4 ms·
I wonder if that will have unintended consequences. It might inadvertently assign a price to the data collected. It also shows a direct discrimination against
by m463 7y ago
I wonder if that will have unintended consequences.
It might inadvertently assign a price to the data collected.
It also shows a direct discrimination against poor and/or young people who might not afford the service.
- cbhl 7y agoYou need parental permission to collect data from young people in the US anyway (see COPPA). But an age gate and asking for a credit card number are very different levels of sign up friction for a young person to try to get around.
- buboard 7y agoThere is already a price in the data collected (for FB i think $120 / year). I think making it public is a good thing. I think the law will also force facebook to offer ad free subscription plans, something people have been asking for. My bet is nobody is going to use them though.
- zawerf 7y agoI didn't believe that number but it seems like it's true if you restrict it to just north america monthly active users: https://thespring.io/investing/facebook-makes-more-revenue-per-user-than-netflix/ https://thespring.io/investing/facebook-makes-more-revenue-p... Average revenue per user is around $25 for global users. This brings up a related issue that not all users are equal. Even in non-data mining business models, you still have some segment of the users subsidizing another.
- whatshisface 7y ago>It also shows a direct discrimination against poor and/or young people who might not afford the service. As opposed to what, treating everybody badly? McDonalds discriminates between people who can afford a Big Mac and people who can't, and that's not a problem.
- aliveupstairs 7y agoThe internet is not the same as a food place. People expect and have gotten used to services for free. If you put a price tag on a software library, you obviously discriminate against students and poor people.
- duckMuppet 7y agoActually, it kinda is the same. If you don't have the money to buy a big mac, you either eat a cheeseburger on the dollar menu or go home and cook a burger yourself. If you don't have the money for the software library, you either choose a lesser library, or go write your own. A larger problem however is many are considering the internet a fundamental human right, which it isn't. Might be nice to have, but a fundamental right it is not.
- briandear 7y agoStudents pay $200 for a single textbook. That they wouldn’t be able to afford some internet service is ridiculous. They could abstain from beer if necessary.
- m463 7y agoPoor people can get other services at a discount, for instance electricity, internet or cable service.
- wmf 7y agoFor a short time AT&T GigaFiber was charging $30/month to opt out of surveillance and I thought they can't possibly be selling my data for that much. I wonder if this new law will also lead to some unrealistically high prices.