3 ms·
The irony of your comment is that the whole point of showing Melinda was to illustrate how she has it relatively easy, and how much more difficult the woman fro
by dahart 7y ago
The irony of your comment is that the whole point of showing Melinda was to illustrate how she has it relatively easy, and how much more difficult the woman from Sahel has it.
The gender part of that graph wasn’t trying to say Melinda herself has it very hard, it was only saying that Melinda is a woman, and statistically speaking on a global scale, being a woman is an obstacle. Both of those things are true, and the article discusses why.
- seph-reed 7y ago> statistically speaking on a global scale, being a woman is an obstacle I think it's important to add the concept of "financial," "independence," or "power" somewhere in here. AFAICT, these are the only things that matter to people, so it's a pretty big deal to have your sex/gender be an obstacle towards them. But the overall equation of happiness has a bit more variables. Ultimately, I meet (on average) about the same amount of unhappy men as women, so from a happiness perspective it would appear that neither men nor women are winning and focusing on money and power instead of well-being is short sighted. Like maybe we should quit arguing which gender gets the most money and try to figure out what makes a human happy.
- dahart 7y ago> maybe we should quit arguing which gender gets the most money and try to figure out what makes a human happy. That's a bit of a straw man, I didn't argue money primarily, and neither does the article. The article is talking about self-determinism, education, and opportunity for women, not money or power specifically. These things are all well known to be of primary importance to happiness. From the article: "the average woman spends more than four hours every day doing unpaid work. Men, by comparison, average just over one hour per day." How do you feel personally about doing unpaid labor? > I meet (on average) about the same amount of unhappy men as women, so from a happiness perspective it would appear that neither men nor women are winning and focusing on money and power instead of well-being is short sighted. That's purely anecdotal and has no bearing on what is happening in the world to people outside your class & geographical region. Drawing a global conclusion about gender inequality based on your personal experience is a pretty bad idea.
- seph-reed 7y ago> self-determinism, education, and opportunity for women, not money Those look a lot more like money and power than happiness. As a counter point, I might list "community" or "the right to express ones thoughts and emotions" if I was going for the happiness > money angle. > How do you feel personally about doing unpaid labor? I do quite a bit of community service, and offer help to anyone who's following their dreams. Unpaid labor is an important part of a functional society. Once again, not everything needs to revolve around money. > Drawing a global conclusion about gender inequality based on your personal experience is a pretty bad idea. Yeah, but drawing a conclusion based off data that doesn't equate to happiness is equally meaningless. Nobody is having a great time and we're fighting over breadcrumbs. It's like a bunch of homeless people infighting over panhandling inequality. As if panhandling is the way it should be, it's just not equal enough.
- dahart 7y agoThe article isn't talking about good-will volunteer service, and I'm certain you already know that, please don't try to twist words and be intentionally misleading. I'm struggling to understand what point you're making now. Nobody from here up the thread said everything revolves around money except for you, it's still a straw man argument. > drawing a conclusion about gender inequality that doesn't equate to happiness is equally meaningless First, there is no objective measure for happiness, so you're suggesting something that's impossible. Second, I disagree that failing to boil down to happiness is meaningless, as do many world economists and social researchers. Economic measures absolutely do correlate with happiness at the poor end of the economic spectrum. https://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/IWP_2016_23.pdf https://www.unicef-irc.org/publications/pdf/IWP_2016_23.pdf More broadly, oppression of women is a global fact of history. It's better now in the U.S. and Europe, and I'm glad it's improving, but I really don't get this argument you're attempting to make that it somehow doesn't exist, or that women are just seeking power and money. It's making your comments seem rather ignorant of history. Gender inequality is well documented, well known and widely agreed to exist, especially in Africa, China, the Middle East, etc.
- 7y ago