6 ms·
Linus eventually realised that his abuse of contributors was a negative contribution and agreed to change. RMS has .. not got to that point. Neither of them se
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Linus eventually realised that his abuse of contributors was a negative contribution and agreed to change. RMS has .. not got to that point.
Neither of them seems hugely socially savvy. Perhaps someone/something helped Linus get there and RMS hasn't had a similar experience.
- pjc50 7y agoThere was an "intervention" where a group of long-time colleagues and senior kernel contributors took Linus off and told him their dissatisfaction in person.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoMeanwhile, some angry woman publicly calls for Stallman's removal and it seems we've gone with that. And are acting like the outcome here is entirely due to Stallman being an asshole.
- pjc50 7y agoI don't think she's the first person to object to his behaviour. I've seen a few more people posting their stories of objectionable behaviour, but I'm reluctant to point HN at them. Edit: a list of complaints over years: https://geekfeminism.wikia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman https://geekfeminism.wikia.org/wiki/Richard_Stallman Edit: at the risk of targeting people for harassment by HN commentators, some personal stories from Twitter. Apparently people kept houseplants to ward off RMS: https://twitter.com/starsandrobots/status/994267630457401344 https://twitter.com/starsandrobots/status/994267630457401344
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIrrelevant to my point. Linus was told by trusted insiders "Get your act together" and he apparently took that to heart. And RMS is being removed as a consequence of the angry actions of a woman who didn't even know who he was: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20993364 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20993364 Edit: I wish you wouldn't do something that you feel puts other people at risk just to back up your point. Especially since you seem to think you have the moral high ground. You are happy to throw other people under a bus to win an internet argument. Some angry woman who admits her screed wasn't really about RMS per se threw him under a bus. And you're fine with it. Because you seem to think that's morally acceptable if you have some kind of justification. Social outcomes aren't about the actions of a single person. They are about the cumulative consequences of the actions of many people. How people choose to respond to problematic behavior is part of that -- and often not in a good way.
- pjc50 7y agoIf those are to be counted as "throwing someone under a bus", then what about the person allegedly assaulted by Minsky? Isn't RMS also "throwing her under a bus" to win an internet argument? > How people choose to respond to problematic behavior is part of that -- and often not in a good way. Well, yes. There don't seem to be any good answers here. Handling it privately is not at all reliable and may result in the complainer getting privately blacklisted. Going public can be effective, but only if you make a major storm - the outcomes of which can no longer be controlled. We don't know if people have tried to get RMS to get his act together. But this doesn't seem to be a first complaint out of nowhere.
- kelnos 7y agoIt's pretty irrelevant whether or not she knew who RMS was before all this. She found out about him, did her research, and uncovered some pretty messed up stuff.
- rmc 7y agopeople have complained about RMS in this regard for a long time
- kelnos 7y ago"Some angry woman" also listed several examples of bad behavior reported to her by multiple sources, dating back decades. While a lot of it was new to me, it's nearly impossible that this wasn't known by people at MIT and/or the FSF who could have acted in the past, but didn't. IMO this was a long time coming, not some brand-new thing.
- bigbugbag 7y agoExamples that came as an afterthought after admitting this was not about Stallman and misrepresenting his words. She did not correct her misrepresentation but instead went on to publish in an appendix what had been dugged and nitpicked to paint RMS in a way that fit her narrative. the appendix is easy to debunk: 1 can be summarized as RMS has opinions, his personal opinions not being the same as the majority means they are problematic (use a reversal of burden of proof fallacy in the process). Goes on to says that institutions/companies that do not remove people with personal opinions different from the majority should be removed from the institutions otherwise it should be interpreted that the institutions themselves support those opinions. Of course totally overlooks the fact if instead of public shaming, calling for witch hunt and not talking with the person, having a fact-based conversation with the person about his/her opinion could be enough to change this opinion as had happened here: https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#14_September_2019_(Sex_between_an_adult_and_a_child_is_wrong) https://stallman.org/archives/2019-jul-oct.html#14_September... 2 is a collection of applying today standard to 40 years old society, expectation of normal behaviour to someone in the autistic spectrum and leaving the reader to fill the holes when the reason for having a mattress in his office and being proud of it is long documented and unrelated to the sexual framing attempt. Then she presents a 1983 report pointing how it was for women is CS at MIT at the time which makes no mention of RMS in any way but is nevertheless add as charge to him. 3. Goes on to put RMS in the same bag with Epstein, and mentions #metoo as if RMS had been mentioned in it with no explanation and no evidence. Rants about MIT and calls for other institutions to go on witch hunts on threat of chaos such as the one she just caused. 4. is about her personal life and how she felt in social context trying to diminish her efforts and accomplishment, how she is desensitized and prepared for escalation from Stallman but disappointed that he did not and instead went on to apologize. Unhappy with the apology and impervious to the fact that she is responsible and the cause for the misunderstanding and the media coverage, she uses this apology as a call to other people to take her action as a model and fight the powerful people. So as a whole this appendix is really not more evidence that the original author missed the point and further attacked a wrongly perceived threat and as a result polarized further against RMS and her.
- lazyjones 7y agoThese comparisons aren't helping. Linus was always factually right (at least overwhelmingly so) and his issue was the aggressive tone in his communication, which was understandably wrong and counterproductive. RMS is being accused of having wrong opinions, defending the wrong people and not being part of the SJW zombie mob that shouts down saner opinions on social media. He has no good reason to change his opinion, he just lost a stupid popularity contest.
- TheBranca18 7y agoSo wait, based on what I'm reading in this post, a saner opinion is getting into a debate about the definition of the words sexual assault on a mailing list? I understand people thinking there is a right way and a wrong way to express disillusionment with a particular person, however, what you're doing here is misleading at best. I'm not really sure why you're expressing derision towards people that don't want sexual assault trivialized. I dunno, I feel like reading these types of posts, which are prevalent in this thread, that I have less and less in common with people on Hacker News. Also it's not a bad thing to want social justice, no matter how many times you type SJW.
- bigbugbag 7y agoyou seem to assume there was assault from Minsky on Giufre, and I wonder where you get that idea. I'm part of the people who do not want sexual assault trivialized and for that to happen not making inconsiderate use of the term is important to not strip it of its meaning. After having read the court documentation, I have yet to see any evidence that Minsky assaulted Giufre, heck there's not even any indication he did have sex with her, only that she was directed to by Ms. Maxwell.
- mantas 7y agoRMS tried to do opposite of trivialising - to get facts straight and put proper blame on each person involved. Everyone includes justice. Including bad actors who shouldn't be blamed for what they didn't do. Judging everyone for they actually did is the true social justice.
- smacktoward 7y ago> I've spent a lot of time working with [RMS] to help him understand why various positions he holds are harmful. I've reached the conclusion that it's not that he's unable to understand, he's just unwilling to change his mind. — Matthew Garrett (https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/52587.html https://mjg59.dreamwidth.org/52587.html)