle miles traveled in California, which means denser housing with mixed uses. Right now that sort of necessary housing and business is illegal in most of the peninsula. We need to change that. It really is just gate-keeping to keep others out. Distributing jobs is not a solution, because sprawl is not a solution. We must make better use of existing land, rather than consuming more farmland or nature.