3 ms·
I'm at a startup now. But I think you'll find most of the big shops you know about, like Google and MS, generally practice pre-commit review. Open source proj
by kenjackson 16y ago
I'm at a startup now. But I think you'll find most of the big shops you know about, like Google and MS, generally practice pre-commit review.
Open source projects often will do post-commit review. The review process is viewed as friction, and they don't want to block contributors due to the review process.
I personally prefer pre-commit review, although post-commit is a legitimate option (one I admittedly wasn't thinking about at the time).
- Roboprog 16y agoSo where do developers checkpoint their work until the official commit? Either: The smarter ones have to maintain a second source control archive (unless they are allowed to make personal branches, in which case the "public commit" is really just a merge, and probably a good thing), or the dumber ones just work without a net, loosing changes, and/or having to manually back out edit and test sessions that didn't go as well as hoped. Oh, and I just realized I'm replying to the same guy about this.