5 ms·
I put to doubt the utility of crash safety ratings. The survival rates for collisions on highway speeds are in single digits no matter what you do. It's just l
by baybal2 7y ago
I put to doubt the utility of crash safety ratings.
The survival rates for collisions on highway speeds are in single digits no matter what you do. It's just laws of physics.
Modern luxury sedans have 1m+ crumple zones, and those only make for few percents extra chance at speeds above 60km/h.
Extending crumple zones beyond that is self defeating, as it will only lead to further increase of average car mass, leading to even more violent collisions
Preventing crashes from happening in the first place is far more economically efficient. EU is just few years away from making some forms of ADAS mandatory, and China is realistically talking about centrally controlled "autopilot" being introduced.
- ProfessorLayton 7y agoMost collisions don’t happen at highway speeds and the crash tests are designed accordingly.
- baybal2 7y agoYes, but collisions below 60km/h got quite survivable back in nineties. Airbag, seatbelt with pretensioner, rigid cabin, and some crumple zone is all it takes to survive a crash below that speed. For a healthy, non overweight person, below 40, survival rates already close to 85%-90%. The reason I'm ringing an alarm here is that survival rates began to slide back since mid naughties exactly because of the trend for more heavier cars being marketed as "safer" resulting in more violent car to car collisions, and more cars going through road barriers.
- lovehashbrowns 7y ago> The reason I'm ringing an alarm here is that survival rates began to slide back since mid naughties exactly because of the trend for more heavier cars being marketed as "safer" resulting in more violent car to car collisions, and more cars going through road barriers. Where are you getting this data from?
- adamweld 7y agoI think both sides here are right. there have been considerable advances in safety technology in the last 20 years, especially in avoidance systems. these improvements have unfortunately been counteracted by larger and larger vehicle sizes, which make everyone less safe on the road. interestingly the larger vehicles represent a tragedy of the commons, where individuals feel safer in heavier SUVs but overall society is much worse off. If all SUVs were traded for sedans crash survivability would improve about 35% on average.
- lallysingh 7y agoThey encourage spending and R&D in effective safety (vs safety theater).
- volkl48 7y ago> The survival rates for collisions on highway speeds are in single digits no matter what you do. As in what, a head-on collision between vehicles traveling at 70mph? Yeah, that's not likely to end well. It's also a highly uncommon event and not what the safety ratings are testing for, nor is it what anyone is realistically expecting their car to protect them from. The small overlap front test is reasonable. It's a 40mph along the outer edges of the vehicle, like if a passing truck on a local road drifts over the center line.
- baybal2 7y agoFor that, sure, but for that even 20 year old cars had good enough structural integrity. By late nineties Japanese cars were already full in into the science of crash safety with concepts like safety volumes, and rigidity belts being fully adopted in mass market cars. Most advances past that level just got cars getting unreasonably heavy, and more lethal, as a result, in car to car collisions, which in turn results in even higher expectations being placed. That's why "safety marketing" tells only one side of the story.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago20yr ago a 40mph partial overlap would have put whatever you were overlapping with in the foot-well.
- ChickeNES 7y agoYour claim isn't backed up by the data: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year#/media/File:US_traffic_deaths_per_VMT,_VMT,_per_capita,_and_total_annual_deaths.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in...
- djaychela 7y agoSorry, I don't think you're right here. Modern cars feature considerably more features (both in the bodyshell and in terms of active safety systems) which protect both passengers and pedestrians. It's simply untrue to say we reached peak safety 20 years ago and everything else has just been pointless window dressing. I buy and sell cars as a side gig, and newer cars (last 10 years or so) are far better equipped to deal with accidents - they have higher waistlines, better active safety features (airbags, stability systems, seatbelt pre-tensioners, lane assist, better-performing ABS systems), and the bodyshells have features such as side impact bars and larger crumple zones. I recently bought a Fiat Seicento as a stop-gap. It was really old-school - light, small, nippy (even with a 55 bhp engine) and great fun to drive. But it was tragically weak and definitely not safe if you had an accident - as backed up by Euro NCAP's assessment of the seicento. Cars like that and the original mini are not something I'd like to have an accident in. (For reference, I did 10 years of gravel rally driving, so I've had a few knocks).
- 693471 7y agoNearby someone recently died in an accident at an intersection where the speeds don't exceed 30mph. It wasn't head on. If we can stop these kinds of deaths, we've made incredible progress.
- mywittyname 7y agoCrash safety ratings are based on sound scientific and statistical analysis of real-world crash data and have been proven to save lives. The process is essentially this: the IIHS looks at the most common crash scenarios which involve fatalities. They replicate the the crashes in a lab to gather data on the forces exerted on occupants during the crash. Then a test scenario is formalized and future vehicles will be scored based on the forces exerted on occupants during the crash and whether such forces are survivable. Auto manufactures are supplied information about the tests are are given an opportunity to design their vehicles to perform well in crash testing. Note, that the IIHS is a independent scientific organization dedicated to reducing fatalities and injuries in motor vehicle accidents and is supported by car insurance companies. These companies wouldn't be funding the IIHS if it didn't have a measurable payoff (humans are expensive to fix).
- Qo2 7y agoI was unable to find a relationship between IIHS safety ratings and IIHS driver death rates for trucks and SUVs based on the most recent set of data released (though this was in 2014, so maybe they have improved their testing methodology since then). Interestingly, the only two vehicles to receive "TSP+" ratings in 2014 were actually among those that driver was most likely to die in - the GMC Terrain and the Chevy Equinox. So far, the only variable that I've found that is predictive of driver mortality is curb weight, and the relationship is not linear. There is a mortality minimum between 4000 - 5000 lbs of curb weight. Again, this is just for trucks and SUVs, and just those 37 models that offered both 2WD and 4WD versions. Maybe the ratings work better for sedans or for other types of vehicles.