4 ms·
Here we are... Proving my point. He expressed opinions which are not insensitive. It is totalitarian force people to only express the 'correct' opinion on an i
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
Here we are... Proving my point.
He expressed opinions which are not insensitive. It is totalitarian force people to only express the 'correct' opinion on an issue.
In fact the opinions he expressed are actually the law in some Western countries. I.e. that someone below the age of consent may be able to consent to sex and that, as a consequence, sexual activity with someone below the age of consent is not automatically rape though an offence.
There is a crucial difference between discussing an issue in general terms and targeting a specific individual who was a victim of that issue. Everything is being taken personally these days when it should not.
- RankingMember 7y agoI agree with you that any topic should be able to be discussed, but I think a modicum of forethought and perhaps a higher level of self-discipline should be employed when discussing sensitive topics such as pedophilia, because these subjects don't exist in a vacuum. RMS gave no real provable basis for his statement- he was just vomiting a baseless opinion, which he has every right to do. People, in turn, have every right to call his opinion callous and stupid. To his credit, he did reportedly change his view after enough people explained to him why children could not be expected to hold the responsibility of consenting to sex with an adult.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> RMS gave no real provable basis for his statement I'm not sure what specific statement you have in mind. However what I wrote before, i.e. that someone below the official age of consent may be able to give informed consent is simply the reality. Reality is not black and white and does not conform to a specific world-view. Accusing about someone of "vomitting a baseless opinion" is not very inducive to discussion.
- DanBC 7y ago> In fact the opinions he expressed are actually the law in some Western countries. Can you name any Western country that allows people under 18 to be prostitutes? Especially if those people are the victims of coercive force? > I.e. that someone below the age of consent may be able to consent to sex and that, as a consequence, sexual activity with someone below the age of consent is not automatically rape though an offence. Rape is a word defined in law and in English language. An activity may not meet the legal definition while meeting the English language definition. Saying that Minsky's actions were not so wrong because really it's not assault if violence wasn't used and that this rape isn't really rape is obviously problematic, especially when paired with Stallman's previous comments about child sexual abuse (familial abuse isn't a problem; willing child sexual abuse isn't harmful; images of child sexual abuse are fine).
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoThat is not what Stallman said.
- DanBC 7y agoYes it is. Here he says the word "assaulting" is wrong: > The injustice is in the word “assaulting”. The term “sexual assault” is so vague and slippery that it facilitates accusation inflation: taking claims that someone did X and leading people to think of it as Y, which is much worse than X. And here he says it's wrong because assault means force or violence: > The word “assaulting” presumes that he applied force or violence, in some unspecified way, but the article itself says no such thing. Only that they had sex. Here's where he denies this was rape: > I think it is morally absurd to define "rape" in a way that depends on minor details such as which country it was in or whether the victim was 18 years old or 17. This is in response to someone saying that having sex with someone who is 17 in the Virgin Islands is rape.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoHaving sex with someone who is consenting, and is able to give informed consent, is neither assault nor rape "in the English language". In law it depends on the jurisdiction. As I mentioned, having sex with someone underage does not necessarily constitute rape though is usually constitutes "sexual assault". The USA are rather conservative with both a relatively 'old' age of consent and statutory rape laws. This can lead to ridiculous situations like labeling someone "rapist" just for having consensual sex with a 17 year old... One issue, which might have been part of Stallman's point, is that people tend to want to use only black and white terms in all circumstances, even when the reality is much more nuanced.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoNo, he didn’t. Read his email. The context here is critical. He’s simply saying that the young woman’s claim, who was acting as a “masseuse”, is that Epstein directed her to engage in sexual activity with Minsky. But Epstein didn’t direct her to do this in front of Minsky, so Minsky likely had no idea that Epstein coerced her. So, we shouldn’t assume that Minsky is a rapist if he had no idea that she was not willing. If I threatened to kill a woman if she did not show up where I knew that you would be, seduce you, and have sex with you, does that make you a rapist? It’s certainly wrong, which Stallman acknowledged, while also saying Epstein should be in jail, but it’s not clear that you’re culpable. I think that would make me the criminal, not you. It hasn’t even been established that Minsky accepted her advances. Her only claim is that Epstein directed her to do it, not that it happened. A witness said Minsky declined her advances. Minsky is no longer alive. So given what we know, it is not appropriate to say Minsky raped or assaulted anyone, whether the act even happened or not.