7 ms·
Now imagine “U.S. drone strike kills 30 pine nut farm workers in France” and feel the difference (which is non-existent). Then it goes on tv and reads the list
by wruza 7y ago
Now imagine “U.S. drone strike kills 30 pine nut farm workers in France” and feel the difference (which is non-existent). Then it goes on tv and reads the list of this morning’s evil men who must be stopped.
- olliej 7y agoFor it to matter to the USG is has to be "X drone strike kills 30 pine nut farmers in [some US state]"
- zapita 7y agoWe already know that the current US administration and senate majority does not care about the lives of their own citizens either. Mass shootings, police brutality, the stoking of hate crimes and the absence of a modern social safety net, withholding support to domestic climate refugees, inadequate industrial regulation, are directly killing many US citizens right now. Those deaths could be prevented but our government willingly chooses not to. The normalizing of imperialistic murder abroad is not an anomaly; it is a core part of US identity. The US itself is a product of imperialistic murder, its crowning achievement even. To this day US soldiers deployed abroad use the term “indian country” to designate occupied territory where they conduct counter-insurgency operations. That term dates back to counter-insurgency operations conducted by the very same institution against Native Americans until 100 years ago. What was once abroad is now domestic - such is the nature of empire.
- olliej 7y agoYou’re misunderstanding. If X was not the USG, then the USG would care and probably go to war with any countries potentially related to, or sounding similar to, X
- peterkelly 7y agoor "X drone strike kills 0 people but damages an oil processing facility in Saudi Arabia"
- sneak 7y agoI’d go with “secretary of defense guns down thirty civilians with a machine gun in Times Square”. Why these mass murderers are allowed to flourish in our society is a continuing source of dismay for me.
- devoply 7y agoBecause freedom and democracy. Wars of attrition for political purposes are nothing but state sponsored terror by another name. More than 16,000 dead and 30,000 injured. Talk about Afghan 9/11 ever year for the past 10 years probably 20 to 40 on which way you are counting. Who destabilized the country? Was it the Soviets or was it the Americans?
- dathinab 7y agoBoth, what you mean is who keeps it instabil. But that's also not as simple as just looking at US drone strikes. Though they are a non small reason due to the mental trauma they caused in a lot of people in some regions, which IMHO is likely to caused more people to radicalize.
- dominicr 7y agoOr imagine "Taleban drone strike kills 30 farmers in Oklahoma". There would be a reaction!
- cies 7y agoOr Yemenis kill 30 Saudi date farm workers in Saud. Or, God forbid, Iran kills 30 Saudis in Saud. We've been exposed to so much propaganda that we instinctively know what is "worse", and who is "allowed" to kill without due process.
- throwaway66920 7y agoI think you’re conflating morally worse with practically worse. It’s not propaganda to note that certain countries attacking each other spell out graver consequences
- cies 7y agoThat fact that you distinguish between morally worse and "practically worse" make me thing you are already under the influence of the propaganda. But it does not mean you are right: Afganistan cannot attack the US over 30 dead civillians, the US can attack Iran for some Saudi property destruction by Yemenis who are being raped by Saudi using US weaponery on them.
- cies 7y ago> But it does not mean you are right I meant: But it does not mean you not are right
- oAlbe 7y agoYeah? And why is that? Is it that certain countries' farm workers' lives are worth more than certain others? It sounds to me that the propaganda got you too.
- throwaway66920 7y ago
- est 7y ago> Now imagine “China drone strike kills 30 Muslim workers in Xinjiang” FTFY
- rqs 7y agoMaybe not the right time and place to being this up, but I personally believe that such illegal activities conducted by the U.S. is hurting people of other nations who is fighting for their own democracy. Just imagine China start to playing news such like this in those concentration camps, free golden material for showing people how rightful it is to follow the lead of CCP I'd say. While it is true the U.S. is benefiting from it's strong global influence, but it is also true that nobody wants to be threatened. If the U.S. don't want to be the good guy in this game, at least don't be the bad one.
- mieseratte 7y agoAs much as I would love the US out of Afghanistan, there’s a war on over there. Yours is a disingenuous comparison.
- alpaca128 7y agoA war where the US were totally forced to participate, of course, like always...
- kmjg88nvf8 7y agoSo do you care about the civilians, or not? It seems possible US engagement saves more civilians than it kills. At least that is presumably the general idea.
- megous 7y agoUnlikely. There were massacres during the Taliban rule outside of war, but it was at much lower scale than in the current war, and US only helps taliban grow by its intervention, it seems, if you look at the numbers of fighters. It's not like killing a person with certain beliefs stops the beliefs from spreading.
- kmjg88nvf8 7y agoSo you think it would be OK to live under Taliban rule? They didn't come into power by democratic elections, it seems. Also, killing people with beliefs does stop beliefs from spreading. How much of Afghanistan do the Taliban control these days, anyway?
- megous 7y agoQuite a lot: https://thedefensepost.com/2019/05/01/afghanistan-resolute-support-taliban-territory-control/ https://thedefensepost.com/2019/05/01/afghanistan-resolute-s... The idea was that "possible US engagement saves more civilians than it kills", and I was reacting to that, as it is very doubtful. I didn't say it would be ok to live under Taliban. But there are other weird islamic countries, where I wouldn't want to live either. Do you propose US making war there, too?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zupzupzup 7y agoAll animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others.
- dkraft 7y agoRight. It all depends on who believes the fake news.
- whiddershins 7y agoNow imagine “France knowingly harbors 911 terrorists.” “French leaders take credit for car bombing which kills 23 civilians.” There’s a historical reason for this discrepancy.
- brosinante 7y agoThe US "knowingly harbored" nazi war criminals.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rob74 7y agoThat's still no excuse to indiscriminately kill civilians - unless you deliberately want to increase the support for the terrorists...
- wruza 7y agoThere is a historical reason for everything. Who attacked US in the first place? It is not even reachable from countries they ‘democratized’, except for caribbean guys.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- megous 7y agoAfghanistan didn't do that, taliban did.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pnako 7y agoAfghanistan does not harbor 9/11 terrorists. The 9/11 terrorists were all from Saudi Arabia, they did not learn how to fly in a cave in the Afghan mountains and their funding did not come from a financial center in Kandahar; Bin Laden was found hiding in Pakistan. That war is absurd and should have stopped a long time ago. It's just fueling more terrorism. All western countries should leave the middle east, for good, forever (except maybe the odd ship to secure shipping lanes and stuff like that, but you get my point).
- rayiner 7y agoI’m pretty sure there aren’t people in France trying to establish a violent worldwide theocracy, and even if there were, the French government would have a handle on it/not be complicit. We don’t conduct missions in Afghanistan for funsies. We do it because there is no State we can lean on to stamp down on the extremists.
- harshalizee 7y agoOh you mean like how the US government has a handle on it's own homegrown extremism?
- rayiner 7y agoAs someone from a Muslim country that’s battling extremists—your false equivalence is ignorant, and your ignorance is dangerous.
- captain_price7 7y agoAs a muslim from a Muslim country, how so?
- rayiner 7y agoExtremists in Bangladesh are locally organized, capable of coordinated attacks, and part of an international movement. Extremists in the US are neither of those things. Often, Incidents in the US are chalked up to “white national extremists” based on nothing more than some murdered having searched such websites. There used to be an organized extremist threat in the US back when the KKK was active, but that was crushed. What’s left is remnants. That’s not true in Bangladesh. Extremists systematically killed journalists a few years ago. Before it was banned, the Islamist party got 3 million votes in national elections. Extremism is being bankrolled from foreign countries through schools that teach such views. There is a deep well of support for such views among the people—1/3 of Bangladeshis believe that people who leave Islam should be executed. And, finally, there is a real risk of extremists taking over the State, as happened with Pakistan and Afghanistan. None of that is true in the US. People who say “hurr durr but Republicans are a white nationalist party” do so out of ignorance, because they have no idea what it’s like to have extremists actually threaten your democracy. And their ignorance is dangerous. It’s dangerous to a world that needs US leadership to overcome extremism. Their false equivalency and apologism undermines the people in countries like Bangladesh who continue to fight for liberal democracy and the rule of law.