6 ms·
Reading the plaintiff's complaint, it says that she took a Lyft home. She did not know that anything bad happened on the trip until she looked at her account an
by tzs 7y ago
Reading the plaintiff's complaint, it says that she took a Lyft home. She did not know that anything bad happened on the trip until she looked at her account and noticed that what should have been a 3 mile trip had been an 18 mile trip.
She also noticed vaginal pain and bleeding, realized that something bad must have happened during that trip, and went to the police to report kidnapping and rape. A rape kit was administered and the results identified semen of at least two men.
Then:
> 42. The NYPD opened an investigation. As part of that investigation, ALISON was asked to ride along in the back of a police car and retrace the route that was taken the night of her attack in an effort to help her recover a more detailed memory of what happened to her that fateful night.
> 43. As she rode in the back of the police car the night of the reenactment, the horrible memories she had blocked from her mind came flooding back and she remembered the terrifying details of how she was held at gunpoint by the driver, taken across state lines and repeatedly raped in the back of the car by at least two other men.
That kind of reenactment has a very high risk of causing false memories. Is NYPD aware of that, and do they take proper steps to avoid it, or did they make plaintiffs case a lot harder right there?
This might not tank a civil case, where you only need a preponderance of the evidence, but sounds like something that could make a criminal case hopeless since that requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. I wonder if that has anything to do with the apparent lack of progress of the criminal investigation?
Police departments really really need to have experts in human memory on hand, and require that those experts be present when investigators do anything that involves the memory of victims, suspects, and witnesses.
- klipt 7y agoSo they have a rape kit and they know who the driver was, can't they at least see if the DNA matches? Also if the driver took a very different route to what she requested on her phone that alone seems suspicious.
- TearsInTheRain 7y agoGotta be enough to subpoena the driver's phone's location or get some footage along the route.