14 ms·
India bans e-cigarettes, citing youth health concerns
- WarDores 7y agoI think we've hit the "moral panic" stage with e-cigarettes.
- abduhl 7y agoOr, alternatively, we've hit the "preponderance of the evidence" stage for e-cigarettes and vaping in general being bad for your health and governments are doing what they think is correct for the health of their constituents.
- stronglikedan 7y agoIt's kinda sad because it's not as bad as real cigarettes, and makes quitting them a walk in the park for those that want to quit.
- slykat 7y agoWhile that's the marketing view of most of the e-cig companies, we don't actually know if either of these claims are true. #1 e-cigs are not as harmful as normal cigarettes It will take several decades to prove or disprove this point. However, early research points to this not being the case. #2 e-cigs make it much easier to quit tobacco Again, early research doesn't indicate that e-cigs don't outperform other smoking cessation techniques. The main concerns I've heard are from a public health perspective. Most tobacco researchers and public health officials are concerned that e-cigs are essentially a "better" product. "Better" meaning perceived as being less offensive, cooler, convenient, and less harmful. The concern is that since the youth perceive e-cigs as cool and safe, while cigarettes as uncool and harmful, it's seeing significant adoption in younger people which is undoing the gains from the anti-tobacco campaigns in the 90s. Essentially, the hypothesis is that e-cigs are a slightly less (but really the distinction is minute and trivial) harmful product that is significantly more compelling to people. The net effect is the threat of e-cigarettes is that it can do significantly more harm to humans that cigarettes (since more people perceive it as safe).
- Clubber 7y agoI can vouch for #2 (and many other people if you'd listen). UK scientists vouch for #1. https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/dec/28/vaping-is-95-safer-than-smoking-claims-public-health-england https://www.theguardian.com/society/2018/dec/28/vaping-is-95... With this evidence, are you willing change your stance on it?
- EpicEng 7y ago#1 you are just plain wrong about. Let's see your evidence. #2 is nonsense. I did it personally and you can hop on any vaping forum to find millions more.
- WarDores 7y agoThere's much more evidence for fast food being bad for your health, and we're not up in arms about that one (collectively). I'm not _for_ vaping, necessarily -- and I don't like it in public: I'm for smoking in general to be banned from public spaces because of the way it affects other people -- but if you want to choose that in your own house, go for it.
- talloaktrees 7y agonot to mention alcohol
- human20190310 7y agoI hate when someone produces a cloud of vape steam in the middle of a crowd of people waiting to cross the street. It just hangs there, a visibly stinking, redolent horror invading everyone else's nostrils.
- reroute1 7y agoThis is all subjective. I personally don't mind at all, but cigarette smoke irritates the hell out of me
- nitrogen 7y agoThis is why public spaces have to target a relatively high standard -- everyone is bothered by and allergic/sensitive to different things.
- mcguire 7y agoWait until you realize that describes normal breath, too. :-)
- 4ntonius8lock 7y agoPeople have a hard time seeing what they don't have interest in could have interest to other people. Most people don't vape, so it's much easier to get on a moral high horse and tell others what to do; there's no consequence for the majority. If they reacted to vaping the same way to cars, coffee, sugar, fast food, etc... they would suffer a loss of freedom. And people don't like to lose their own freedom, but plenty of people are eager to restrict others. It makes sense for me: most people don't work on self improvement so imposing self improvement on others is a way to feel that society is improving.
- nightsd01 7y agoAnd I’m sure that everyone who currently uses e-cigarettes in those countries will simply shake their heads and give up the habit. Which history clearly shows is what happens when we ban a substance. Right? Yeah.... Not only is there vanishingly little “evidence” that e-cigarettes are harmful to health, most of the evidence we do have is for knock-off street THC or cheap Chinese juice. That’s hardly a logical reason to ban e-cigarettes entirely. Especially given the fact that many of these people will go back to smoking real cigarettes.
- willis936 7y agoThe black market will inly grow when the substance is outlawed. These bans are effectively deregulating and needlessly endangering constituents.
- gpm 7y agoUnlike with cigarettes, black market production of e-cigarettes sounds unlikely. They're complex electronics that need large factories to build. Illegal importation from legal foreign factories will probably happen, but those foreign factories are going to be building to the same standard regardless, and compared to normal contraband like "plant leaves" it's going to be pretty easy to tell where they are coming from.
- naoru 7y agobasic mech setup is a high drain battery connected to a coil with a wick through a high current switch. no rocket science here.
- wgerard 7y ago> Unlike with cigarettes, black market production of e-cigarettes sounds unlikely. Wait, isn't that exactly the problem that's lead to what's happened here? Unregulated THC cartridges causing health issues in states where marijuana is still illegal?
- 7y ago
- DanBC 7y agoE-cigarettes are considerably less harmful than smoking. Banning vapes while keeping tobacco legal is incoherent.
- falcolas 7y agoHas India also outlawed cigarettes, cigars, and pipe tobacco? If not, this isn't due to an preponderance of evidence and a care about constituents' health.
- ineedasername 7y agoIt is if e-cigs are causing a higher overall use if tobacco products. The time to stop it is early on, now. Traditional tobacco products on the other hand are so entrenched that it would take a truly astounding amount of effort to institute such a ban. I agree there's some amount of moral panic at play here, but it's not the only factor and maybe not even the dominant one.
- falcolas 7y agoPer TFA, there are around 35 Million vapers worldwide. The WHO (via Wikipedia) indicates that over 120 million people smoke cigarettes in India alone, with 1m dying every year due exclusively to smoking complications. So, no, e-cig use could not possibly be higher, or have a higher health impact.
- nitrogen 7y agoAre there numbers by age group? I know of people that wouldn't smoke, but got addicted to nicotine at earlyish ages via vaping.
- ineedasername 7y agoYou misunderstood. I didn't say that e-cigs were, by themselves, higher. I said they may be causing a higher overall use of tobacco (well, nicotine) products. Health risks are less clear. Vaping hasn't really been around long enough to examine life-long vapers for the really long term effects. Still, based on available evidence, I'd guess the risks are much lower than smoking. But if it converts non-smokers into vapers, that will increase the overall number of people at risk. Of course it can (and does) convert smokers to vapers, which may not reduce the raw number of people doing something risky, but it may decrease the overall pooled risk of that whole population. So I don't know. From a public health policy point of view, it's not an easy equation to balance. What amount of new people with health risk is worth it to reducing the overall risk? Should there be such a utilitarian calculation? Should they try to reduce both the number of people with risk and the overall risk pool by both banning vaping and making traditional tobacco products harder/more expensive, or more education to prevent initial use? What about freedom to make these not-so-great choices, people make bad but not illegal choices all the time, why should this be different? I don't propose answers to the above. I'm simply saying the India ban may not purely be a case of moral panic. That's all.
- nomel 7y agoIf they were doing anything for health they would ban actual cigarettes...
- corndoge 7y ago"Preponderance of the evidence" being 5 reported deaths from "vaping related" illnesses, 3 of which involved illicit cannabis products? Meanwhile untold numbers of people have been able to quit smoking, which we know absolutely causes harm, thanks to vapes.
- pennaMan 7y agoFunny how quickly the media disinformation outburst about those illicit vape products convinced the public conscious that there is suddenly massive evidence of general vaping long term effects.
- corndoge 7y agoRight? Completely insane, people are acting like vaping is the same as meth now
- tomatotomato37 7y agoThat's not a good enough reason to ban something. Actually let me clarify that, it is theoretically a good enough reason to ban something, but in reality it just lead to speakeasies and NASCAR.
- EpicEng 7y agoPlease point me to this preponderance of evidence. I'll wait.
- mcguire 7y agoHas there been new evidence? All I've heard recently has been the recent cases of an unidentified lung illness (which seems much more likely to be the result of some new product on the market, since it doesn't take years to become apparent). Any new epidemiological studies? Any new direct evidence of harm? (I mean, beyond the long-existing studies involving burning vaping liquid at extremely high temperatures and discovering lower quantities of dangerous chemicals than you would find in cigarettes or marijuana.) Any serious study showing higher levels of nicotine addiction than cigars or pipe tobacco? (Cigarettes have had decades of engineering specifically to make them addictive.) Are you sure this isn't just another puritanical flap?
- bag531 7y agoAre cigarettes banned in India?
- hello_friendos 7y agoDoes it matter? This is about vapes. Pointing at something else that is harmful and saying "What about this though", is unhelpful and lazy.
- magashna 7y agoNot when they're directly related to each other.
- KingMachiavelli 7y agoIt matters because, if the law drives people to smoking tobacco then this could have a net-negative health effect.
- olcor 7y agoI don't think the law is driving people to tobacco. The law seems to basically give up on incorrigible cigarette smokers who won't (can't, even if they try?) be swayed by the best of intentions and data, and trying to ensure that less well-informed people don't fall prey to fancy e-cigarette ads which don't do much to specify how much nicotine they contain and how addictive they are. I agree that it's not the best of implementations. Unsure how effective it will be though, but it's one of the easiest to cook up. edit: I fully support downvotes if you think this comment is insensitive, but at least provide a bit of logic so I can understand what I might be missing?
- EpicEng 7y agoYou don't have a clue. The alternative for many of (myself included) is cigarettes, not quitting. You can call us lazy, weak, whatever, it doesn't matter; we like smoking and we're not going to stop.
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoAny government that bans e-cigarettes without banning normal cigarettes should just give up and dissolve.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoWhich other risky activities should be banned? American football? Alcohol? Unsustainable consumption of natural resources? I don't see a need to ban things that don't hurt others. I'd rather plow more resources into educating members of society of the consequences of their actions. Edit: I was under the impression that e-cigs don't produce second hand smoke harmful to others like old cigarettes, but if they do then I would change my position. I was under the impression e-cigs are harmful to their users only.
- sachdevap 7y ago> I'd rather plow more resources into educating members of society of the consequences of their actions. And how has that worked for smoking levels in Japan, South Korea - I would say they have pretty high levels of education, with no dearth of information on bad consequences of smoking. Edit: I think people are assuming I am for the ban. I am not for the ban. I don't think bans like this work. But plowing more resources into the education system is just not particularly effective at preventing addictive behaviors.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThen that is their choice? Children play sports even though they break bones, people at desserts even though carbs and sugar are bad for you, people fly to island resorts for vacation even though it's destroying the planet. On the scale of things causing negative externalities to society, e-cigs are not at the top of my list. Although, the smell of cigarette smoke and its effects on others's lungs is of course harmful to others, so I could get behind stricter regulations or banning of those.
- sachdevap 7y ago
- donohoe 7y agoSign. India in the lead on this one and US lags behind. I'm disappointed that with the big tobacco settlement (1998) they didn't start automatically raising the legal smoking every year by another year - and basically phase out tobacco forever.
- techntoke 7y agoSame with alcohol and caffeine and addictive prescription drugs.
- noobiemcfoob 7y agoAnd water.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 7y agoBan dihydrogen monoxide now.
- viklove 7y agoThey should do the same for alcohol, marijuana, and other addictive substances as well then. Why give adults the power to control their own lives? We know better, don't we?
- olcor 7y agoI'm a life-long straight-edger who knows next to nothing about e-cigarettes except that it looks like they're much better nicotine-delivery systems which don't have the extra harmful stuff cigarettes have wrapped up, so please take all I say with multiple grains of salt. IMO is a good decision. And I say this with full cynicism; I really don't care either way. I don't have many people in my circle who're smokers or vapers, and I've never done either, so I can't really relate. I feel this is a good decision because: - Cigarette and beedi (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beedi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beedi) companies have been entrenched in this society for long, so they can battle things out for the existing products. Most people have started to wisen up to these though, so the effects on mass population are reducing day by day (education and those large images of cancer help). In e-cigarettes' case, getting something out before it becomes entrenched, is IMO, a good thing, however unpopular. It took so damn long for people to realize tobacco is dangerous. Better this info gets out quicker now, especially in a country like India where accurate and well-rounded information is hard to get. - E-cigarettes still contain addictive nicotine. While the current war against normal cigs/bidis might be about the smoke and other stuff, the central hook is still an addictive substance. E-cigs have the potential to dial up delivery of this addictive stuff up to 10. This isn't good for most people. - Say whatever you want about e-cigarettes. It's known that it's seen as a cool thing among kids, and the packaging is damn near perfect. a country could do better to avoid getting its future generations getting hooked up with a snazzy-looking thumb drive before realizing too late that their parents' money is now captive to fruit-flavored pods. I've noticed juul usage amongst teens in the US, and some seem hooked beyond repair (just like smokers are today). I don't really care however this goes, I'm not going to be the one who'll be vaping or smoking or whatever so I don't have much of a stake in this (I don't even like the current politics either). But to me, getting something out of the picture before it becomes a huge issue might be a good idea (unless, like in Harry Potter parlance, where the best thing Umbridge did to make sure The Quibbler was read was banning it...)
- Clubber 7y agoYa, who cares how many people this decision kills. It doesn't affect you, right?
- magashna 7y agoThat's rich considering their literal rivers of garbage.
- ganitarashid 7y agoIt’s good that e-cigarettes are not safe. There shouldn’t be a “safe” smoking alternative and we should never believe the tobacco industry.
- programmarchy 7y agoe-cigarette marketing was targeting youth demographics [1]. They could have stuck with marketing to adults, but they got greedy, and I have no sympathy for these companies now that governments are coming down hard on them. [1] https://truthinitiative.org/research-resources/tobacco-industry-marketing/4-marketing-tactics-e-cigarette-companies-use-target https://truthinitiative.org/research-resources/tobacco-indus...
- choko 7y agoAs a legal adult, all of 4 of those marketing drives appeal to me, especially sweet flavors. I don't see how that means they are marketing toward a demographic that is legally unable to purchase their product. To me, this is just another case of moral panic.
- ch4s3 7y agoThis is just FUD. Those social media campaigns ended four years ago, the Sundance Film festival isn’t aimed at minors, and adults buy the flavors to help quit smoking cigarettes. I don’t know what to say about that 1 scholarship program, because I’ve never heard of it before. Even saying that 31% of youth vapers citing flavors as a reason for trying vaping feel flimsy. Are they heavy or repeat users in any way? Do they switch to tobacco flavor in the absence of other flavors?
- EpicEng 7y agoNonsense. Honestly, how do people swallow the garbage argument that only children like sweet flavors? As you typed that out did you forget that you enjoy the taste of ice cream more than the ashes of a bonfire?
- programmarchy 7y agoThe marketing is obviously directed towards youth in certain circumstances -- for example they have packages that look exactly like Lucky Charms and Froot Loops. Would you also argue that Lucky Charms and Froot Loops cereal commercials are not advertising to children, because some adults happen to eat sugary cereal?
- autokad 7y agoblack market e-cigarettes harms/kills some people the solution people come up with? ban legal e-cigarettes
- ngcc_hk 7y agoEqual treatment of both; otherwise e is better than traditional one as it harms other less
- KingMachiavelli 7y agoIf we are to ban anything that could endanger public/youth health, then we should ban alcohol & driving as well. (In the US) It's absurd that same cities/communities that were behind legalization of cannabis also are the first cities to crack down on vaping. Why is one thing a champion of individual freedom while another is the scourge of soccer moms? Make the legal limit for everything 21, I don't care. I'm an (young) adult and would like to consume the same substences humans have been consuming for 100s of years; alcohol, cannabis, & nicotine (tobacco), It shouldn't matter that I'm mitigating the harm of the worse one (tobacco). The goal isn't to be 100% safe, otherwise I'd also have to eliminate driving, red meat, etc.
- slykat 7y agoDifferent substances are regulated differently because they have different risks for the population. Nicotine is significantly more addictive and harmful than marijuana which is why it is regulated differently than marijuana: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Drug_danger_and_dependence.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Drug_danger_and_dependenc...
- EpicEng 7y ago>harmful Need a citation here. I've read the literature and the current consensus (as far as I'm aware) is "we don't know what the harms are". There is a study which suggest that nicotine may increase cancer risk in mice, though it is not a direct cause and even then the study was inconclusive. Your link is a chart which shows relative lethal doses of substances. Nicotine requires a "very high" dose, not one you would ever get in practice. Not sure what point you were trying to make with that.
- vkou 7y agoThis is not an argument in good faith. The social ROI on driving is a net benefit, in our current society (95% of us would be dead in a few weeks, if all cars and trucks disappeared tomorrow.) They cause long-term problems, and we absolutely must be working towards a low-carbon future. Do you have a roadmap towards a low-vaping future? I assume not - so I'm not entirely sure your concern for public health is entirely sincere. It's also been argued to me that prohibition did not have a particularly large impact on overall crime rates, but may have had a positive impact on public health. Depending on which statistics you want to cite, you can very easily make this case. [1] So, no, it's not at all clear that prohibition was a disaster, and its entirely possible that had we let that experiment run a generation or two, alcohol consumption today would have been much, much lower. [1] https://www.aeaweb.org/conference/2014/retrieve.php?pdfid=801 https://www.aeaweb.org/conference/2014/retrieve.php?pdfid=80...
- hourislate 7y agoSince this is a relatively new vehicle in delivery of an addictive substance it would seem prudent to ban it while possible before wide spread adoption. India already has a problem with heavy pollution that basically amounts to smoking a pack of cigarettes a day just living in most of its cities. Add to the fact that cigarettes and tobacco are widely available, why even introduce more ways to destroy peoples health.
- ggreer 7y agoVaping is a substitute for smoking. If you ban vaping, you get more smokers and overall worse health outcomes. Using just US statistics, you get the following result[1]: > ...if a public e-cigarette ban reduces the number of smokers who switch to e-cigarettes by 2%, you’ve just killed an extra 9000 people per year – about three 9-11 attacks, or twice the number of US soldiers who died in the Iraq War. 1. https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/03/28/thank-you-for-doing-something-ambiguously-between-smoking-and-not-smoking/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2013/03/28/thank-you-for-doing-so...
- gpm 7y agoVaping can be a substitute for smoking, but a lot of people are now vaping who weren't previously smokers, especially young people. Maybe it should be offered as a prescription drug to quit smoking...
- EpicEng 7y agoKids drink a lot of alcohol too. Want to compare the numbers to alcohol related deaths for those under 21?
- ggreer 7y agoYou are assuming that vaping is comparable to smoking in terms of danger. It isn't. Vaping is incredibly safe. The only people who have gotten sick or died have been using black market THC cartridges. Smoking kills around 400,000 Americans per year. If you make vapes harder to acquire than cigarettes, you will cause mass death. Cigarettes are available without a prescription. You can get them at any gas station, corner store, or supermarket. If vaping isn't as convenient or as available, you will get more smokers and worse health outcomes. Again, a 2% increase in the number of smokers in the US is 9,000 deaths per year. I understand where you're coming from. It certainly doesn't feel good to let a bunch of teenagers get hooked on vapes. But you are weighing a hypothetical, unlikely harm against a concrete ongoing harm that is several thousand times larger in magnitude. One's intuitions simply can't be trusted in these cases.
- uptown 7y agoWonder how big a check the traditional cigarette makers cut to make this happen.
- Clubber 7y agoIt's happening in the US too, and we're all falling for it.
- danans 7y ago> “The data that we have largely is derived from the US’ experience and it the US the latest stats that I have before me states that there has been a 77.8% growth among school students who are at the 10th and 12th level.” > She also pointed to “surprising” growth in e-cigarette use among US middle school students — up 48.5%, per stats she cited. It's interesting that they are citing US data for this decision directly. Not that you can't learn from others, but you'd think the Indian government would be able to gather its own domestic statistics on this. If I had to spin a theory about the reason for this ban, I'd say that this is more about preventing the urbanized middle to upper class youth - who are more likely to mimic trends form the US - from starting the habit. It seems like more of a political signal that "we are in cultural control" to conservative voters (who are mostly middle to upper class in India). Also, note the similar ban on flavored e-cigarettes by the US administration just a few days ago. Perhaps one government is taking political queues from the other? Wouldn't be the first time that has happened lately. It can't be practically related to health, since as others have noted, the extreme urban air pollution is likely the primary broad-based driver of respiratory disease in India, not vaping.
- tryitnow 7y agoWhy can't it be related to health? It seems like it's an attempt to prevent Indian youths from developing nicotine addiction, which is probably a pretty smart idea even if it's done for culturally chauvinistic purposes. Personally, I'm ambivalent on whether or not nicotine by itself is harmful, however, I would use the precautionary principle here for the following reasons: 1) vaping isn't just nicotine alone, there are other chemicals and the jury is still out on their effects, why take the risk? which leads to... 2) risk profile: the risks associated with not vaping are virtually non-existent whereas the risks associated with vaping include consuming chemicals other than nicotine and any risks associated with chronic nicotine consumption (both the risks we know and the risks we don't know about). In other words there's no actual benefit from chronic nicotine consumption. Now, I do believe occasional nicotine consumption can be used to enhance cognitive performance. Of course, the business model for vaping doesn't support occasional use. Vaping is all about getting people addicted so they're forced to buy your product even though your product doesn't benefit them beyond just alleviating withdrawal symptoms - symptoms which wouldn't exist if they hadn't been addicted in the first place! For those who can control their addictive urges I recommend using nicotine gums, lozenges, and patches once in a while (as long as you're in good health).
- tossAfterUsing 7y agoi think they should just ban the nicotine, not the vaping. as a person with a nicotine addiction, i can tell you it's a hard one to crack. as a person who has smoked, i can tell you vaping is hardly a substitute. that being said, i know some friends who have gotten way worse nicotine cravings as a result of vaping more or using stronger liquid than what they'd have in their regular cigs. something worth noting, in countries outside the US, you can get approximate dosage labels on your cigs. something else worth noting, my own nicotine dependency seems to have been made way way worse by using hooka, instead of cigarettes. surely, this is n=1. edit to add: i don't actually think they should be banning any of this shit... but if you want to prevent people from getting hooked on a substance that can later be further used to manipulate behavior (e.g. by adding other things to it) then you should ban the nicotine. in the end, i think they're wanting to ban vaping because they want to prevent people from smoking thc.
- EpicEng 7y ago>as a person with a nicotine addiction, i can tell you it's a hard one to crack. as a person who has smoked, i can tell you vaping is hardly a substitute. I smoked a pack a day for fifteen years. Vaping was the only thing that got me off of cigarettes because it is far more enjoyable. Cigs now taste like eating a bonfire. You should preface that with "IMO" because obviously it doesn't apply to the tens of millions who have successfully switched over.
- xiphias2 7y agoI'm hoping that e-cigarettes decreases second hand smoking that I have to endure, which is affecting me quite badly. If a person comes to my house I prefer that he smokes e-cigarette over a real one at least while he's visiting me.
- mcguire 7y agoHere's a question: Are there any studies on the relative addictiveness of various forms of tobacco? IIRC, cigarettes have been explicitly engineered to deliver a high, short-lived dose quickly, while cigars and pipe tobacco, and apparently vaping liquids, do not have the same psychoactive effects.
- johnisgood 7y agoAlrighties. Are they going to ban cigarettes too?