3 ms·
Torn down by whom? There is a whole system of laws and companies and staff that would object to such a dictatorial move. We agree that it’s fucked. We likely d
by sneak 7y ago
Torn down by whom? There is a whole system of laws and companies and staff that would object to such a dictatorial move.
We agree that it’s fucked. We likely disagree on where it needs to go, and possibly on how it needs to get there.
Actionable steps to improve are what is needed, especially now that stance on healthcare regulation has become a point of political identity in the USA.
I think it will probably get worse before it gets better.
FWIW, I agree totally on the lack of information part. The current system is the worst possible setup.
- toomuchtodo 7y ago60% of Americans believe the government (in some form) should ensure healthcare for its citizens (per Pew Research). 70% of Americans support Medicare for All. We’re going single payer (Medicare For All), it’s just a matter of when (the younger you are, the more you’re likely to support it). https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/10/03/most-continue-to-say-ensuring-health-care-coverage-is-governments-responsibility/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2018/10/03/most-contin... https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/412545-70-percent-of-americans-support-medicare-for-all-health-care https://thehill.com/hilltv/what-americas-thinking/412545-70-...
- godzillabrennus 7y agoMakes sense to go single payer (and I tend to be pretty libertarian over all). Insurance is about having a pool of payers large enough for offsetting costs. The larger the pool in a nation with population growth the higher probability that a larger pool will be better. The largest pool is everyone. I don’t like calling it a human right. That implies the doctors are enslaved to provide care. No rational and highly intelligent person will pursue medicine as a career if it’s going to require 12 years of education before conscription into unpaid labor.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- blackflame7000 7y agoI like your argument, my only concern is that the government also operates the VA and the DMV which doesn't give me much confidence. The problem is also on the cost side of things. Hospitals charge astronomical for basic things like saline solution ($595 with insurance from personal experience). We have to get costs down because both of these industries are enriching themselves by privately negotiating rates.
- seppin 7y ago> Makes sense to go single payer Government as a single buyer of services from private health care providers. What's the problem?
- Ididntdothis 7y agoSomehow other countries have figured it out. Europe has a wide variety of systems from mostly private to completely public but none is even remotely as insane as the US.
- Frondo 7y agoOf course they would be paid, just like doctors are paid everywhere there's universal health care available. Access to a functioning justice system, as it ensures everyone access to laws, is arguably a human right, and yet no one ever says police, judges, or public defenders are slaves. Why is health care different?
- hwillis 7y ago> I don’t like calling it a human right. That implies the doctors are enslaved to provide care. No rational and highly intelligent person will pursue medicine as a career if it’s going to require 12 years of education before conscription into unpaid labor. That's a ridiculous Shapiro-esque take. Are programmers enslaved by accessibility requirements? Are constructors and building owners enslaved by handicapped bathrooms and wheelchair ramps? Not to mention, the thing you're describing already exists and is one of the least controversial parts of healthcare. Doctors are required to provide care, even above and beyond the Hippocratic oath. They cannot discriminate against their patients in many circumstances. Generally this is agreed to be a good thing. Healthcare as a human right does not mean that people are forced to become doctors and forced to provide care. It means that the available care should be distributed to everyone, just like the ADA means that available resources must also be distributed to give some level of equity to people born with disabilities. All humans deserve an equal footing, and should not be responsible for bad things happening to them which are not their fault. Disabilities are an obvious and clear example of that. Healthcare is similar. I have no particular stance on healthcare as a human right but you're being atrociously uncharitable in representing it.
- specialist 7y ago"...tend to be pretty libertarian over all" How do libertarians square their notion of freedom from coercion with their embrace of winner takes all economics? Best as I can tell, the two are mutually exclusive.
- remotecool 7y agoI don't look forward to this day. What many people don't realize is that the majority of new medicine is patented and created in the US. Once it's released, governments that have socialized health care create generics and get around these costs, mostly because they don't have to put any money into R&D. The world of medicine will be in trouble without our system, because govetnments are really not that good at innovation. Socialized medicine is great for simple checkups, but breaks down as you get older and need major surgery. I really don't want the government making these life or death decisions.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoPrivate insurance makes those decisions already (care rationing), as does the government when you’re on Medicare (government run healthcare with very high approval ratings from those on it [per Gallup and AARP]). You’re hand wringing over a system that is already here, and your fears are unfounded. If you want more drug R&D, up the funding for the National Institute of Health; it’s then publicly owned, and you’ve cut out yet another middleman (drug companies).
- roland00 7y ago>The world of medicine will be in trouble without our system, because govetnments are really not that good at innovation. Medicine is not like building a factory, completely different capital model for Medicine is about "discovery" there is a universal truth out there (yes there is differences in genes not making it perfectly universal) , and advances in medicine is figuring out this discovery. It actually appears most of our medicine discoveries use basic research that is governmentally funded and not privately funded. Pretty much you are applying top down ideology that government is bad no matter the situation or context.
- remotecool 7y agoI`m applying top down ideology because I've never seen a socialized government industry out-compete any private pharma company by coming up with new/innovative medicine. The reason is because you need to risk lots of money for R&D well beyond "basic research" and historically, governments arent nearly efficient enough to accomplish this. Private industry/the free market is the perfect way to do this and historically has proven itself over and over again. Another problem is that FDA approval takes over a decade and many billions of dollars. We need to find a way to improve this, without sacrificing quality. A couple of good examples of the free market working in the free market is LASIK eye surgery. 20 years ago it was thousands of dollars. Competition brought it down to less than $500. You don't get this natural competition with the government monopolizing healthcare and price fixing. We all win with more competition, and government-run healthcare is the exact opposite of this.
- brian-armstrong 7y ago> Torn down by whom? Trump can and should do it. He's one of the few in Washington who isn't actually owned by the Pharma companies.
- seppin 7y ago> He's one of the few in Washington who isn't actually owned by the Pharma companies. IF that's true, it's because they haven't offered him anything yet.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoExcellent performance so far by him, right?