7 ms·
There are enough US citizens abroad to justify about 7 or 8 members of the House of Representatives, but how would you allocate them? There are enough in Mexic
by tzs 7y ago
There are enough US citizens abroad to justify about 7 or 8 members of the House of Representatives, but how would you allocate them?
There are enough in Mexico, and enough in Canada, and maybe enough in the Philippines to have one Representative for each of those.
The rest, though, are sufficiently spread out that when you group enough different countries together to get enough US citizens for a Representative, that Representative will have such a diverse group of constituents with such diverse concerns that it is not clear the Representative could actually effectively represent them.
- andylynch 7y agoMaybe the US could look to France again - since they do just this in their National Assembly, and also have representatives for citizens aboard in the Senate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constituencies_for_French_residents_overseas https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Constituencies_for_French_re...
- fhrow4484 7y agoMaybe France could not look at the US and also start taxing citizens everywhere in the world: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.boursorama.com/actualite-economique/actualites-amp/impot-universel-une-mission-parlementaire-appelle-a-elargir-les-criteres-de-residence-fiscale-93a5dd32283ba4eb6d06211cda1aa01c https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.boursorama.com/actualite-ec... (french source)
- cm2187 7y agoThat’s pretty bad, you could end up with two countries claiming you are fiscally resident in their country at the same time. France has actually considered taxing French citizens abroad like the US. It comes regularly during presidential campaigns. I think the last serious attempt was Hollande. They backed down because it would require to renegotiate every tax treaty and they didn’t want to open that door. But I think it will happen one day.
- dcolkitt 7y agoMaybe just allocate them through proportional representation? Seems like that would pretty much fit the problem of representing diverse sub-groups naturally. For example say the demographic of "student-age backpackers teaching English overseas" was about 20% of the expat population. Then all else being equal you'd expect candidates who best represented this group to garner about 20% of the vote totals, and therefore gain 1-2 seats.