4 ms·
I wonder what the solution is here. To expose people to this stuff continuously seems wrong. Then again so does exposing everyone to it / would probabbly kill
by duxup 7y ago
I wonder what the solution is here.
To expose people to this stuff continuously seems wrong.
Then again so does exposing everyone to it / would probabbly kill the service if it wasn't dealt with by someone.
Another concern is finding people who can handle these situations in a healthy way, might be few and far between, and generally the folks exposed to it folks hired into low pay / outsourced warm bodies in chairs kinda situations.
- Grangar 7y agoKeep things small and community-moderated. Keeping social networks self-moderated in a small community, say a city, would quickly ostracise people sharing this sort of thing.
- duxup 7y agoCommunity moderation is a pretty amorphous concept... not really sure how that would work out. Reddit is a pretty good example of it both working, and very much not working.
- Grangar 7y agoI mean physically small. In my view much of the mess the internet is seeing right now is because of the lack of local/real-world consequences. Links between people are now on a global spider-web scale, so to say. Whereas it used to be on a local neighbourhood-city level scale. This gives way to a separate space decoupled from your local environment. If a community is (relatively) tight-knit on a physical scale sharing repulsive content or blatant propaganda could have a real-world consequence and definitely wouldn't get the reach it has right now. It's not the pipe dream of what the internet was supposed to be back in the 90's, but I think it's safe to say that experiment has failed. Humanity has shown itself not to be able to behave itself enough for this. I'm sorry if this sounds abstract or convoluted or anything, I've had a long day and am a bit brain-fried but I have thought pretty extensively about this. I'm having a bit of a hard time putting it down in a HN comment. Maybe it's worth the effort writing this up.
- Kalium 7y agoI've done a lot of community moderation in my life. It's been my experience that making things smaller and replacing professional moderation with volunteer moderation is rarely as effective as might be hoped for. Further, once you get past Dunbar's number (about 150), you get the semi-anonymous effect that enables abuses of social networks, much like real cities. There is also a potential wrinkle where people can easily migrate from one forum to another. Taken together, unless you keep people from migrating from one petty dictatorship to another to find one they like, the outcome will tend towards a small number of big megalopolis-style communities and a middling number of mid-size ones. It's not a bad idea by any means. It's essentially a mirror of an idealized pre-industrial agrarian society. There might be some wrinkles added by basic human behavior patters that could be worth considering carefully is all.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoWhat if the answer is to kill social-media-as-we-know-it? There are some sick and "extremist" people in this world. If their stage were relegated to email threads I imagine we would not be having this discussion. But I think what bothers me the most, and this is eluded to in the article, is not that some extremist is posting crap, no surprise there. But that seemingly once-normal relatives of mine are consuming this crap and then reposting it — becoming the extremists themselves.
- veidr 7y ago> What if the answer is to kill social-media-as-we-know-it? The answer obviously is that. But the questions is, what if we can't? (Spoiler alert: we can't.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shantly 7y ago> What if the answer is to kill social-media-as-we-know-it? This is the real answer. If running a service requires paying people to look at awful, damaging material—stop running the service. It shouldn't exist. It doesn't need to. Absent things like Twitter and Facebook we'd find other ways to keep in touch with people who matter. Special Email clients that do most of the friends & family stuff that FB does but over email or whatever. Some new protocol. Progress on that kind of stuff only stalled because we've got the spyvertising- or VC-funded, moderator-harming services to compete with. Take those away and the void will be filled, with hardly a hiccup. "Well gee whiz we just can't run our service without doing this to our moderators, so I guess we have to"—no, you don't, period, at all. You can stop running your service, or live with hurting people and stop acting like you care.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoI would suck as a CEO. The first time someone live-streamed an attack/rape/murder on my platform I would pull the live feature.
- pjc50 7y agoIn the long term, the solution would have to be real consequences for those posting it.