3 ms·
I've been using inerleaved responses for 20 years. It's the only right way. The only time I top post is 1) If the reply is not a direct answer to a question,
by jedberg 16y ago
I've been using inerleaved responses for 20 years. It's the only right way.
The only time I top post is
1) If the reply is not a direct answer to a question, but instead a more general statement
2) If the email had a single question.
Why do I top post for #2? Because most mail readers these days give a preview. A short answer at the top will show up in the preview, so the recipient doesn't have to open the email. This is especially useful on today's mobile devices with small screens.
I never bottom post, because scrolling all the way down is annoying.
* I also top post when dealing with non-technical "old-timers" because they seem to get confused with the interleaved responses.
- ScottBurson 16y agoI've been doing it longer than that, but I don't quite agree that "it's the only right way". I top-post maybe half the time now, depending on the kind of reply (as you note) but also my audience's expectations. For example, when replying to a developer list for an open-source project, I'll usually use interleaving because it's the style in that community. In business contexts I'm more likely to top-post because that's what everyone else does (and as another poster noted, Outlook is broken). I guess we don't disagree too much; I'm just saying I don't try to force interleaving where it's not likely to be appreciated.
- jedberg 16y agoYeah, when I said "it's the only right way", that was kind of a joke. Should of had a smiley there. I think we pretty much agree -- I tend to lean towards interleaved, but will top post when it is expected.