5 ms·
Reading the linked Vice article >"Based on pilot accounts, encounters with these UAPs (unidentified aerial phenomena) often involved complex flight patterns an
by godelski 7y ago
Reading the linked Vice article
>"Based on pilot accounts, encounters with these UAPs (unidentified aerial phenomena) often involved complex flight patterns and advanced maneuvering, which demand extreme advances in quantum mechanics, nuclear science, electromagnetics, and thermodynamics.” - Walker
> Republican representative Mark Walker of North Carolina
This is laughably stupid. QM and nuclear science? Can we call out politicians for just throwing in words that they don't know what they mean? Seriously, I think we should call these people out. I'll even laugh at the extreme part.
My bet is that these things are just some test drones. They might have advanced materials and so you can't trust a lot of the data coming into the FLIR sensor. I don't think it would surprise anyone here that the people making the "most advanced sensors on the market" 1) have more advanced sensors being researched/tested 2) don't perform adversarial attacks on those sensors during testing. As for the visuals, well drones can pull Gs that pilots can't. So if we can't trust the sensor readings (speed and size) and we just see something zipping around, it shouldn't surprise anyone that a drone _could_ be the culprit.
As to the article, this is clearly misdirection. But that's part of warfare. https://youtu.be/qOTYgcdNrXE?t=1281 https://youtu.be/qOTYgcdNrXE?t=1281
- Pokepokalypse 7y agospaaaaaaaace foooooooorce.
- _vn5r 7y agoIs it possible he’s just repeating something he read on a navy report? Genuine question.
- godelski 7y agoI'm not sure why anyone in the Navy would say that to them, especially anyone with any type of engineering or science background. But if they did I'd be happy to shift the accountability, somewhat. Somewhat because politicians should also have BS meters, so holding their feet to the fire should also help tune this BS meter. Because let's be real, this is just absurd and should set off tons of BS meters.
- chubbyrabbit 7y ago> This is laughably stupid. QM and nuclear science? I see nothing stupid with using quantum mechanics and nuclear science in this context. > Can we call out politicians for just throwing in words that they don't know what they mean? I'm sure they know what those words mean on a surface level. They don't really need to understand them beyond that point, it's not their job.
- RandomTisk 7y agoMe either, it's that R word making people sensitive again.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jazzyjackson 7y agoThe man went to school for biblical studies. Now I don't have a grudge against anyone with a BA in biblical studies, but I'm not going to respect their opinion on whether something requires quantum or nuclear science.
- RandomTisk 7y agoThere are way too many layers to unpack your statement here, but I will say that if you have an open mind, you'll find most Christians are very pro-science where it's observable and repeatable using empirical methods. Nuclear physics certainly falls in that realm and I have no doubt Quantum mechanics too. Edit: unless you mean it's beyond the scope of his degree, then I can agree with that. Although even though I don't have a math degree either, but after watching a hundred or so Numberphile videos on YT, many on the cosmos and nuclear physics, I can see myself making similar statements in the future ;)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago
- RyanAF7 7y agoTone it down, CSS. lol
- elif 7y agoIf you're going to call his use of those terms incorrect, can you explain a craft travelling supersonic without jets or rockets, leaving no emissions, utilizing no airfoils, consistent with our understanding of physics?
- knodi123 7y agowell, a meteor could fit your description. but more generally, what he's saying is that the sensors are not infallible, especially when dealing with advanced materials.
- godelski 7y agoI'm basically saying Occam's Razor here.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoA meteorite? A projectile? A sensor ghost?
- jazzyjackson 7y agoI don't know, the video didn't show me that the objects traveled at any speed -- that's from the pilots testimony, but maybe it appeared to move against the backdrop as they were banking around it. I would expect fighter pilots to be a good judge, but maybe you lose some sense of velocity when you're surprised by something you haven't seen before. Separately, radar operators saw something they didn't understand. It could have been noise as they are now looking out for tiny drones and very small radar signatures, they have sensitivity turned way up. Sometimes you see things that aren't really there. I'm honestly going weather balloons on this one.
- mcphage 7y ago> I don't know, the video didn't show me that the objects traveled at any speed That’s because you’re watching a YouTube video that was filmed on a potato, instead of actually, y’know, being there.
- perseusprime11 7y agoI've seen those videos. The objects were at 80,000 ft traveling at Sonic speeds as recorded by jets flying in the vicinity. The object also took a sudden left so fast that our radars could not lock in the position. All to say that it is ok to entertain that these are not identified by human technology and they may not be our drones.
- luxuryballs 7y agoMaybe they’re testing tech that tricks pilots and tracking systems into seeing things that aren’t there, or things that distract the sensors and pilots so the real craft can make a hasty escape.
- perseusprime11 7y agoWhat would be the point of such testing when we don't have the means to follow such targets?
- duxup 7y agoIt seems like there is a historical pattern where people observe something they can't explain and then note that "it must mean X" maybe that is advances in something, or it's just magic, or aliens or whatever.... rather than "We just don't know enough to explain what we think we observed". And often later we find explanations that fit within the confines of things we understand just fine.
- ant6n 7y ago"We just don't know enough to explain what we think we observed" -- this is literally what UFO means.
- godelski 7y ago> what UFO means Technically yes, but that ignores the fact that words mean more than their dictionary definition. Words simply mean what people think they mean. If you're going to tell me that when someone says UFO that "aliens" doesn't come to mind in some way or form, I'll call you a liar.
- zorronimous 7y agoIt's an UFO until it's a drone. (Joking)