2 ms·
For conditions that are as poorly defined as fibrosis -- i.e., a symptom is noted, but not a cause -- RCTs can produce tragically misleading results, resulting
by ncmncm 7y ago
For conditions that are as poorly defined as fibrosis -- i.e., a symptom is noted, but not a cause -- RCTs can produce tragically misleading results, resulting in excellent therapies being dropped.
Apparently most treatments for depression fall in this range, which may be why new treatments arrive so rarely. Depression is a "wastebasket" diagnosis, with many, many causes. Any given treatment only helps with one or a few. Which variety you have can only be discovered by seeing which medications fix it, so putting together a set of candidates who have what one treatment would fix is impossible without actually trying it on them first.
If fibroses have this character, the only medication we can hope will get past the gauntlet will be palliative treatments, that reduce the body's common response to all the causes, without addressing any of the causes.
It's as if we were treating "ague", and not differentiating flu from malaria or bacterial pneumonia. Since a candidate antibiotic may only help the few with gram-negative bacterial infection, it looks not sufficiently effective, and is dropped. We are left with aspirin for fever and decongestants, while the infection rages unchecked.