5 ms·
> Then you add power-to-gas facilities that produce Methane from electricity and use the existing infrastructure for strategic NG reserves to store it. For long
by mlyle 7y ago
> Then you add power-to-gas facilities that produce Methane from electricity and use the existing infrastructure for strategic NG reserves to store it. For long periods of low production (e.g. winter) you turn the gas back into electricity.
The efficiency of this process is like 35%. (power to gas to power with methane).
If you're making a bunch of methane anyways, it might be OK to fill in a little with this, but this does not sound like a great overall strategy.
Why not just throw in a little nuclear for base load, and then everything looks a lot better/easier?
- adrianN 7y agoI'm in favor of doing that, but I don't think it's necessary or helps a whole lot. Nuclear power plants need to run close to max capacity all the time to make financial sense at all. So you can't use them to bridge over low production for wind and solar. They also take ages to build. Nuclear might make sense for district heating in winter, but people generally don't like having nuclear plants close to where they live.
- macspoofing 7y ago>Nuclear power plants need to run close to max capacity all the time to make financial sense at all. That's right. And we know that they work and they can scale with our needs. We know we can make them cleaner and more efficient. Maybe wind and solar just isn't the technology of the future for anything by niche applications.
- adrianN 7y agoNuclear would have been a good solution if we started thirty years ago. By today we don't have enough time to go 100% nuclear before we emitted to much CO2. We have less than ten years of current emissions left if we want to stay below 1.5°. Building nuclear power plants takes longer than that.
- RockIslandLine 7y ago"Building nuclear power plants takes longer than that." So fix that broken process. This is a nonsense result.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoProduction of all carbon free energy, sources: solar + wind + nuclear, is not enough to get to 100%in a decade, unfortunately
- mlyle 7y agoWe can't get to 100% with solar/wind in a decade, either. Do what we can with solar/wind, and also start building nuclear base load.
- macspoofing 7y ago>Nuclear would have been a good solution if we started thirty years ago. Talk about an understatement. Imagine the trillions of tons of CO2 that would not have been emitted into the atmosphere had the developed world invested in nuclear to the same level as France. It would maybe bought us another 50 years. Really puts into perspective the destructive force of anti-nuclear environmentalism. >We have less than ten years of current emissions left if we want to stay below 1.5° Hate to break it to you, solar/wind/battery isn't going to do it. It can't do it today, and there's nothing forthcoming to change that. Germany who went all in, is projecting 2060s as the time they wean themselves off of fossil fuels. France on the other hand is essential fossil-fuel free from power generation today, as is my home province on most days (thanks to Nuclear and Hydro) [1]. [1]http://live.gridwatch.ca/home-page.html http://live.gridwatch.ca/home-page.html
- pfdietz 7y agoAnd we know they will cost two arms and a leg, compared to renewables.
- mlyle 7y agoYah, I don't advocate a majority-nuclear grid. But at some point, the variability of renewables is going to start costing two arms and a leg, too. So a bit of dependable, low-carbon power in the mix sounds really good.
- pfdietz 7y agoBut that doesn't work. Adding a little bit of nuclear to a mostly renewable grid is useless. Most of the output of the nuclear plants is thrown away when the renewables are generating, so the marginal cost of covering the remaining slack periods is hideously bad. Other sources would be cheaper (in particular, burning CO2-free hydrogen in turbines, or using natural gas w. atmospheric CO2 capture.)
- mlyle 7y agoYou add a bit of nuclear-- 10 to 30%. Then you size wind and solar for the remaining 70-90% of load, say 70th percentile. During the remaining 30% of the time, you use agreements that allow you to shed load and you draw upon intermittent hydroelectric resources. The solar/wind overcapacity factor and the remaining bit of battery or power->gas->power you need can be much, much smaller because the reliable nuclear base load really stretches the hydro and load shedding. And you can use the "extra nuclear power" when wind/solar are overproducing to pump hydro, charge batteries, or make gas for power->gas->power. Put another way: the reliable nuclear energy just subtracts a constant amount from grid demand, and the remaining wind/solar production variability is reduced proportionally.
- pfdietz 7y agoYour proposal doesn't work, though. It requires that nuclear be subsidized by buying its power 24/7, even when much cheaper sources are available. This opportunity cost, if properly accounted for, makes the cost for the gaps that nuclear fills in for very very expensive. Trying to use the excess nuclear for hydrogen production, battery charging, etc. doesn't save you, for basically the same reason. Nuclear is expensive, and you can't shuffle that expense around under three walnut shells hoping it will somehow disappear.
- mlyle 7y agoYah, you use nuclear for base load, and then conserve hydroelectric resources for times when you need to bridge over missing wind/solar. It's almost like you're saying that having 30% of the power completely reliable and non-variable doesn't make the problem considerably easier. Nuclear makes an annoyingly constant amount that has little to do with demand. Wind makes an annoyingly variable amount that has nothing to do with demand.
- beat 7y agoIf solar costs less than a third what nuclear does (which is where we're headed, we're already down to half), why do you need nuclear base load? Why not just do this gas conversion? Nuclear is basically dead right now because of cost. The biggest factor in nuclear cost is financing and interest rates, which are very risk-sensitive. When existing nuclear plants are shutting down right now, because they're losing major customers to cheaper wind power, what happens to the risk on 50 year investment scales? Risk goes up, interest goes up, and plant cost skyrockets. So the very fact that nuclear costs more than renewables makes nuclear even more expensive than before.
- mlyle 7y ago> If solar costs less than a third what nuclear does (which is where we're headed, we're already down to half), Because power to gas to power delivers a fraction of the input power, and has a bunch of cost itself-- it isn't free.
- beat 7y agoI'm not saying it's free. Sheesh. I'm saying that there's some point on the price curve where it becomes cheaper than nuclear, even for base load. Now, that point may never happen. Or maybe it's already happened, and will be scaled out over the next couple of decades. The cost of PV solar has dropped over 80% in the past decade, and we don't know what the bottom is yet.
- mlyle 7y agoI am saying that even if pv gets cheap enough that the input power through 1/3rd efficiency is the same as nuclear... power to gas costs a lot IN ADDITION to the input power. And then burning that gas in a power plant costs something, too. So reaching parity seems difficult.
- pfdietz 7y agoThe cost of electrolyzers has also fallen dramatically. On the other side, gas turbines are incredibly cheap. A simple cycle gas turbine plant costs as little as $400/kW, vs. $10,000/kW for a nuclear plant. It's this huge cost advantage of combustion turbines that is making natural gas such a killer competitor these days (along with fracking).