4 ms·
Like always, mr. Krugman gets it wrong. Of course he blames the single currency, when he should have blamed things like "rules governing worker firing helped li
by paganel 16y ago
Like always, mr. Krugman gets it wrong. Of course he blames the single currency, when he should have blamed things like "rules governing worker firing helped limit job loss, while strong social-welfare programs ensured that even the jobless retained their health care and received a basic income.". There's one thing that I've learned as a programmer, there's no silver bullet, you can't have both "strong" social programmes and a dynamic and versatile economy. You can't both stay at home doing nothing for most of the day (look at the 35-hour week in France, for example) and still dream at a life-style consisting of holidays abroad and 2 cars per family.
- 9oliYQjP 16y agoI have a lot of family in Europe. It wasn't the social programs that led to their current problem. They were vacationing and dining out on credit cards, accumulating lots of revolving debt, and acquiring rental properties that were supposed to pay for all of this. Of course, since everybody else in the middle class was attempting the same strategy, it became a bubble. Essentially, Europe is in much the same mess as the U.S. is for a lot of the same reasons. However, because the U.S. is a single country and Europe isn't, getting out of the mess is a very different problem.
- khafra 16y agoWhen I read a critique of an article that starts with a personal attack on the writer, I take the critique much less seriously.
- paganel 16y ago> When I read a critique of an article that starts with a personal attack on the writer, I take the critique much less seriously. I don't have anything personally against Krugman, why would I? It's just that when you write a 8-page article in the NY Times bashing the Euro and you don't mention the protests in Hungary (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_protests_in_Hungary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_protests_in_Hungary), which practically demonstrated that an European country not affiliated to the Euro cannot devalue its currency, then I'd say you deserve being criticized by anonymous guys like me on the internets.
- khafra 16y agoI'm not saying your critique is wrong (although I'm not sure how programming taught you that putting in more hours always means getting more work done), just that "Like always, Mr. Krugman gets it wrong" crosses the line from attacking the argument to attacking the arguer.
- bryanlarsen 16y agoAs opposed to the US where everybody over the age of 30 is afraid to quit their jobs to start their own company because they'll lose their health insurance? And I see lots more Americans staying at home getting fat in front of the TV than I do Europeans. - 5 extra hours a week and 4 extra weeks of vacation a year just give you more time to work on your side projects to get out of that corporate job quicker. - in some countries, unemployment insurance provide resources to help you start your own company - "overseas vacations" are a lot cheaper cause you can buy a plane or train ticket for 50 euros to get to the Mediterranean - Nobody wants two cars because they provide more hassle than benefit in an area where everything is close by and available via public transit that's clean, convenient and used by everybody, not just the poor. - but most importantly, if you fail, you know that your kids won't starve and that your own retirement will be comfortable. As everybody knows, fear of failure is the biggest impediment to starting your own company. - in return, you pay 10% higher taxes, which you don't miss one bit once you make that first million. The biggest reason the US is more entrepreneurial is purely cultural. In France, one of the biggest aspirations is to go to Polytechique and become a bureaucrat. In the US, that's for lazy people who want a secure job. So France has a much better bureaucracy and a much worse entrepreneurial scene.
- anamax 16y ago> As opposed to the US where everybody over the age of 30 is afraid to quit their jobs to start their own company because they'll lose their health insurance? I've paid health insurance out of pocket and it's no big deal (compared to rent and other expenses). Considering that I'm over 50.... And before you write "pre-existing conditions", "remember" that if you don't go without coverage, you can switch with no waiting period. (I suppose folks without pre-existing conditions can be excused for not knowing that, but if they're going to make arguments about pre-existing conditions ....)
- InclinedPlane 16y agoAfraid? Perhaps. But even so the American job market and economy is far more dynamic. A lot of people over 30 do quit their jobs and start their own companies.