4 ms·
I did my Ph.D. 28 years ago and Rod was on my thesis committee. At the time the big debate was over whether robots should plan or react (with Rod, of course, b
by lisper 7y ago
I did my Ph.D. 28 years ago and Rod was on my thesis committee. At the time the big debate was over whether robots should plan or react (with Rod, of course, being at the vanguard of the "react" contingent). My thesis basically said: they should do both. 30 years on it feels like things have come full circle and we are once again arguing over what AI architectures should look like. I think the answer now is the same as it was then: all extreme positions are wrong. We are not going to build AI simply by throwing more computing power and larger training sets at the One True Algorithm, neither are we going to do it by hand-coding everything. Human brains are the messy result of millions of years of evolution. I see no reason to believe that successful AI will be any less messy.
- randallsquared 7y agoBut the reason people keep expecting a specific algorithm to take off is that this is how it was in so many other areas: figuring out the principles needed for duplicating human or animal capabilities has always allowed us to exceed human or animal limits almost immediately. Flying, swimming, running, and lifting heavy things all require Rube Goldberg complexity for evolved systems, and stunning simplicity (by comparison) for designed systems.
- lisper 7y agoI actually believe that there could be a "one true algorithm" for learning and creativity. The problem is that in humans that algorithm interacts with a ton of other stuff that has evolved and influences our worldviews. For example, humans don't learn how to recognize cats. We have cat detectors hard-wired into our brains because having cat detectors provided a reproductive advantage in the ancestral environment.