2 ms·
Can one of the internet lawyers out there explain why this is a civil lawsuit, and not a criminal lawsuit? I'd think that if he committed an actual crime, it w
by reaperducer 7y ago
Can one of the internet lawyers out there explain why this is a civil lawsuit, and not a criminal lawsuit?
I'd think that if he committed an actual crime, it would be a criminal suit. I thought civil suits were for people trying to get money out of each other.
Or is this like how the feds couldn't get Al Capone for murder so they put him away for tax evasion?
- larkeith 7y agoThere is already a separate criminal suit; this one is just trying to prevent him from profiting from his book, due to it (allegedly) containing intelligence info and violating his NDA. From the link: "This lawsuit is separate from the criminal charges brought against Snowden for his alleged disclosures of classified information. This lawsuit is a civil action, and based solely on Snowden’s failure to comply with the clear pre-publication review obligations included in his signed non-disclosure agreements. "
- reaperducer 7y agoIf I buy the book, does that make me a criminal accessory? Or guilty of the receipt of stolen property (information)?
- larkeith 7y ago"The United States’ lawsuit does not seek to stop or restrict the publication or distribution of Permanent Record." So presumably not.
- henryfjordan 7y agoNo. Classified Info laws only apply to people who are authorized to have that info in the first place. This is why the US went after Snowden but not the journalists he worked with, as they broke no laws. You also do not have an NDA with the government (I assume) and so owe them nothing but taxes.
- bdcravens 7y ago> Or is this like how the feds couldn't get Al Capone for murder so they put him away for tax evasion? No, both of those were crimes. They just incarcerated him on the one with the easiest case to convict. Civil cases are often contractual cases. He had access to confidential information; they are essentially suing him for violating an NDA.
- codeddesign 7y agoI especially like the fact that he can’t fly back to the US since he has no passport, but at the same time he is being prosecuted. It’s been so long, why even care? Who is running the show on this?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- logfromblammo 7y agoBecause no criminal charge that rests solely upon openly publishing facts would ever stand up against the 1st Amendment. Before any cleared individual ever touches or sees classified materials, they sign an NDA that establishes personal responsibility for protecting classified material. This is separate and distinct from the criminal espionage and treason consequences, but they do their best to make you think they are closely tied with the training materials. As it happens, openly publishing as a protected right is hugely different from the criminal act of selling or gifting secrets to a foreign adversary, so a civil suit is all they can do. And given that it is a civil suit, Snowden would have a reasonable shot at an "unclean hands" defense, if the judges were truly impartial and objective.
- LatteLazy 7y agoA criminal charge has no effect as he can't actually be brought back for trial and can't be tried in his absence. If you sue someone, you can serve their intermediaries (his bank or publisher etc). So then the case can proceed. By getting a judgement they can seize US book revenues. Its a pretty cheap move imho but I think that's the logic: if you can't do something at least look like you're doing something.