3 ms·
> One has to have the right opinion or stay quiet. I don't really see how this is so hard. Don't treat women poorly, in person or online. Don't talk authorit
by kelnos 7y ago
> One has to have the right opinion or stay quiet.
I don't really see how this is so hard. Don't treat women poorly, in person or online. Don't talk authoritatively about subjects you don't understand, especially when those subjects (like rape and human trafficking) cause people intense pain.
If you really do want to act this way, then you probably should exercise some self-censorship, and rethink your views, perhaps.
> ...in what we can say without facing consequences.
What you say should have consequences. No one should censor you (what you say should be up to you), but you don't live in a vacuum. What you say has a real effect on others, and if that effect is bad, you should be held accountable.
- noobermin 7y agoHow does one learn what is wrong unless they speak out? You have to give people room to grow and forgive them when they fail.
- Faark 7y agoYes, people have to grow to not be stupid assholes. On the other side, if people think you're a stupid asshole, they should be allowed to cut off contact. Thus you probably want to avoid growing in the only global circle we have. With smaller circles, getting cut off (as always has happened) is less of big deal. In a similar vein, I'm fine with scientists exploring "IQ of the races" in their work. But going on a podcast and sharing that with a more general audience while not understanding its role in broader society while washing concerns away with "this just facts" is fine to have consequences.
- concordDance 7y agoYou seem to be advocating keeping the public ignorant. Presumably this only applies in cases the knowledge in question is an instance of the adage "a little bit of knowledge is a dangerous thing"? Do you think having norms that advocate hiding knowledge that someone could argue is dangerous from the public will do more good than harm and won't backfire in the form of public distrust of experts?
- kelnos 7y agoYou learn by first listening, and asking questions. No one expects everyone to be perfect out of the gate, but you at least have to make an effort.
- reirob 7y agoI think that in general animals and people learn most efficiently by making mistakes. Sure, I am talking about mistakes that do not kill us. But even mistakes that kill, have hopefully a learning effect on those who observe. I think as well that we as a society should learn to be more empathic, more tolerant, to learn how to forgive, and to avoid mob judgements. Both, are my opinions. I don't know if there are any studies or references to this.
- tomd3v 7y agoYou learn by discussing.
- kelnos 7y agoSure, that's what "listening and asking questions" is. But in the beginning, when you know very little, your default should be to absorb, not to espouse.
- Kye 7y agoEasy: don't speak authoritatively. Acknowledge the limits of your knowledge and invite better information from people who know better. I would advise not speaking authoritatively even if you are an authority. People are less likely to offer suggestions and ideas you didn't consider if you act like you know what you're talking about. I learn all kinds of things by not sounding as certain as I usually am. ...they said, authoritatively. I'm a work in progress.
- drcode 7y ago> Don't talk authoritatively about subjects you don't understand No one is allowed to have an opinion unless they're an "expert" (Sarcasm)
- madmulita 7y agoYou are right! Maybe we should start an experts registry, so there is no confusion about who can speak.
- kelnos 7y agoI get that you're being sarcastic, but... yes? It's fine to talk about topics where you're not an expert, but if you want to talk authoritatively about something, yes, I'd expect something at least approaching expert level.
- ThrowawayR2 7y agoThen, pray tell, what qualifies you to state your authoritative opinion on what we are permitted to talk about? We would like to see your credentials. /s
- kelnos 7y agoI mean, I'm posting on HN so clearly I'm an expert in... oh... damn.
- finnthehuman 7y ago>Don't talk authoritatively about subjects you don't understand Then it's time to just shut down HN in general, eh?
- KaiserPro 7y agoI'll have you know I'm an expert, I'll stake my [imaginary] PhD on it.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 7y agoI don't really see how this is so hard. Don't treat women poorly, in person or online. Don't talk authoritatively about subjects you don't understand, especially when those subjects (like rape and human trafficking) cause people intense pain. Morality is constantly changing and what is considered treating someone poorly changes too. More recently it appears to be changing faster than ever. That can make it hard to remain with the bounds of what is in the current instance of time considered socially acceptable by the majority. There is no absolute morality even though it may seem like it if you are thinking with the span of an hour or a day. Stretch it out and it's a constant shifting. In any case, I don't think anyone should be silenced. If they say something that the majority feels is foolish, they can be considered a fool, or a debate can be had to convince them of why they may be wrong, but to silence externally, or increasingly, self silencing with self censorship, in my opinion is dangerous as that means ideas cannot be discussed openly.
- dangerface 7y ago> What you say has a real effect on others, and if that effect is bad, you should be held accountable. Speech is just a tool to share a thought, if a thought effects some one it is for them to bare alone. The idea that sharing thoughts should have consequences upsets me greatly, maybe it shouldn't but it does. Your speech has filled me with bad feelings and troubling thoughts is that burden mine to bare alone or should I hold you responsible? The sword you are flailing is sharp at both ends.