2 ms·
Isn't this worthy of a "duh"? I mean, seriously. A prion is a protein. Say you have a prion disease and you sneeze: it's now in the air, where it won't die i
by Groxx 16y ago
Isn't this worthy of a "duh"?
I mean, seriously. A prion is a protein. Say you have a prion disease and you sneeze: it's now in the air, where it won't die if it dries out or is exposed to UV radiation like lots of non-air-traversing diseases.
In the experiment: a mad-cow-disease-for-mice was aerosoled (sp?) at lab mice, and they're surprised it infected the mice through the nasal nerves, which are damn-near exposed directly to air.
>"We were amazed at how efficiently they spread"
The efficiency may be surprising. How can the spreading be?
>The prions didn't need processing by the immune system first, as some other research has suggested
Really? It's a protein! Sure, some could need processing by the immune system, or gastric acids, to change how they are shaped, but certainly not all.
This being science, yes, it does need an experiment to show that it is so. I'm by no means arguing this is a superfluous use of funds. I'm arguing that believing otherwise and acting on it when designing your safety protocols is borderline gross negligence, and I wouldn't be surprised if it has killed someone already.
- jacquesm 16y agoSimilar stupidity happened early on with HIV, especially dental procedures, I recall that there was a big stink about the aerosolized particles from the drill making it in to the suction tube and back out again when starting up the drill for the next patient. So now the whole assembly is replaced between patients instead of just the tips. It seemed rather obvious to me at the time. On the other hand, what's obvious in retrospect is not always obvious beforehand.
- Groxx 16y agoThat one is a bit less obvious overall though, I'd argue. It's a suction tube; things coming out isn't what most people expect. But yes, it does seem obvious. But expecting proteins to somehow change when aerosoled? And this is well after when the resistances to radiation and chemicals of some of the nasty ones of these was known. Look at a steak. Smell the steak. You're sniffing entire steak proteins (not that that's the majority of the smell, of course). Why would prions be any different?
- jforman 16y agoIt's definitely not a duh (I got three years into a computational biology PhD before coming out to silicon valley). Prions are fundamentally different from other diseases in that they're very dumb. Both viruses and bacteria have enormously complicated systems for infection that are specifically tuned to human physiology. A virus is many orders of magnitude too large to diffuse into a cell, so it has surface proteins that attach to human cell surface proteins in order to gain entry. A protein doesn't have this (one can easily assume), but it's also too large to diffuse into a cell. So, yeah...I wonder what the molecular mechanism of this is? I have no idea.
- Groxx 16y agoIf it attacks your nerve cells, and you can get it by consuming it, why wouldn't you expect to be able to get it by sniffing it?
- jforman 16y agoThat's...a very good question. So much for my vaunted Ph.D. I'm going to Google Scholar to figure out how the hell a consumed protein can get into a nerve cell...
- jforman 16y agoA 15-minute search yields: we don't know how prions infect a cell. "the underlying mechanism of infection remains unresolved" http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pbio.0060100 http://www.plosbiology.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjo... "the exact physiological function of PrPC and the mechanism of neurotoxicity are still unknown" http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cp/2010/00000007/00000001/art00004 http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/ben/cp/2010/00000007/0... ...I did run across this interesting paper suggesting that prions could be a widely-used regulatory mechanism rather than an aberration, however: http://www.nature.com/nrm/journal/v11/n12/abs/nrm3007.html http://www.nature.com/nrm/journal/v11/n12/abs/nrm3007.html
- Nelson69 16y agoIs that known and understood? Prions aren't terribly well understood, there aren't a lot of them. If I'm not mistaken there are doubters that don't believe the some of the diseases attributed to prions are actually caused by them. I know it's still just theory how it is that they work. At Colorado State University there are stables where deer were stabled while chronic wasting diseases was being studied and they are off limits forever now. On the upside, it seems like they tend to be slower acting diseases but it's still a bit scary to think they can aerosolize.