5 ms·
I've said this before, but the "Internet of Things" is a bad vision for the future. Dystopian, almost. I don't want every little thing to be a computer running
by modeless 7y ago
I've said this before, but the "Internet of Things" is a bad vision for the future. Dystopian, almost. I don't want every little thing to be a computer running software that is buggy, out of date, insecure, out of my control, and constantly pestering me for updates.
What I want is one smart device: a robot that can operate all my non-smart devices. The robot can set the thermostat, unlock the door, flip the light switches, do the laundry and the dishes, monitor the house while I'm away, etc. That's the goal we should be working towards. IoT should be seen as, at best, a stopgap solution. It's not a desirable end state.
- pcunite 7y agoLove this. To use computer terminology, kinda like having a mainframe in the home that is connected to devices it controls? I think that is a far better and user friendly design. Also personal clouds backed up by corporate clouds if desired.
- dekalbcountyman 7y agoI'm working on something like this right now. Dockerized and runs on local dedicated server (Mac Mini, Old Windows Desktop -> Linux Server) You mind emailing me at wow.its.nothing@gmail.com if you could you like to talk about this more?
- dekalbcountyman 7y agoI'm working on something on this exactly. Do you mind emailing me at wow.its.nothing@gmail.com?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI kinda do this with a Raspberry Pi currently using OpenHAB on OpenHabianPi[0]. I was going to link it all up with Mycroft[1] but I havent setup my own version of Mycroft just yet. I might just buy one to support the project. Up next is security cameras using MotionEyeOS[2] and Raspberry Pi Zero W's. You really don't have to pay millions of dollars to automate your home. My thermostats use technology called Z-Wave for which there is a USB[3] adapter available on Amazon, for about $45 I turned 2 different Thermostats into Nest-like thermostats that I fully control myself, if my pi dies, the usb device still has them synched. All in my house, all in my control and managed by yours truly. [0]: https://www.openhab.org/docs/installation/openhabian.html#raspberry-pi-prepackaged-sd-card-image https://www.openhab.org/docs/installation/openhabian.html#ra... [1]: https://mycroft.ai/ https://mycroft.ai/ [2]: https://github.com/ccrisan/motioneyeos https://github.com/ccrisan/motioneyeos [3]: https://www.amazon.com/Aeotec-Z-Stick-Z-Wave-create-gateway/dp/B00X0AWA6E https://www.amazon.com/Aeotec-Z-Stick-Z-Wave-create-gateway/... Final thought: If I ever get Mycroft setup, I'd essentially have a robot in my home running off a Raspberry Pi. He wouldn't move (wouldn't need him to) but he would do whatever I wish. For now openHAB has a UI for me. Edit: Forgot to mention that openHAB is also scriptable, and even has a bit of IFTTT type of capacity internally.
- jp555 7y agoSounds like you want a multi-generational household. My household recently became multi-generational and it's really great! Feels like this is what it's supposed to be like.
- chopin 7y agoBut that's a low-tech solution. Why have a simple solution while you can have a complex one, which sucks as a bonus. Oh, and spies on you.
- EvanAnderson 7y agoHere's the utopia I'd love: The thermostat / door lock / light would present a simple documented interface exposing all the functionality available from the physical device. I'd even be okay if it was delivered via Wi-Fi or ZigBee (though I'd really prefer RS-488, RS-232, or wired Ethernet w/ PoE). No manufacturer will do this because it limits their ability to engineer-in planned obsolescence, vendor lock-in, and recurring revenue "cloud" business models. There are commercial and industrial-grade devices that do what I want, but they're priced for their market segment and, infuriatingly, their protocols are needlessly baroque (MODBUS, BACNET, et. al.) or proprietary.
- leppr 7y agoWe need the Unix philosophy in the physical world. Our multitude of small devices themselves can stay "dumb", but it'd be a huge missed opportunity to totally cut them off from the software world. A robot turning knobs and pushing buttons as grandparent seems to suggest is a romantic vision that doesn't hold up well to the real world.
- dngray 7y ago> What I want is one smart device: a robot that can operate all my non-smart devices. The robot can set the thermostat, unlock the door, flip the light switches, do the laundry and the dishes, monitor the house while I'm away, etc. Sounds like what you need is a https://www.deviantart.com/plank-69/art/Mr-Handy-Advert-Fallout-4-573980730 https://www.deviantart.com/plank-69/art/Mr-Handy-Advert-Fall... https://ilyanazarov.com/projects/X21AL https://ilyanazarov.com/projects/X21AL
- noja 7y agoI want a standard package for IoT stuff: a smaller form factor Pi Zero with battery and connectivity running a normal OS.