40 ms·
What's funny is that a Mini14 ranch rifle would be more acceptable to anti-assault rifle people. Even though it's roughly the same thing.
by tyingq 7y ago
What's funny is that a Mini14 ranch rifle would be more acceptable to anti-assault rifle people. Even though it's roughly the same thing.
- kls 7y agoWhile I agree with you, the driving factor in most of these shootings is the fact that the AR is one of the cheapest platforms that one can purchase. You can get a functional AR for a little over $400, Mini-14's are closer to a grand. The Columbine shooter used a Hi Point rifle which at the time where much cheaper than the AR-15 platforms offered. The driving factor in most of these are that the guns used are the cheaper platforms. I have always said one of the deadliest firearm platforms for mass killings would be a Saiga-12 with a bag full of 20 round drums loaded with 3 inch 00 buck. But you don't see them being used because a decent one that has has the ports drilled and has been converted is over 3K and the drums run close to $100 each. If the AR is eliminated the shootings will not stop they will transfer over to the next cheap platform, or handguns and honestly in a corridor setting, such as a school and unarmed civilians with no body armor, a handgun is going to be just as effective as far as body count is concerned. They just don't fit the image that these shooters want to portray. there is a reason that most of them wear a bunch of tactical gear when they commit these criminal acts.
- codezero 7y agoThis comment makes it seem like you think that people against high powered rifles are unaware of the technology and capabilities of weapon systems. I also think you are wrong.
- rayiner 7y agoBased on the assault weapons bans in place in states like Maryland, that’s exactly what I think. The Maryland State Police maintains a buyers guide for helping you find an assault rifle that’s legal within the state: https://mdsp.maryland.gov/Organization/Pages/CriminalInvestigationBureau/LicensingDivision/Firearms/FirearmSearch.aspx https://mdsp.maryland.gov/Organization/Pages/CriminalInvesti... There are numerous great choices!
- tptacek 7y agoI'm not clear on what the argument here is. Are current assault rifle regulations bad? Yes, clearly. But they didn't start out that way; most centerfire semi-automatic rifles that accepted detachable magazines would have been (properly) considered assault rifles under the original 1980s proposals. (The AR-15 itself, of course, was designed by Eugene Stoner to be a standard-issue US military rifle.) The only thing I think we can conclude about the incoherence of firearms legislation is that they have staunch and effective opposition from firearms advocates. I do not think it is at all valid to look at them and say "legislators don't know what an assault rifle is".
- cthalupa 7y ago>The only thing I think we can conclude about the incoherence of firearms legislation is that they have staunch and effective opposition from firearms advocates. I do not think it is at all valid to look at them and say "legislators don't know what an assault rifle is". Well, if we're calling AR-15s and centerfire semi-automatic rifles with detachable magazines assault rifles, then we don't know what assault rifles are. The term has been in use since WW2 and refers to selective fire rifles with intermediate cartridges and detachable magazines. I'm not entirely sure what you mean about the original 1980s proposals - afaik the only major 1980s attempts at legislation occurred after a school shooting in California, had limited opposition in California, and was enacted into law. It included classifying rifles as assault weapons if they had detachable magazines plus at least one of other relatively features, such as pistol grips, barrel shrouds, folding/telescoping stocks, etc. Most of those features have limited to no impact on the ability of the rifle to be a deadly weapon. >(The AR-15 itself, of course, was designed by Eugene Stoner to be a standard-issue US military rifle.) The ArmaLite AR-15 designed for the military was a select fire rifle that ultimately became the M16. The trademark was sold to Colt. Colt later used that trademark in producing the semi-automatic civilian version. An AR-15 or AR-15 clone a civilian can buy is not the same AR-15 that Eugene Stoner designed. As best as I can tell, most legislators have no idea what assault weapons are, what assault rifles are, or much at all about guns in general. And this includes those on the conservative side. I'm pro gun control, if we can find a way to effectively do it, but if we're actually concerned about human life, assault weapons don't even make sense to be the focus. Over 60% of homicides committed with firearms are done with handguns. Rifles only make up about 4%. Mass shootings are scary, and make news, and are terrifying. But they're responsible for a tiny fraction of gun related homicides, and the focus on rifles (and particularly features that are more related to appearance than efficacy in being deadly weapons) screams to me that it is almost entirely a political play and less related to any real concern over the healthy and safety of those living in America.
- notadoc 7y agoI think he's right, the average anti-gun person has no experience with rifles (or guns in general) and is mostly spooked by a tactical appearance, not by any particular cartridge or capability.
- ncmncm 7y agoThe average "anti-gun person" relies on people who do know more about abuse potential to recommend policy. Most lethal misuse is for suicide, but it is only in the US that suicides take out an honor guard on their way down. It might be more effective to ridicule shooters ("Dumbass peppers crowd before disposing of self") than to restrict weapons.
- bifrost 7y agoWe've got 2700 firearms homicides per year in the US right now, its low; That includes lawful shootings by police and DGU. The average anti-gun person is hyped up by the news and by ableist rhetoric when suicides are reported as gun violence. Only anti-violence work will lower the homicide rate, not bans.
- ncmncm 7y agoFirearm homicides are not systematically reported--not even "lawful" ones by police--so 2700 is the absolute lower bound.
- somebodynew 7y agoThe .308 cartridge commonly used to hunt deer carries substantially more energy than the .223 or 5.56 used in a Mini-14 or AR-15. If not energy, by what metric could the latter be described as "high powered"?
- neverartful 7y agoVelocity is a big part of the equation.
- kls 7y agoOnly when dealing with body armor. It's the reason the 45 ACP and the 12 gauge slug are still powerhouses even at relatively slow velocities, when compared to modern high velocity rounds. When body armor is taken out of the equation these rounds do as much of not more than their high velocity counterparts. You can compensate for some loss of mass with velocity but not all of it. It's similar the the differences between horsepower and torque. To paraphrase a popular meme, Horsepower is how fast you hit the wall, torque is how much of the wall you take with you.
- sigstoat 7y agoenergy takes into account both mass and velocity. you can check the relative energies (and velocities) of common rounds on wikipedia. .308/7.62 has more energy, as the projectiles generally mass more than twice as much, and go only slightly slower.
- partialrecall 7y agoAll* full sized rifle rounds are supersonic and cause the cavitation the 5.56 has become infamous for (e.g. bruh it goes so fast it's basically explosive! - overheard in a cafe). The terminal effects of 5.56 on flesh are severe, but not moreso than other rifle rounds. A full sized rifle round will cause more damage and can do it from much further away. * excepting a few that are deliberately manufactured to be subsonic, because they are niche products.
- jabl 7y ago
- sneak 7y agoI believe that it might be you who is incorrect if you mistakenly believe that something chambered in .223 is a “high powered rifle”.
- wl 7y agoIf you consider an AR-15 rifle to be high powered, let me introduce you to the AR-10, FAL, and SCAR.
- hunter-gatherer 7y agoFN makes incredible weapons. I grew up shooting a FAL regularly and never had issues. And after four years in the Infantry I can attest to the quality of the 240B. Elegant engineering.
- kls 7y agoAn interesting foot note of history, the FAL was nearly the US battle rifle: https://medium.com/war-is-boring/the-fn-fal-was-almost-americas-battle-rifle-5186bdbda998 https://medium.com/war-is-boring/the-fn-fal-was-almost-ameri...
- thrower123 7y agoFind a Remington 742 with a couple of the extended 10-round magazines. It's not too far off from an M1918 BAR. Great deer rifle, although if you're walking around lugging it, you'll get a workout.
- simonh 7y agoAs my instructor in the TA here in the UK said, when a recruit asked if the 5.56 was weaker than the 7.62: "Maybe so son, but if you catch one in the arse it won't half make you're eyes water".
- wl 7y agoI wouldn't want to catch a .32 ACP or even a .22 LR in the ass. That doesn't make either round "high powered" though. Calling an AR-15 a "high power rifle" is simply wrong. As far as rifles are concerned, 5.56x45 NATO is on the weaker end of things. Such a term can only be reasonably applied to .50 BMG and the like, with rounds like .308 in between.
- 7y ago
- tyingq 7y ago"I also think you are wrong" No, I'm not. Various states with some sort of assault rifle ban allow the mini 14, including California.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIf you attach the wrong knicknacks to the mini-14 it can be illegal in CA too (e.g. wrong muzzle device or the A-Team style stock)
- novok 7y agoThat is their behavior although, including laws passed in california against 'assault rifles'. It's an equivalent to banning body kits and spoilers on cars because it makes them look more scary.
- ben509 7y ago> This comment makes it seem like you think that people against high powered rifles are unaware of the technology and capabilities of weapon systems. They have passed laws that demonstrate that they don't understand these things. The Federal Assault Weapons Ban, for example, only banned various cosmetic features and manufacturers simply adjusted their designs and were compliant overnight. That legislation was put together by activists, lobbyists, researchers and politicians who were motivated to save lives. That entire effort failed to identify the functional aspects of the weapons systems they were trying to regulate. There is a massive information asymmetry between pro-gun and anti-gun, and not just in technical matters, but the pro-gun people are also encyclopedic on the law; after all, they are looking at potential jail time if they screw up.
- tptacek 7y agoPeople like to bring up the Mini-14 in gun arguments, and I never quite understand what they mean to prove. The Mini-14 is a tactical rifle (note caps). It's not a black rifle, but neither is a classic AK-47, which also features a wooden stock. The fact that it doesn't look like an AR-15 (or its successor, the M16) was a feature of the weapon, not because people in the 1970s were afraid of mass shooters, but because the M16 had acquired a reputation for unreliability. Is your point that the Mini-14 should be regulated the same way as a Colt AR-15? Of course, you're right. Obviously, Mini-14 regulation isn't that much of a problem today, since the AR-15 platform became the default sporting rifle platform.
- homonculus1 7y agoThe point is to show by contradiction that "assault weapons" regulations are not based in any systematic or factual threat assessment. There are better arguments in favor of the right to bear arms, this one is directed specifically at how the irrationialities of gun control betray its motivation.
- kls 7y agoIf we where serious about gun deaths we would not be debating the emotional issue of mass shootings and black guns, rather we would be focused on the real tragedy of handgun deaths which does not just eclipse the rare and significantly smaller portion of mass shooting deaths by long-arms rather it statistically makes them almost null in comparison. On average handguns kill 19 times as many people than all other guns combined. The number of people killed in mass shootings is a even significantly smaller percentage of that 1 in 19.
- tyingq 7y ago"Is your point that the Mini-14 should be regulated the same way as a Colt AR-15?" Partially. It's allowed in some places where the AR-15 is banned. People tend to react to the tactical appearance. There's almost no functional difference.
- qball 7y ago