4 ms·
I really really love Airbnb, and I've mostly stayed at Airbnb and ignored hotel in the last 5 years perhaps. I now find hotels dirty, impersonal, and a chore to
by baby 7y ago
I really really love Airbnb, and I've mostly stayed at Airbnb and ignored hotel in the last 5 years perhaps. I now find hotels dirty, impersonal, and a chore to stay at to be honest.
Now, I've become increasingly irritated by Airbnb's pricing tactics. They are blatantly lying to you when it comes to how much you're going to pay.
I have two recent examples if you are not used to booking Airbnb:
* 99$/night room end up being 159$ for a night [1]
* 150$/night room end up being 500$ for two nights [2]
And these are not exceptions, but pretty much the norm nowadays. The final prices are ALWAYS way higher than what you would expect.
[1]: https://twitter.com/cryptodavidw/status/1173775045606301696 https://twitter.com/cryptodavidw/status/1173775045606301696
[2]: https://twitter.com/cryptodavidw/status/1159574818661867520 https://twitter.com/cryptodavidw/status/1159574818661867520
- simonebrunozzi 7y agoI'm not sure, but this might fall into the category of "dark patterns". It's the same as Lyft and Uber giving you a "wait" estimate that almost always ends up being longer, but if the expected wait seems to be shorter, you are more likely to book the car and wait for it to show up. Similarly, you are more likely to book the room/house/apartment on AirBnB if the price shown is lower than the final price. Bad behavior. But everybody does this, one way or another.
- avar 7y agoAirBnB clearly uses low room rates and high service fees to pull you in, but there's a legitimate reason to display it like that. The cleaning fee is fixed. So maybe you start out thinking you'll stay 5 days, but end up staying 10. If they showed "all inclusive" rates you'd have confusion in the other direction. What you thought was the cheap hotel suddenly isn't because the cleaning fee for the two is very different. Similarly, it's important to display the local taxes separately, because some customers may be e.g. entitled to a rebate for that part (some localities e.g. only charge foreigners).
- chrislh 7y agoThe product I work on has a search experience similar to Airbnb's. We initially made the choice to show all-in prices on the initial search screens. Bookings TANKED. Guests called in to complain why our listings are "more expensive on our own site than Airbnb" (they were cheaper at the end of the day, but we weren't hiding fees). End of the day, we had to switch to Airbnb's fee-hiding style because users are trained to expect the hidden fees.
- romwell 7y ago>Similarly, it's important to display the local taxes separately, because some customers may be e.g. entitled to a rebate for that part (some localities e.g. only charge foreigners). Yeah, and we can come up with a story of why a hefty AirBnB fee should be hidden until the last moment as well. Or we can notice that 99.99% of AirBnB users aren't going to have their taxes and fees rebated, and would be better off seeing the total price right away. Yes, including the cleaning fee. The users enter specific days anyway. The rate changes depending on which days those are. You can't infer the price for another date range without getting a quote specifically for that date range anyway. Separating the cleaning fee out achieves nothing.
- Spooky23 7y agoAirBnb employs all sorts of clever people. It’s pretty easy to show an average rate that incorporates the various fees and make the detail available later.
- systematical 7y agoA junior-level developer could do this. You don't need any serious brainpower to pull this off. They have all the pricing already. They omit the fees purposefully. Source: I've worked as a Sr. Engineer at an OTA for the last 5 years.
- earthshot 7y agoThe legitimate reason is that momentum causes even frustrated and annoyed people to finish most transactions even after they realize that AirBNB has tricked them about the price. Let's not pretend there's something nobler then that. The whole travel industry is chock full of this bullshit where vendors hide the full price (taxes, resort fees, etc.). It sucks.
- systematical 7y agoWorking for an OTA for the last 5 years I can confirm this. Also, stay away from travel insurance, cancellation protection, or whatever else they call it. It's a scam. And yes, as a previous user stated, it's very easy for us developers to include the fees and taxes in the average rate display. Fees are either fixed dollar amounts or a percentage of the room charge. It's trivial to add this into the average rate per night. Our corporate overlords instruct/force us not to. Furthermore, my advice is to avoid the major OTAs such as Expedia. First, they engage in price-fixing. Hotels are not allowed to display prices cheaper than they appear in Expedia, otherwise they are threatened with delisting. Expedia calls this their "rate parity" policy. They should be taken to court by the DOJ. Second, they take a massive percentage from hotels as commission. Use Expedia to find availability, but then go direct to the hotel. Also, because hotels know they are getting absolutely FUCKED by Expedia. They will not put inventory on Expedia during peak seasons. They know they can get max occupancy without being charged a 30% by Expedia. Ski resort hotels are a prime example, but there are several other cases. In short fuck Expedia and probably AirBnB too. Just google "expedia price fixing" and the list goes on, here is the most recent one: https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2019/05/09/290827.htm https://www.claimsjournal.com/news/national/2019/05/09/29082...
- avar 7y agoI work for another OTA, opinions are my own. Rate parity isn't price fixing, and it's been going on for decades (pre-dates the Internet). The DOJ and EU regulators know about it. The hotel can price rooms however they want, they then enter into a voluntary contract with an OTA to give them a percent. If hotels could just consistently give consumers OTA prices minus that percentage directly customers would get savvy to that, and the legitimate service an OTA provides wouldn't be paid for. It would just lead to shadier forms of advertising for the same service, like the OTA obscuring the name, location etc. of the hotel. Maybe that'll happen, and maybe we'll be better off as a society. It'll impact a lot more than just OTA's, e.g. Google Adwords displaying a product for $100 when part of that margin is being given to Google. > Second, they take a massive percentage from hotels as commission. Use Expedia to find availability, but then go direct to the hotel[...] 30% is very high, but if the hotel is voluntarily paying a 30% rate on advertisement that's how much it's worth to them. Whether that's "fair" or not it's generally a bad deal for the consumer to book directly at the same rate, if something goes sideways they don't have the OTA's bargaining power to help them out. > They will not put inventory on Expedia during peak seasons. Good for them, but it seems 30% is worth it in the off-season if they go out of their way to sign-up to pay that. > In short fuck Expedia and probably AirBnB too. A hotel that's willing to pay Expedia 30% on X for ads isn't going to be better off with no X at all, which unless they're idiots is the alternative. You're basically saying "fuck advertisement". Sellers stand to gain from advertising their services to buyers, that's why advertising exists.
- meowface 7y agoI've found this annoying, but they always show you the total on the initial booking listing (if you've specified the dates and number of people). You know upfront what you're going to pay; there's no bait and switch. It makes searching by nightly price a little more tedious than it should be (search by total would be nice), but I've never felt deceived.
- romwell 7y ago>You know upfront what you're going to pay; there's no bait and switch. The map only displays the nightly price, IIRC. And not being able to filter by total is a hostile UI.
- meowface 7y agoTrue, the search UI (map + filtering) only shows nightly. But the total is always prominent on each listing page.
- Jagat 7y agoYeah, it's the same reason tipping exists, and resort fees exist. They do it because it helps them make more money by tricking people into thinking it's cheaper than what it actually is. Pretty sure Airbnb has A/B test results somewhere to back that up.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoI feel the opposite and love hotels. If I wanted to clean up after myself like all my Airbnb hosts demand I’d just stay at home. I grew tired of all their demands (stripping all the beds before leaving, really?, washing all dishes, really?) and just started staying in hotels again and never looked back.
- baby 7y agoTo love hotels you are probably spending at least 400/night on them right? Anything lower and the standards are usually all over the place. On a tighter budget (50-150$) I always prefer airbnbs.
- foobandit 7y agoI've stayed in ~70 Airbnbs over the last few years and have never gotten those sorts of demands. That seems unreasonable and I'd just ignore them.
- vadym909 7y agoI hate airbnbs because they either charge $20 to send someone to pick your garbage or you have to haul garbage publicly and find a place to dump it. I understand it costs money but just build it into your daily rate and don't nickel and dime me for every silly request- additional towels- $5/pop, Early checkin- $50, late checkout- $100. As if all the flights in the world now fly you into and out of city between 11am and 4pm.
- cylinder 7y agoSeriously my first and only airbnb experience was a luxury house in Spain. He left a negative review because we didn't clean? What? He had a cleaner meet us and we paid a cleaning fee. We dropped all the towels by the washing machine. We were given no clear instructions. Who pays all this money to then worry about cleaning an entire house on holiday? I can't stand Airbnb and would rather use a specialist holiday rental agency dedicated to the area I'm headed to.
- Lucadg 7y agoIt always shows average prices to me when I insert people and dates, so it probably behaves differently according to users/markets or it does a/b testing.
- baby 7y agoInteresting. Where are you located? Maybe I can use a VPN to get the same behavior.
- artr 7y agoAirbnb knows exactly what they're doing and will comply with regulation only if it needs to: You'll see different rates on different pages on EU, Australia (where drip pricing is illegal) and USA versions of the site for the same property.
- baby 7y agoDoes browsing Airbnb in France or from France force true prices ?