10 ms·
So write books in English? What about German makes you want to write novels in German specifically?
by fastball 7y ago
So write books in English?
What about German makes you want to write novels in German specifically?
- vonseel 7y agoMaybe he is German and the majority of his non-professional communication is in his mother tongue?
- taneq 7y agoMaybe it’s their native tongue?
- agota 7y agoI'm not the person you were replying to, but I'm also a writer, and I think you are underestimating the command of language required to write fiction. I'm fluent in English, I write in English for a living, but I doubt I'd be able to write decent fiction in English. "Just write novels in your second language, bro" comes off as extremely ignorant.
- fastball 7y agoLolita is considered one of the greatest books of all time. It was written by a non-native speaker in English. Thinking a non-native speaker can't write great English novels is the ignorant view, in my opinion. Is it difficult? Of course it is. But all writing is difficult.
- neffy 7y agoNot by anybody who has actually read it.
- fastball 7y agoDownvotes on HN for saying people think Lolita is great? Interesting.
- cafard 7y agoI beg to differ. I don't know that I'd rate it as one of the greatest works of all time--in the European/American world, there's what, three thousand years of recorded literature? However, I would have no trouble finding widely read folks who think very highly of it.
- dbuder 7y agoI don't know where you get that impression, it is an undeniable work of genius.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- _Wintermute 7y agoNabokov was raised bi(tri?)lingual, comparing him to someone who learned English as a second language isn't exactly fair.
- avn2109 7y agoAlso, Nabokov was an utter linguistic genius and extreme outlier all-around-literary-intellectual, so comparing to him is mostly unfair, period.
- vkazanov 7y agoVladimir Nabokov was a native speaker in both languages. he grew up with English-speaking nurses, governesses, etc aroun him... He also spoke French fluently, as all Russian nobility did. Additional fact: he learned to read in English first, Russian next. Not to mention his years in Cambridge, UK. TL;DR he probably spoke English better than most native speakers do nowadays.
- raverbashing 7y agoThanks, TIL. > TL;DR he probably spoke English better than most native speakers do nowadays. True, especially "internet English" which is abysmal.
- jelliclesfarm 7y agoNabokov was also supposed to have experienced synesthesia*. 2 thoughts: 1. Nabokov’s synesthesia was largely why..IMO..made his writing captivating. The first sentence of Lolita makes you gasp. It ‘hits’ you where you didn’t expect it and you like it. The subject matter of Lolita was likely secondary to the synesthetic appeal of the language of Nabokov. It’s is a linguistic neural dissonance. It reminds of Szechuan peppers in Hunan/Szechuan cuisine. The addition of which gives you a numbing tingling sensation to the inside of your mouth. It is called ‘mala’ in mandarin. It is also said to cause neurological dissonance especially when used with spicy foods. Szechuan peppers themselves are not peppers but from the citrus family. They are often used with hot peppers..often mildly hot peppers but the numbing/tingling sensation makes the eater think that they are eating something super spicy ..far more spicier than it really is..and the body reacts with watering eyes and increased heartbeat and that endorphin rush associated with eating capsaicin. It’s the same thing reading Nabokov. You expect to read a story and you are entirely bowled over by the sensory aspect of his language. Even though Lolita is his most popular work, he has written so much more. Pale Fire, Speak, Memory, Real life of Sebastian Knight.. 2. My second thought is that authors who are non native English speakers/writers have remarkably rich vocabulary that is super descriptive. English is not a voluptuous language. Others that come to mind are Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Neruda, Borges, Italo Cavalo, Umberto Eco, Marukami, Junichiro Tanizaki and the many Asian languages to English translations. Something lyrical in these languages is beautiful transmitted into English..a quality that English itself doesn’t seem to possess. On a slightly different note: older languages like Sanskrit and the even earlier like epic of Gilgamesh relied on meter. As our speaking faculties expanded to accommodate more experiences and senses..and as we became more musical, language evolved too. It is the most beautiful evolution of the human state and we barely pay attention to language’s evolution. I also think Germans shouldn’t be translating anything to English or anything from any other language to English. I don’t know German but I can often tell if any translation has had a translator remotely connected to the language. The language doesn’t lend itself to fluidity and nimbleness. Altho I have read some translations of Carl Jung’s Red Book from High German to English that intrigued and somewhat appealed to me. I don’t know if it was the translator or Jung’s language/words itself. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synesthesia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synesthesia + http://nabokovsecrethistory.com/news/nabokovs-synesthesia-and-memory/ http://nabokovsecrethistory.com/news/nabokovs-synesthesia-an... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_with_synesthesia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_with_synesthe... : List of people with synesthesia
- billfruit 7y agoSame with Conrad too, English was his third language, after Polish and French, yet he wrote his widely praised oevre almost entirely in English.
- raverbashing 7y ago> "Just write novels in your second language, bro" comes off as extremely ignorant. Just as a note, it is not common but it does happen. Not to mention other forms of cultural production like songs (where adherence to grammatical norms is not as important as other forms of cultural manifestation). Which one is the "least correct" one, "Hotline Bling" or "I Want it That Way"? One was written by a native speaker, the other isn't.
- Iv 7y agoFor the same reason most English-speaking authors are not writing their books in Chinese.
- fastball 7y agoMost english-speaking authors don't speak a word of Mandarin. The OC obviously has a very solid grasp of English. If the comment had been written in German or broken English I would not have made the suggestion.
- Iv 7y agoFunctional English requires a very different level of mastery than writing literature in English. I am a casual writer in French, I consider myself almost fluent in English. I tried to write a short story in English during the last NaNoWriMo, it was incredibly difficult. I can explain in a lot of details why my C++ code is broken or the intricacies of a compiler inner parts. But I don't have as many words to describe a fence, as I have in French. In French I know how a farmer will call the place they put animals in and I know the official word that is the "correct" terminology. And I know which is which. It is very hard to find good translations of the tone behind this. That's a great learning experience, but being an author in one language while being fluent in another, does not mean you can easily write stories in both.
- jonathanstrange 7y agoI believe that for most people it is not possible to write good novels in a language in which you're not a native speaker. I wouldn't even dare to try, although my work language is English and all of my scientific publications are in English. Notice that literary translation is also usually from the foreign language into the mother tongue and almost never the other way around. Yes, there are notable exceptions like Vladimir Nabokov, but these are extremely rare and definitely not the rule.
- keiferski 7y agoJoseph Conrad would be the exemplar of this category, I think. English was his third language and he wasn't fluent in it until his twenties.
- fastball 7y agoNabokov wrote one of the greatest novels of all time in English as a non-native English speaker, and it's known especially for its turns of phrase. That is much more than a "notable exception". Additionally, the reason that there are so few "great authors" in the English-language non-native category is because there just aren't that many authors in that category. If he can do that, other people can write passable novels in English. It's not like you're writing the greatest novels of all time in German.
- Shaanie 7y ago>The family spoke Russian, English, and French in their household, and Nabokov was trilingual from an early age. He related that the first English book his mother read to him was Misunderstood (1869) by Florence Montgomery. In fact, much to his patriotic father's disappointment, Nabokov could read and write in English before he could in Russian.
- andrepd 7y agoWhy don't we all speak in English then, and be done. Linguistic diversity is an amazing beautiful incredible thing. There are things you can say in English that you can't say in German, and vice-versa, or Portuguese, or Swahili, or Mandarin, or Lojban. You'll forgive me for speculating that you don't speak more than one language, or you would appreciate that.
- criddell 7y agoWhat's something that I can say in English that cannot be expressed in German?
- andrepd 7y agoNo matter how good the translation of Lord of the Rings, it's never gonna be the same as reading the original English. The text is inextricably linked to the English language, the English countryside, a certain feel that cannot be entirely preserved in translation. It's probably not gonna be so bad in German, but in Italian? Forget it. 100 Years of Solitude is an absolute masterpiece. It's very difficult to put a finger on exactly why, but all agree there is a tone to it and to the way he tells the story, which usually people call "magical realism". The way it's so inexorably connected to a South American place and time, it's gonna be a different thing if you read it in English (credit though to the translators who do this incredibly difficult job in a stunning manner). The musicality and mood of the speech, for lack of a better description, cannot be accurately rendered in English. In short, it's more nuanced than "what's a sentence I can say in English that I can't say in German".
- ppseafield 7y agoTo provide a more literal response to your comment: there's no exact word for stain (as in: on clothing) in German. You can say Fleck, but it means spot in a more broad sense. Also, a date, in the relationship sense, has been imported. Verabredung is closeish, but more like an appointment. Likewise from German there's not a direct translation for Backpfeifengesicht, a 'face that is asking to be slapped', more literally 'face slap face'. Is there a more Englishy way to say Zeitgeist that captures the same meaning? You could replace it with "spirit of the time", but it feels a bit too general and clumsy. Is there a succinct English equivalent to Schadenfreude that isn't too long or clumsy?
- bloak 7y agoIt's probably best to write in the language you are most comfortable in (which, if you're an émigré, might be a language you acquired later in life) and get translators to translate it into whichever languages have a viable market for it. If you have a good understanding of some of those languages then you can even supervise the translation. You'll get a better result that way and it'll probably cost less, too, if you value your own time. Umberto Eco heavily supervised some of the translations of his books and has written about that process. He's rather a special case, of course: his books are not the easiest to translate even with the author's help.
- gherkinnn 7y agoAs it happens I prefer fiction in German. So please, do write more stuff in German.