5 ms·
In a similar vein: There was a Japanese TV program a few years ago testing talented youngsters. One brain teaser was "On this table you have six match sticks
by patio11 16y ago
In a similar vein:
There was a Japanese TV program a few years ago testing talented youngsters. One brain teaser was "On this table you have six match sticks of equal length. Arrange them such that you create four triangles."
The match sticks are presented lying flat on a table, and approximately everyone tries to solve the problem in 2D and fails hideously. The right answer, which is a peculiar kind of perverse clever that math teams and startups are fond of, is to make a triangle on the plane and then point the last three match heads upwards from the vertices, creating a pyramid. Each of its four faces is a triangle. Half of the wunderkids got this right.
One kid ran out of time and didn't get it. After being shown the 3D solution, he skipped the next problem entirely and would only say "It works in 2D, it works in 2D, I know it works in 2D" and continue playing with his match sticks.
He eventually solved it halfway through the next problem, confounding the host because his solution was not written in the notes: make two triangles in the plane, flip one, and arrange them to form a Star of David. (Nobody here would call it that, but I'm assuming most HNers know what one looks like.)
Quote the kid: You said I had to make four triangles, but you never said anything about the fifth, sixth, seventh, or eighth.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThere's a better way than a star of David, that gets you exactly 4 triangles in 2d using 6 matchsticks.
- shard 16y agoDo you mean a box with an x through it? I guess the rules never said the ends of the matchsticks had to match up either. I'm definitely enjoying all these different answers which explore (exploit?) the imprecisely specified problem.
- zck 16y agoThat's still more than four triangles -- two right triangles next to each other that way make a larger triangle. One way to make only four triangles is: \ / \ / -------\----/------ \1 / \/ /\ \ / \ / \ / 2 \ / ---\---/------\----/- \3/ \4 / \ \/ / \ /\ / \ / \
- nooneelse 16y agoOk, so make a box with an incomplete x in the middle, a "y", by only sticking that one match partway into the square. \ \---- |\ /| | \/ | | / | |/ | ----
- anigbrowl 16y agoNo. Sorry to reply so late, I posted so early this morning I forgot about it during the day. | | /|\ / | \ / / \ \ // \\ /---------\ / \ / \ Argh, that's ugly. In case it's not clear, 3 matches in an upward-pointing triangle, 3 making an upside-down Y shape, the former on top of the latter so there's one large triangle trisected into 3 smaller internal triangles. Or it's the 3d tetrahedron solution squashed flat if you want to think about it that way. The cheat is that you've abandoned consistent shape and area for all triangles, plus there's the 'legs' sticking out if you're concerned about geometric efficiency.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- AaronM 16y agothe way I read the instructions is that you have to create exactly 4 triangles.