4 ms·
I am not a Google fanboy, actually I've been using duckduckgo for a couple of weeks as my default search engine. However, I've done it for the privacy features
by simias 16y ago
I am not a Google fanboy, actually I've been using duckduckgo for a couple of weeks as my default search engine. However, I've done it for the privacy features of ddg, not because I think google search "sucks" more than it used to.
Maybe I'm blind. Maybe I don't pay enough attention. Maybe I just use my search engine differently than most (or at least than those who seem to complain a lot lately) but I fail to find a concrete example where google (or ddg for that matter) gives me results that are obviously "wrong" (whatever that means).
I think we've all learned to speak "google". When you query a search engine you don't speak english. You don't ask (or do you?) "I want articles concerning java on the android platform on the hacker news website". Instead, you say "site:news.ycombinator.com android java". And most of the time I get what I want. Maybe I'm more easily satisfied than most. At any rate, these days it's important to learn this language to effectively use any search engine.
In this particular article, the author states that searching for "iPod Connectivity" doesn't yield much results that "actually answer your query". My question is: as a human being, what kind of results do you expect when you search for "iphone connectivity"?
I'm not playing dumb. Is there one good way to interpret this query? Are you shopping? Are you looking for specs? What kind of connectivity are you looking for anyway?
I did the query just now. The third link targets apple.com, the fifth amazon.com. The rest is a bunch of websites doing reviews or selling iphone parts. I can't really judge if those site are legit or not, some do look fishy. But at any rate, why do you say they are "bad answers"?
I do have my gripes with google. Expertexchange used to be a huge pain in the ass, but it's mostly gone these days (probably more thanks to stackoverflow than google, that's for sure). Google has also _never given me any results on google groups even if it will gladly give me some ad-ridden usenet mirror. I think Google has effectively contributed to destroy usenet that way.
It seems people want google to answer queries such as "What phone should I buy?" and have google give the right answer in the first link. It seems some people took the church of google a little too literally. The day Google knows how to answer that it will probably follow up by sending a mechanical Schwarzenegger clone back in time to kill bill gates' mother.
To sum it up: of course Google may want to fight even more the various adfarms out there, but before you criticize the answer, ask yourself if you've asked the good question.
- numbchuckskills 16y ago"Maybe I just use my search engine differently than most" You definitely do. The majority of consumers tend to ask very broad questions.
- chopsueyar 16y agoI agree with your notion of Google contributing to the destruction of usenet.
- quanticle 16y agoI think we've all learned to speak "google". When you query a search engine you don't speak english. You don't ask (or do you?) "I want articles concerning java on the android platform on the hacker news website". Instead, you say "site:news.ycombinator.com android java". And most of the time I get what I want. Maybe I'm more easily satisfied than most. At any rate, these days it's important to learn this language to effectively use any search engine. You've learned to speak "Google". The majority of the world hasn't. My mom, for example, would search for "how to bake apple pie", rather than "apple pie baking" or any other such set of key terms. In fact, your approach reminds me of the approach that I used with AltaVista (back when it was the premier search engine). The reason I used this approach is because I was taught to do this by one of my teachers. Back then, it was recognized that search engines don't recognize human language and that search queries had to be carefully crafted to return optimal results. Of course, very few people think about that now. No one spends time crafting a search query - they just type their question into the Google box and click search. As Google search results decline in quality we might see a resurrection of the old way of thinking about and crafting search queries to return the optimal result set.