3 ms·
I said nothing of the sort. I simply said that the first amendment is not involved in this case, in reply to someone who said it was.
by dangrossman 16y ago
I said nothing of the sort. I simply said that the first amendment is not involved in this case, in reply to someone who said it was.
- _delirium 16y agoThe fact that Sony is bringing the case doesn't really stand in the way, because the DMCA is a government law, so must respect the First Amendment. The government is the one prohibiting certain kinds of activities, via a law passed by Congress; the fact that the DMCA's enforcement mechanism is suits by private parties doesn't change that. Via the DMCA, the U.S. government prohibits "dissemination" of "technology, devices, or services" designed to circumvent copy-protection systems. The first-amendment generally doesn't allow the government to prohibit "dissemination" of things that qualify as "speech", so the open question is whether any of the things being prohibited qualify. (Universal v. Reimerdes, one of the DeCSS cases, upheld the DMCA against a similar challenge, so it's an uphill battle. A stronger case would probably be an attempt to suppress a cryptography-research paper via the DMCA, since publishing papers is the kind of activity usually assumed to be protected by the First Amendment. There've been a few potential test cases of that sort, but the plaintiffs seem to always back down before they get to a ruling.)
- stcredzero 16y agoMaybe a professor should coauthor a paper with geohot?