5 ms·
I agree, Troy is way too gullible here. > Do you really think the only thing the bank does to log people on is to check the username and password? Yes. I assu
by tialaramex 7y ago
I agree, Troy is way too gullible here.
> Do you really think the only thing the bank does to log people on is to check the username and password?
Yes. I assure you that when bad guys with your username and password log in and steal all your money the bank _won't_ say:
"Doh, our sophisticated environment, behavioural and heuristic patterns used to establish legitimacy let you down this time. We'll pay for this"
No, they'll say it is your fault because the bad guys had your username and password.
And that's all you need to know.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoI'm inclined to agree. I was checking my bank account on my phone yesterday and the office Wifi was having an off day. So I disconnected the wifi and proceeded to try to login over 4g. I got locked out of my account for 10 minutes because that is suspicious. After checking my account I couldn't find a payment I was expecting to see so I opened my account on my laptop and got locked out for another 10 minutes. Sounds like the dumbest IP checking to me, not some super clever heuristic based check.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoIt's that assumption, literally: if the attacker had managed to steal your session information from the browser, then they would not be able to use it since they would also need to share my IP. In real life if the attacker is capable of stealing my session credentials the chance of them _not_ being able to tunnel through my local network is infinitesimal.
- VBprogrammer 7y agoThe thing is though, what they seemed to object to was trying to login (not using the same session cookie) across different IP addresses. At least that was the case when I opened the site on my laptop. Maybe my phone did login on the dodgy wifi and then when I reconnected via the 4g it tried to use that session, perhaps causing my account to be flagged. I'm not really convinced though. It clearly makes sense to tie the session to the IP address but the 10 minute delay doesn't make much sense to me.
- nybble41 7y ago> It clearly makes sense to tie the session to the IP address... At one point that might have been true but not any more. Mobile devices are the norm, and handoffs between cell towers and WiFi access points are handled transparently without any user interaction. Consequently, people expect their sessions to continue working despite changes in their IP address. Use TLS connections and set expiration times on the session cookies, but ignore the source IP address.
- rtkwe 7y agoYour IP doesn't change per tower transition, your data from the tower goes through more centralized servers. For example my IP sitting physically in RTP in North Carolina is actually exiting AT&Ts network in Atlanta, Georgia.
- nybble41 7y agoFor clean handoffs within the same network, sure. But you also have roaming to consider, and the device may lose its connection temporarily and be assigned a new address when it returns.
- wool_gather 7y agoIs there actually any advantage to having a dynamic pool of IP addresses like this? Associating a number from your IP block to a subscriber number seems far, far simpler and better.
- mnoorenberghe 7y agoIf you’re suggesting each subscriber gets a static IP then that’s much worse for privacy.
- wool_gather 7y agoI'm speaking from the provider's point of view: they don't care about privacy. In fact, in the US there is a federal law that requires them to be able to associate network activity with a subscriber at the request of law enforcement.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>In real life if the attacker is capable of stealing my session credentials the chance of them _not_ being able to tunnel through my local network is infinitesimal. In real life each "trivial" filter like this cuts down a substantial number of potential attackers. Defense in depth. When there's a ton of hoops to jump through attackers go find a different target.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoNah, in real life it constantly batters the system administrators with unnecessary alarms who then stop taking them as seriously as they should be if they were actual attacks.
- throwaway201606 7y agoI mentioned signals in another comment in this chain and this is a scenario (for banking specifically) where it makes 100% x 100% sense to kill the session for the client's security. Like kill it totally totally dead! Unlike other apps, with online banking, the priority is not to keep you connected. It is to ensure the person carrying out the activity is whom they really say they are and that it is OK for them to do what they are doing with your account The security posture is "deny" by default and allow if we can verify this person is whom they say they are. Think about the signals here: - connection has changed (from wifi to 4g - that gives you a whole bunch of IP, ISP, routing (hops) etc stuff ) - there is a proxy in the chain now (it is possible to identify the hop from phone to laptop) - view port is still the same (connection is not the user on their phone, they are on their laptop, connected to a phone) ... then the same thing happens all over again but in reverse when you went back to the laptop. The bank has no idea whether the proxy is a real phone or a MTM intercept especially since the connection did not initiate from that device but switched in flight. Would totally have required killing the session if I was responsible for defining scenarios here.
- geocar 7y ago> Yes. I assure you that when bad guys with your username and password log in and steal all your money the bank _won't_ say: "Doh, our sophisticated environment, behavioural and heuristic patterns used to establish legitimacy let you down this time. We'll pay for this" No, they'll say it is your fault because the bad guys had your username and password. If your bank treats you this way, you should contact the relevant government authorities. In the US that's the FDIC: https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/questions/consumer/complaint.html https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/questions/consumer/complaint.... In the UK that's the FOS: https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/contact/index.html https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/contact/index.html My own experience is that the bank fixes the account balance while I'm still on the phone with them so I'm not inconvenienced, does an investigation, and then decides whether it was actually me that did the transfer over the next few weeks.
- zainhoda 7y agoIn the 1990s, someone sent a fax to Chase with instructions to wire $25,000 out of my dad's bank account. When we discovered it was missing, they found the fax and realized that it wasn't my dad's signature and his name was misspelled. Chase put $25,000 back into my dad's bank account within about 2 weeks. So yes, they will pay for it.
- benj111 7y agoMy Nans will was held up because she spelt my Uncles (her son) first and last name wrong. Professionally I've seen various other equally stupid errors over equally important things many times. So I feel for Chase in this situation, I'm not suggesting they shouldn't have paid out.
- MichaelDickens 7y agoTwo weeks seems like an unreasonably long time to be missing $25,000. If my bank took that long to repay me that much money, I would probably switch banks.
- Swizec 7y agoOn the other hand I log into my bank with my computer using the same browser as always and my username and password, but this time I'm in a different country. Even just a different Wi-Fi (like at a coffee shop) And the bank _freaks out_. Omg omg omg hacking hacking! Quick to the 2FA mobile! Should we call you? Can we text you? Do you prefer email? That's before we even get into how trigger happy they are about credit cards being used in weird ways. You buy one thing out of the ordinary (like a $3000 downpayment for a motorcycle) and immediately get 5 texts, 10 emails, and 2 phone calls. YO did you do that? Or the one time my girlfriend deposited a physical cheque and it was so out of the ordinary the bank had a melt down and started shutting down all her accounts and blacklisting her from the bank. I don't know about "sophisticated", but they definitely do something.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoSometimes they make mistakes. My wife once went to the bank office to make some operation and they unexpectedly asked a "security question" about her father's given name - something they don't usually do (the standard practice is to ask for one's mother's maiden name). She gave the answer and they rejected it, and immediately locked down access to her account without her realizing it. She only found out when she couldn't log in to the on-line interface at home. Angry phone calls were made and situation was restored, but it took a day or two and was pretty stressful. Speaking of countries, it might be worth it to let the bank know if you're going somewhere atypical. Before my work trip to China, I phoned the bank and told them I'm gonna be there from this to this date, and didn't have any problems with accessing my account (modulo one branch of ATMs not cooperating with my card).
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoStop deliberately using “modulo” incorrectly like this. It’s cringey, doesn’t make sense, will never catch on, makes people pause for a full minute trying to understand what you really meant or if it’s an odd autocorrect, wastes people’s time, and ruins your entire comment. Just say “other than” like a normal person.
- astine 7y ago
- not_a_cop75 7y agoI don't think gullibility is the issue here. Really it's liability. Don't think for one second that Troy wouldn't get his pants sued off for any number of these banks for poo pooing their security. They certainly have the money to do it with.
- paranoidrobot 7y agoI don't think it's gullibility, but I doubt that it's liability, either. Why would the banks give a moment's thought to what Troy thinks about their security? Even if he went on national TV telling everyone that this is terrible, they would just roll out their normal "While we appreciate the feedback, we are confident that our systems are secure" line. The vast majority of people don't know who Troy is, they don't have any understanding of IT Security, and having some random computer guy rave about bank security is going to mean nothing to them. The few that might be marginally concerned over hearing it are almost certainly going to be persuaded by the bank's IT Suit that's rolled out to deliver the line.
- disjhshava 7y ago>No, they'll say it is your fault because the bad guys had your username and password. This sort of claim requires evidence. Many people have had money fraudulently taken out of their accounts, so there is a wealth of experiences to draw from out there. Lots of people are getting hacked via credential stuffing due to password reuse. If the normal response from banks were to blame the customer, everyone would be talking about it.
- jdc 7y agoRight. I've heard what actually happens is the bank does an investigation (which obviously costs them). One thing they'll want to figure out is if the account holder is trying to defraud them. During this investigation the money is not available. And they do not guarantee it will be over quickly. This could result in all kinds of unpleasantness, including eviction, repossession, etc.