4 ms·
Anyone in this thread familiar with Electronic Warfare? Specifically, the EW arms race between a guided missile's "eyes", and decoy signals created by things th
by derefr 7y ago
Anyone in this thread familiar with Electronic Warfare? Specifically, the EW arms race between a guided missile's "eyes", and decoy signals created by things that don't want to get hit by said missiles? (Or, better yet, between large-scale MIRV missiles, that don't want their warheads to get hit by interceptor systems, and the sensors on those interceptor counter-missiles. In that case, you'd call these techniques https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_aid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penetration_aid s.)
Consider that we now have reasonably-cheap, high-quality cameras and feature-detection ASICs that we can plop into missiles. Oh, and wide-band software-defined radios, too, to cheaply range-find our targets all over the spectrum. (Remember, SDR radios are expensive for consumers, but that's an artificial supply-limit, precisely because of their military applications.) Consider what sort of decoys would be required to trick all that fancy sensor tech. Now consider what such decoy emissions would look like to human eyes, or any other sensor. If you can trick a Sufficiently-Advanced Missile, you can trick anything.
(For fun, also consider the modern menagerie of cheaply-available parts that you could shove into such a decoy: a laser rangefinder, a short-throw projector, an optical stabilization array, some negative-index metamaterial "scales" that can be flipped on and off—like those glittery pillows!—some more SDRs, a MIMO signal-shaping antenna array. Oh, and an ultrasonic humidifier, because emissions won't diffract off of thin, non-turbulent air.)
Presume you have a bunch of these mesh-networked together (or all slaved to a stealthed aircraft so far above that it's out of range of your instrumentation unless you know exactly where to look), and that they're built with hard real-time links to one-another such that they can execute perfectly-timed hand-offs of the emissions-signature they're working together to project.
In short, picture a bunch of projectors you can't find, working to create a moving multi-spectral hologram in the sky. Picture one of the projector-drones gliding into place "underneath" the projection, just in time to give off a sonar return—and then wandering away again.
None of this is impossible. None of this is even particularly challenging if you spend $100MM/yr on it. And this is just what someone who doesn't know about any of the classified stuff can imagine.
- guardiangod 7y agoYeah, I watched Spider-Man:Far From Home as well. Seriously though, the pilots reported visual sighting as well. Projecting a hologram is one thing, projecting one while flying at 800km/hr is another.
- derefr 7y ago> Yeah, I watched Spider-Man:Far From Home as well. I haven't; what was in the movie? > Projecting a hologram is one thing, projecting one while flying at 800km/hr is another. Like I was saying: short-throw laser projectors (or rather, in this case, long-throw projectors, but same diff, tech-wise.) Have a missile vanguard blow through the airspace first, making the air turbulent and perhaps "doping" it with some dyes so that the vapor-trail blends back into the sky. Then fly out your penaids, have them assume static positions around the diffractive "canvas", and then start throwing emissions at the "canvas." Reorient some lasers a tiny little bit, and now it looks like you've got something glowy accelerating at Mach 6 along your "canvas." But it's not a violation of the laws of physics—it's just light (and RF, and IR, and...) But my real argument wasn't meant to be a constructive proof about what properties penaids should be able to have. My point was that, given the tech that's cheap enough for any nation on earth to put into each and every counter-missile, if certain nations (ahem) want to retain air supremacy, they're going to want to develop something that can fool that sensor tech. The result would be the EW equivalent of a "deepfake": a decoy that fools cameras better than our eyes, feeding AI more discriminant than our brains. What hope do we humans have of telling such a decoy apart from a real UFO?
- carlisle_ 7y ago>I haven't; what was in the movie? Pretty much exactly what you're describing haha (with obviously a fair bit of artistic license). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4onAJ-3FAM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4onAJ-3FAM