5 ms·
He was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. That is what he was defe
by colechristensen 7y ago
He was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island.
That is what he was defending. The intellectual quibbles about this and that he was bringing up are irrelevant when faced with the above fact.
That isn't about political correctness, it isn't a "witch hunt". RMS did something incredibly inappropriate in an incredibly inappropriate place and was fired. He deserved it.
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoMinsky is accused, with no hard evidence. RMS is likely correct that Minsky did not know the girl's age or that she had been coerced. So, assuming Minsky did have sex with the girl, he had no way of knowing that what he was doing was illegal, since it was made to appear to him that this was not the case. That would make Minsky somewhat creepy for sleeping with someone so much younger than him, but not culpable morally. If Minsky didn't actually have sex with the girl, than he did nothing wrong at all.
- roenxi 7y agoStallman's defence of Minsky wasn't in his capacity as the FSF President, and his resignation isn't the result of a thoughtful and considered process. This resignation is the result of a witch hunt. The thing about accusations is that being accused of something doesn't mean the thing happened. There is a pretty plausible line of evidence that Minsky kept his hands to himself when confronted by a 17 year old on a private island. It is an excellent time to try and defend a dead friend when such doubts are present. And as a particularly important point - there are no charges so horrible that people shouldn't be defended against them. That is one of the best principles we have in the Western intellectual tradition. "He's defending someone from something serious" is not a respectable counter; you should rethink your arguments.
- colechristensen 7y agoThe issue wasn't him defending a man, not really. The issue was him defending statutory rape by saying the victim would have seemed willing. The cirumstances around that hypothetical (17, 73, billionare's island) solidify the problem. It isn't intellectual disagreement. It's defending rape, real or imagined, by saying the victim seemed willing.
- roenxi 7y agoIf someone honestly thought, and had reason to think, that they were having sex with a willing 18 year old and it turned out days later that they had sex with an unwilling 17 year old then: (1) They have committed statutory rape (2) Their position is morally defensible, although a bit creepy for an old man. He probably didn't know she was 17. Why on earth would Minsky be risking the law by sleeping with a 17 year old girl when he could just sleep with an 18 or 19 year old? Presumably Epstein had all sorts on tap. It is very likely he wasn't told she was 17 and quite likely that if asked she had been coerced into lying. Stallman has a point here. And to top it off even if he is wrong it is not such a critical fact that he needs to resign over it. Even if I accept tomorrow that everything I typed today so far was wrong; this is still not an important enough point to resign over anything. It is a moral hypothetical. It is no relevant to my, or Stallman's, daily personal or professional life.
- JohnStrangeII 7y agoThat's not what happened, no matter how often you repeat your mantra. First of all, Minsky didn't agree to the offer, as evidenced by eye-witnesses. So there was probably no rape in any case, although there could have been one at another time and another party. For all that RMS and you can know, there was none. Second, nobody of the invited people had credible reasons to believe that the girl was underage - Epstein did not tell that to people he invited, for obvious reasons. For all that they could know, she was a young prostitute or a billionaire's "groupy." This is not uncommon at parties of insanely rich people, and Epstein was known for it. Whether you personally like that or not is irrelevant. Read some AMA's by sex workers to understand how this works in reality, you can find plenty of them on Reddit. RMS also defended the view that declaring every sexual act of an adult with a 17 year old as statutory rape is morally questionable. That's a legitimate viewpoint that has been discussed extensively by lawmakers and legal scholars. Again, whether you like his opinion or not is not important. What's important is that it is ridiculous to insinuate in any way that discussing these matters is somehow morally reprehensible, especially when they concern accusations of a good friend who - for all you know and believe - is innocent. You are being very dishonest in your posts by distorting the actual situation and what actually happened. I've personally met a guy who lost his job and all of his reputation for a similar matter - every single accusation was ruled out and disproved in court, even with direct video evidence contradicting the accuser's testimony, yet his life remains in shambles. You can only hope that you will never become the victim of such a witch hunt yourself.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 7y agoPart of being in a leadership role is not offending carelessly speaking on topics that will bring bad might onto your organization. RMS has been a force that has driven people away for a long time. He may be good as a thinker and coder, but he is fucking awful at being in a leadership position.
- mymythisisthis 7y agoHe's defending his friend who went to a brothel, there is nothing wrong with sex for money. Maybe if the USA didn't make it so hard to run a brothel less craziness would happen.
- afiori 7y agoHe was not defending Minsky, he argued that the crime (which he states he had no reason to deny) as described was not "assault". His statement was that we should use proper names for crimes. If I were to accuse Epstein of genocide and you reply "That is not genocide, he was a sex-trafficking pedophile that used minors as blackmailing pawns and more" would that be a defense? It does not look like a defense to me.
- DanBC 7y ago> He was not defending Minsky, he argued that the crime (which he states he had no reason to deny) as described was not "assault". But he was wrong about English usage and about legal usage of the word "assault". When we're talking about a child who has been trafficked and coerced into sex it's weird to "well actually, is it really assault?" into the conversation, especially if that's based on his misunderstanding of what the word means. And the effect of his interject was to defend Minsky. When hundreds of people misinterpret him the blame lies with his poor communication, not their lack of comprehension.
- afiori 7y agoThen I apologize on my understanding of the English language. According to the quote I read of RMS (I did not read the original email fully) the salient part is his discussion where he claims that "sexual assault" as an expression (at least colloquially) implies the use of force/violence/aggression/intimidation/coercion/etc. by Minsky. He claims that given the official report as true and taking the the claim of the victim as correct none of those (force/violence/aggression/intimidation/coercion/etc.) were likely. This is independent on whether Minsky committed a crime or not. This is simply trying to properly understand what the accusations are. I honestly have no idea whether this would constitute rape/statutory rape/assault or any other crime, taking in goodwill what I have read it is likely that whatever happened (other witnesses claim to have seen Minsky decline the advances and the report does not claim any sexual encounter, "just" that Epstein instructed her to) Minsky did not use violence. I actually believe I misrepresented RMS words here, as he truly only said that the violence implied by the word assault was unlikely. (Also given that by other reports one of Epstein tactics was to lure guests into having sex with minors to blackmail them)
- marble-drink 7y ago> He was defending his friend who, at the age of 74, is accused of having sex with a 17 year old girl on a billionaire's private island. Where I live (the UK), that is perfectly legal and I believe any man would jump at the chance to do the same with a willing 17 year old. Your repetitive statements of fact in this thread look like nothing more than jealousy to me.
- ajnin 7y agoWhy is it wrong to defend someone that is accused of something ? Does an accusation equate to culpability ? Should we ban lawyers and move all court cases directly to sentencing without defense arguments ? This total abdication of reason and emotionally led behavior in the face of certain words put on someone is quite frightening.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]